Punishing Fire-o-Meter

Updated 9/26/2018

This is a list of the most played creatures over the last two months in Legacy from MTGtop8.com. The number in parenthesis following the creature name is the number of Punishing Fires required to destroy it. A ? indicates the creature has variable toughness and can sometimes be destroyed by Punishing Fire. An X indicates the creature can't reasonably be destroyed with Punishing Fire.

1. Snapcaster Mage (1)
2. Gurmag Angler (X)
3. Delver of Secrets (1)
4. True-Name Nemesis (X)
5. Stoneforge Mystic (1)
6. Baleful Strix (1)
7. Mother of Runes (1)
8. Phyrexian Revoker (1)
9. Thalia, Guardian of Thraben (1)
10. Griselbrand (X)
11. Recruiter of the Guard (1)
12. Street Wraith (2)
13. Flickerwisp (1)
14. Dryad Arbor (1)
15. Death's Shadow (?)
16. Emrakul, the Aeons Torn (X)
17. Walking Ballista (?)
18. Simian Spirit Guide (1)
19. Sanctum Prelate (1)
20. Mirran Crusader (1)

Number of creatures that can be destroyed with 1 Fire: 13/20, 65%
2 Fires: 1/20, 5%
Can sometimes be destroyed: 2/20, 10%
Can't reasonably be destroyed: 4/20, 20%