Guest User

Untitled

a guest
Jan 25th, 2026
141
0
Never
7
Not a member of Pastebin yet? Sign Up, it unlocks many cool features!
text 19.63 KB | None | 0 0
  1. Test 1: Scroll restore: change the restore to gridEl.scrollTop = scrollTop + 4; in renderGridBody. If the visible gap jumps, the saved/restored value is the lever.
  2.  
  3. Observations:
  4.  
  5. * The offset on the large scroll (no animation) has gotten large)
  6. * The offset on the short scroll is the same.
  7. * Downward short scroll is still fine.
  8.  
  9. Test 2: Spacer math: add + 4 to topSpacer and bottomSpacer when we compute them. If the gap jumps, spacer sizing is the lever.
  10.  
  11. Observations: No change to scrolling. Rather, there is a 4px gap between the first row at the time that the table is loaded.
  12.  
  13. Test 3: Resnap hook: in _rowScrollApi.resnap, force gridEl.scrollTop = lastSnappedTarget + 4;. If the gap jumps, the post-render resnap is the lever.
  14.  
  15. Observations: No change.
  16.  
  17. Test 4: Added the next +4px test: in renderGridBody the startIndex calculation now uses scrollTop + 4 (temporary) to see if scroll-index math affects the offset. Test this run; we’ll revert once you’ve observed the impact.
  18.  
  19. Observations: No change
  20.  
  21. Test 5: Reverted the startIndex tweak and added a new +4 test: capture scrollTop as gridEl.scrollTop + 4 before rendering, then use that through the render/restore flow. Please test this run and note any changes; we’ll revert afterward.
  22.  
  23. Observations: Same result as test 1
  24.  
  25. Test 6: We tried biasing the saved scroll value by +4 before virtual render/restore (capturing scrollTop + 4 instead of the raw value) to see if capture/restore was the lever; it behaved the same as the earlier restore +4 test (large jumps worse, short-scroll gap unchanged), so we reverted it.
  26.  
  27. Observation: No change
  28.  
  29. Test 7: inflate the virtual spacer heights—set topSpacer and bottomSpacer to startIndex * rowStride + 4 and (totalRows - endIndex) * rowStride + 4 in renderGridBody—to see if spacer sizing influences the offset. Please run with this change, note any differences, and we’ll revert based on the outcome.
  30.  
  31. No change
  32.  
  33. Test 8: bias the scroll restore downward by 4px to see if restoring a slightly lower position affects the offset. In renderGridBody, temporarily set gridEl.scrollTop = scrollTop - 4; instead of the raw scrollTop. Run this version, observe whether the short up-scroll gap changes, then we’ll revert based on the outcome.
  34.  
  35. Observation: No change
  36.  
  37. Test 9: Temporarily biased the snap baseline by +4 in scrolling.js: during wheel snaps we now use snapBase = rowOffset + 4 in the snap equation and log that adjusted baseline. Please test and see if the up-scroll offset shifts; we’ll revert based on the outcome.
  38.  
  39. result: Everything is offset by an additional 4px, but the same regular 4px offset difference remains.
  40.  
  41. Test 10: Forced the virtual spacer calculations to use the measured rowHeight first (ignoring the cached stride) as a temporary test. Run this version and see if the up-scroll offset changes; we’ll revert based on the result.
  42.  
  43. result: The the 4px offset difference remains, but now there is a cumulative additional offset that affects all scrolling. In essence - it didn't address the issue, just created a new one on top of it.
  44.  
  45. Test 11: Applied next +4 test: snap rounding now uses a stride inflated by 4px (snapStride = rowStride + 4) while keeping the same snap base. The debug log reflects the adjusted stride. Please run this and see if the up-scroll offset changes; we’ll revert based on the result.
  46.  
  47. Result: Created a cumulative offset issue for all scrolling.
  48.  
  49. Test 12: At this point we’ve tried +4 biases on restore, capture, spacers, start index, resnap, snap baseline, snap stride, and spacer stride without shifting the persistent 3–4px gap. The next lever to test is padding/border on the scroll container itself: temporarily add +4 to gridEl.clientTop equivalent by setting a scroll-padding-top: 4px on the scroll container via JS/CSS and see if the gap follows. Want me to set up that test?
  50.  
  51. Result: No change.
  52.  
  53. Test 13: Implemented the next +4 test: in scrolling.js the measured snap baseline now adds +4px (rowOffsetCache = measuredOffset + 4) to see if shifting the baseline itself affects the gap. Please run and note any change; we’ll revert based on the result.
  54.  
