EG CYOA #5 Harem:3 IWTCIRD

>It had been about a month since your escapade at Pinkie's big party
>Ever since then, Pinkie has begun joining you, Sunset Shimmer, and Twilight for lunch and weekly after-school fun
>You paid for your lunch, and made your way to your usual table, where the three girls were already sitting
>Sunset Shimmer smiled as you approached, and motioned for you to take the seat next to her
>"Hey Anon," she said warmly
>She gave you a quick peck on the lips, and you put your arm around her
>Sunset's belly was now giving away the fact that she was pregnant, and your small group were now her only remaining friends as gossip spread throughout the school
>"Ooh, this is so exciting you guys!" Pinkie exclaimed
>"I'm not so sure. I feel like this group is big enough as it is..." Twilight said
>You all turn to look at a distant table, where Rainbow Dash was eating and talking with her friends
>She glanced over to you, and her smile quickly dissipated before she turned back to her friends
>"We've never really made use of the picture," Sunset said as she looked through her phone
>"Plus, it's always nice to have more friends," she said, giggling
>"Yay friends! C'mon Twi, what's the worst that could happen" Pinkie interjected
>Twilight rolled her eyes and took a bite out of her apple
>The four of you continued to talk and eat until the bell rang, and everyone began moving to their next class
>Your group began to make its way towards Rainbow Dash, who was alone at her locker
>As you near her, she turns to face you, frowning glumly
>You raise your hand to wave at her, but step on one of your shoelaces
>"Fuck!"
>Losing your balance, you fall towards Dash
>She tries to turn away, stepping to the side
>Your hand comes down onto her chest, grabbing onto her petite breasts
>The two of you fall towards the wall of lockers, and Rainbow's face smacks loudly against one
>She yelps, and starts shouting expletives
>"Oh shit, sorry Rainbow," you say, reaching out to help her
>She pushes you away, and you can see a line of blood running down her chin from her nose
>"Dashie!" Pinkie cries as helps her back onto her feet
>After Pinkie helps her onto her feet, Rainbow Dash wipes the blood away from her nose and looks at your with disdain
>"What do you want, Anon?" she snarls
>"I just wanted to talk to you about that picture we took of you," you say
>"Yeah? Look, asshole, this... This just isn't fair! People would look at that and think we were... Doing stuff."
>You chuckle
>"That's the point."
>Dash turns to Twilight and Pinkie
>"Guys, why?"
>"We're sorry Rainbow Dash, but..." Twilight says, trailing off as she turns her face away from Rainbow
>"Look, RD, I'm going to give you a chance to get rid of the pic, and we'll be done. You won't have it hanging over your head anymore."
>She pauses for a few moments
>You can tell she doesn't quite believe you
>"W-What do you want me to do..?"
>"You and me. Rock Off at tonight's Battle of the Bands."
>"What?!"
>"You heard me."
>Dash grumbles
>"Fine. I'll be there."
>You go to the rest of your classes, and the school day finally ends
>Once home, you take out your electric ukulele, and begin practicing
>Your fingers ache as you practice and practice
>The sun begins to fall below the horizon, and you make your way to the Battle of the Bands
>Sunset, Pinkie, and Twilight meet you there, being your vocalist, drummer, and bassist respectively
>You are pumped for the battle at hand
>The first few acts go on, to middling applause
>Then, Rainbow Dash
>She goes on stage, alone, carrying an electric guitar
>Your eyes widen as she begins, her musical prowess far beyond anything you'd expected
>She finishes to riotous applause, walking off stage smugly
>"Beat that, asshole"
>You turn to your band, panicked
>"There's no way we can beat that!" you exclaim, pacing backstage
>"Sure we can, Anon!" Pinkie says with a smile "I know a guy who's no stranger to rock offs!"
>She begins bouncing around, calling out in strange tongues
>Lights flicker, and a wind picks up seemingly out of nowhere
>A low murmur begins to rise around you
>Suddenly, a hand pierces the ground, and a red form pulls itself out of the ground
>"Yay!"
>"Pinkie!" it shouts, "To what do I owe the pleasure?"