  55. Result: There is an additional 4x offset on everything.
  56.  
  57. Test 14: Temporarily removed scroll save/restore in renderGridBody: we no longer capture scrollTop/scrollLeft or set scrollTop after rebuilding; startIndex now uses the current gridEl.scrollTop. This lets snapped positions persist without being overwritten by pre-render values. Please test whether the 3–4px up-scroll gap changes; we can revert after observing.
  58.  
  59. Result: No change
  60.  
  61. ---
  62.  
  63. Debug 1: Instrumented renderGridBody to log scroll state before and after rendering: we now capture scrollTopBefore, use it through the calculations/restores, and log a formatted “before” line plus an “after” line showing spacers, rowStride, and the resulting scroll positions. This should help pinpoint where drift happens.
  64.  
  65. Result: We can see when drift happens: every time we render after a snap up, we restore scrollTopBefore and log it unchanged (e.g., 857.6) even though the snap equation produced a target of 860.8 or 887.6. The “before” log never reflects the snapped target; it’s the pre-snap value, and we then render with spacers/top/bottom based on that lower value and restore it again. So we’re ignoring the snap target and reusing the old scrollTop through render/restore, which explains why up-scrolls land a few pixels shy—the snap math isn’t being applied to scrollTopBefore, and we keep restoring the unsnapped value.
  66.  
  67. Debug 2: Restored scroll save/restore while keeping the instrumentation: renderGridBody now captures scrollTopBefore/scrollLeft, logs the “before” state, uses that for startIndex, restores it after render, and logs the “after” state. Use this to see exactly where drift occurs.
  68.  
  69. Result: The snap math is consistent (all snaps are to clean multiples), but for the “bad” up-scrolls the logged scrollBefore/scrollAfter stay at the pre-snap value (e.g., still 857.6/911.2) instead of the snapped target (860.8, 887.6, etc.). We’re restoring/reusing the unsnapped scrollTop through render, so the snap result never sticks on upward moves, causing the persistent gap.
  70.  
  71. Debug 3 implemented: added a snap-time log in scrolling.js (snap-target with unsnapped/snapped/scrollTopNow), and renderGridBody now logs the snap target alongside before/after scroll and spacer info. This should let us see if the snapped value differs from what render receives/restores. Please run a short up-scroll sequence and share the condensed logs.
  72.  
  73. Result: The new logs show why up-scroll snaps still miss: snap targets are being computed (e.g., 3969.6, 3942.8, 3916, …), but render-grid sees scrollBefore as the pre-snap value (4009.6, then 3989.6, 3964, …) and restores that, so the snap never sticks. Downward snaps are aligned because scrollTopNow equals the snapped value when render runs. We’re still restoring the old scrollTop through the render pipeline instead of the snapped target on up-scrolls. The discrepancy is between the snapped value in snap-target and the scrollBefore/After in the next render: they don’t match on up-scrolls.
  74.  
  75. Debug 4: I want to add a compact log that records, per wheel notch, the trio of values we keep bouncing between—snapTarget, targetRef.top, and the scrollTop we actually render/restore with—so we can see exactly where the 3–4px drift is introduced. This will add a single line per snap (no spam). OK to add this instrumentation?
  76.  
  77. Result: The “snap-target” lines show the root of the 3–4px gap: we compute a clean snap (e.g., snapped/targetRef=190.8), but the live scroll position (scrollNow) sometimes stays at the older value (e.g., 214.4). That mismatch means the DOM never actually lands on the snapped row before render, so we keep rendering/restoring from a slightly off scrollTop—exactly the 3–4px offset you’re seeing.
  78.  
  79. Debug 5: Add one compact log at two spots to trace where we lose the snap: (1) immediately after the wheel handler sets targetRef.top/lastSnappedTarget, log {snap, targetRef, scrollNow}; (2) right before and after renderGridBody restores scrollTop, log {snapTopUsed, scrollTopBefore, scrollTopAfter}. This will show exactly whether the snap is lost between the wheel event and render restore, and by how many pixels. Proceed?
  80.  
  81. Result: From these logs the snap math is still clean—each notch snaps to exact multiples—but on the upward passes the live scroll (scrollNow) stays at the pre-snap position (e.g., snapped/targetRef=137.2 while scrollNow=160.8; snapped=83.6 while scrollNow=110.4), so the DOM never lands on the snapped row before render/restore. Downward snaps do align, but upward snaps leave scrollTop parked at the older value, which is exactly the source of the 3–4px gap we keep seeing. (I think we already knew that)
  82.  