>"We need to win a rock off, Satan," she responds
>He rubs his chin, stroking his goatee
>"I know of a song," he says
>Instantly, you feel power coursing through your veins, the knowledge of musics forbidden emblazoned upon your minds
>"AND NEXT, THE NORMALPEOPLE!"
>You walk on stage, looking over the crowd, and you begin to play
>It was the greatest song in the world
>Every hundred thousand years or so, when the sun doth shine and the moon doth glow and the grass doth grow
>You walk off the stage, undisputed champions
>Rainbow Dash's eyes bulge as she sees the four of you comes towards her
>"H-How could I have lost! I summoned Satan and everything..."
>"Oh... Sorry Dashie, Satan and I are really good pals."
>Dash threw her hands up in defeat, and broke down, falling to her knees
>"I'm fucked, aren't I?"
>You laugh
>"Yes you are fucked, shit out of luck. Now I have won, and my cock you will suck."
>You laugh to yourself again, noticing your words seemed almost lyrical, in an odd way
>Sunset Shimmer hangs onto your shoulder, peering over you and down onto Rainbow Dash
>Dash places her hands on your waist and hesitates
>She pushes her hair out of her face, and takes a deep breath
>Her hands shake as she readies to unbutton your pants
>She turns her head upwards, looking at you pleadingly
>"Don't stop now," Sunset says
>Twilight turns away, ashamed
>Rainbow Dash pops open your pants, and unzips them before pulling everything down
>Her eyes widen in shock as she sees your cock
>"Anon... You don't have to do this," Twilight says
>You decide that you've already humiliated Rainbow enough.
>"This would just be pushing it", you think, pulling up your pants
>"I... I'm sorry Rainbow Dash... Look, we'll delete the picture"
>Rainbow's face lights up
>"Aw, you're no fun sometimes, Anon," Sunset says toyingly
>She pulls out her phone, and deletes the picture
>"See, gone"
>"Thanks, guys..." Dash says
>She glances down to your crotch and blushes
>"Well, uh, I guess I'll just go home now..."
>"Wait. You know, you performed pretty awesome today. Why don't we all just hang out at my place?"
>"Ooh, yeah! C'mon Dashie!" Pinkie begs
>She stands still for a few moments
>"Fine, I guess I'll come or something," she says, punctuating her sentence with a fake cough and shifty eyes
>Pinkie jumped forward and put Rainbow Dash into a bear hug
>Once at the house, everyone settles in, sitting around the television
>You put your arms around Twi and Pinkie as Sunset Shimmer sits on your lap
>Rainbow Dash sits on a nearby chair, looking towards you, biting onto her bottom lip
>"Hey guys, I've gotta get up for a sec," you say
>The girls move aside, letting you up onto your feet
>You go looking for some duct tape and a lacrosse helmet
>"I don't even play lacross," you think to yourself
>Scrounging through multiple drawers, you find some duct tape
>"I could definitely use this..." you mumble
>"Anon? You're missing the best part," you hear Twilight say
>"Yeah, get over here!" Pinkie says
>"I'm coming, I'm coming," you say, dropping the duct tape back where you found it
>You sit back down onto the couch, putting your arms around Twi and Pinkie as the movie heads into its climax
>Rainbow Dash scratches the back of her head
>"Welcome back, Anon," she says with an awkward smile
>Sunset Shimmer sits back down onto your lap, and begins wriggling her ass on your crotch
>Without turning from the television, she begins groping about your zipper
>She unzips your pants, reaches in, and pulls out your cock
>Sunset moans as she places your cock into her ass, slowly bobbing up and down
>"Ngh~"
>You look over to Rainbow Dash, whose face has gone completely flush
>She brings her hand up to her mouth, unable to look away
>You wink at her as Sunset Shimmer continues to ride your cock, letting out deep moans
>Twilight begins breathing heavily as the two of you go at it, sliding her hands into her skirt
>"O-Oh~"
>Pinkie slides her hands into her skirt as well, arching her back as she fingers herself
>You reach your hands around Sunset Shimmer and grab her enlarged breasts in each hand
>The jiggle to the touch, soft and plump
>You begin to rub your thumbs on her nipples
>The girls moan and gasp loudly as Rainbow watches, who has begun to pant
>"W-What do I do?" Rainbow Dash stutters
>"Ooh, ooh, I know! TICKLE FIGHT!"
>"Pinkie!" everyone shouts, laughing
>"I have a better idea," Sunset Shimmer says
>You all roll onto the floor in front of Rainbow Dash, and Sunset Shimmer slides your cock out of her ass
>Suddenly, Twilight and Pinkie hold down your arms
>"Why don't you do the honors, Rainbow Dash?" Sunset says as she sits herself down on your face
>Rainbow Dash gulps, removing her skirt and underwear
>"It's so big..." she says as she lowers her hole onto your cock, trying to push your head through
>With some force, she slides you into her tight pussy
>"AH~"
>Rainbow Dash leans back as she slides you in and out of her wet pussy
>The sensation is too much to bear, and you struggle to get out
>Your cock pops out of Dash, and you sigh in relief
>"Oh fine, you big baby," Sunset says, removing her shirt
>She kneels by your waist as Twi and Pinkie hold you down, and runs a finger along your shaft
>"Feeling sensitive are we?" she says deviously
>"Not too sensitive, I hope"
>Sunset Shimmer sits herself down on your cock, her ass hugging against it tightly
>Twilight and Pinkie lay back, letting you cup your hands between their legs
>You rub your fingers in a circular motion before sticking your fingers in
>"Oh~" they moan
>Rainbow Dash sits her toned bottom on your face, already dripping wet
>You begin to flit your tongue on her pussy, and she moans in ecstasy
>Sunset Shimmer leans forward and kisses Dash, letting her tongue writhe against hers
>The two of them begin to fondle each others breasts, Sunset's pregnant body slowly rising and falling on your dick
>You exhale deeply as tension builds up in you body, and Rainbow Dash coos as your warm breath blows across her slit
>"Almost there?" Sunset asks
>"I-I want to cum inside Rainbow Dash," you say, trying with all your might to delay orgasm
>The moans of Twilight and Pinkie as you finger them slide smoothly into your ear, only adding to your excitement
>Sunset removes herself from your cock
>Rainbow Dash pounces on you without second thought
>She greedily sticks your dick into her as she rides you, giving you a great view of her backside
>You can't hold it back any longer, feeling spent as you shoot your load deep into her body
>"AH~" she moans, and you feel her contract against your cock as she cums
>She falls back onto you, and you put your arms around her
>The rest of the girls move in towards you, lying down next to you, hands strewn about your collective bodies
>You breath a sigh of content, and close your eyes as their warm, naked bodies press against yours

>5 months later

>You stood outside as you waited for Sunset Shimmer with the rest of the girls
>Twilight and Pinkie were showing very noticeable signs of pregnancy, being 6 months in
>Their breasts had expanded over the past few months, which added some new fun to your gatherings
>Rainbow Dash held her hand against her stomach, and smiled at you
>Finally, you see Sunset Shimmer round the bend
>You rush out to help her
>"Thanks Anon," she says lovingly
>"Can you believe it's been almost 9 months now?"
>"It still feels a bit unreal to me," you say
>You embrace her, and give her a kiss
>She blushes as you pull away, and follows you up the stairs into the house
>You all sit down in your living room
>You can't help but smile as you look at the faces of those you love
>"Anon... What's going to happen now?" Twilight asks
>You exhale
>"I don't really know. I... I love all of you. I want to spend the rest of my life with you. But..."
>"Ooh! Oooooooh! Anon, pick me!"
>You turn to Pinkie, a quizzical look on your face
>"Why don't we all just become Mormons?"
>"It does seem like the only way," Dash adds
>It hadn't really crossed your mind before
>"I think we should do it, Anon... If this is what you want," Sunset Shimmer says
>"Wait right here," you reply
>You return from your bedroom, holding a long jewelry case
>You kneel down, the girls surrounding you in a semi-circle, and open it up to reveal four rings
>"Will you guys marry me?"
>They all put you into a bear hug, tears rolling down their faces
>"I guess we're Mormons now," you say

SAPPY HAREM ENDING GET