  83. Debug 6: I rolled back the animation-killing snap force and added sequence tracing. Each wheel snap now bumps a seq and logs snap-target seq=… dir=…. The first animate frame per seq logs animate-frame seq=… current/target, the first native scroll event per seq logs scroll-event seq=… scrollNow/targetRef, and render now logs [render-snap] seq=… snapUsed/before/after. This should show exactly where the snap value is lost across wheel → animate → scroll → render. Please reproduce an up-scroll and share the condensed logs so we can see which stage fails.
  84.  
  85. Result: From that run we see the same failure point: up-scroll snaps are computed (seq 5–8), animate starts walking toward the snapped targets, but the native scroll positions never reach them (scroll events stall above the target), and when render fires it restores to the pre-snap value—or worse, drops to 0 (render-snap … before=56.8 after=0). No clamp logged, so it’s not clamping; the snap is simply never applied to the live scrollTop before render/restore, and the restore step can even zero it out. In short, we’re still rendering off the pre-snap scrollTop rather than the snapped target, which is the source of the 3–4px gap.
  86.  
  87. Debug 7: logs the entire snap-to-render path with a sequence ID: clamp now logs if it adjusts the target (reason, min/max, before/after); the first animate frame per snap logs the current vs target, and when animation stops it logs the remaining diff before setting scrollTop; native scroll events log the live scrollTop and targetRef for that snap; snap-time logs still show unsnapped/snapped/scrollNow; and render logs include the snap sequence plus the scrollTop it used and restored. Together these should reveal whether clamp alters the target, whether animation reaches the snap, and whether render/restore overwrites the snapped scrollTop.
  88.  
  89. Results : We learned two new specifics: (1) the animation actually reaches the snapped targets—animate-stop shows diffs of ~0—so the snap math and easing are fine; (2) the render step then blows it away: render-snap shows snapUsed=83.2/before=83.2 but after=0, and the next clamp pushes that 0 up to the minTop 56.8. Also note scrollAfter shows “0/0 table=0”, so the render/restore cycle is zeroing scrollTop (and scrollHeight is reporting 0) right after we rebuild the table. In short: we hit the snap, but renderGrid wipes scrollTop to 0 during/after the DOM rebuild, and clamp then forces it to 56.8, creating the visible offset. Next debug should pinpoint which step in renderGrid sets scrollTop to 0 (e.g., log immediately before/after removing the old tbody, after appending the new tbody, and after the scrollTop assignment).
  90.  
  91. Debug 9: Added render-step logs around the DOM rebuild in renderGridBody—before removing the old tbody, after removal, after appending the new tbody, and after restoring scrollTop. Each line includes the snap seq, scrollTop, scrollHeight, and table height. Please reproduce the issue; these logs should show exactly when scrollTop drops to 0 during render.
  92.  
  93. Results: We’ve confirmed the precise failure point: during render, when the tbody is removed/empty, gridEl.scrollHeight and gridTable.offsetHeight drop to 0, and the subsequent “after-restore” assigns scrollTop but the DOM stays at 0—render-snap shows before=56.8, after=0, and the next clamp forces it to 56.8. So the snap is reached by animation (animate-stop diffs near 0), but the virtual-render cycle collapses scrollHeight/table height to 0 and wipes scrollTop to 0 before restore can stick, creating the offset on the next frame. In short: the table is being re-rendered into a 0-height state, which resets scrollTop to 0; our restore attempt happens while scrollHeight is 0, so it doesn’t take effect, and clamp then applies minTop. We need to keep non-zero spacer height or skip restoring while scrollHeight is 0.
  94.  
  95. Debug 9.1: Added spacer-phase logs and a guard: we now log top/bottom spacer sizes before adding them, log after append, and only restore scrollTop when scrollHeight is non-zero; otherwise we log that restore was skipped. This should show whether scrollHeight is 0 when we try to restore. Please rerun the up-scroll and share the new [render-step] lines to see if the restore is being skipped due to zero height.
  96.  
  97. Results:
  98.  
  99.  
  100.  
  101. ----
  102.  
  103. Fix attempt 1: Exposed the last snapped scroll target from scrolling.js and used it in renderGridBody when restoring scroll after a virtual render, so we restore to the snap target (if present) instead of the pre-render scrollTop.
  104.  
  105. Result: No change.
  106.  
  107. Fix attempt 2: Temporarily disabled virtualization by setting virtualizationEnabled = false in renderer.js to see if the offset disappears without virtual rows/spacers. Please run and check the scroll behavior; we can revert after observing.
  108.  
  109. Result: Same offset issue, everything is just slower.
  110.  
  111. Fix Attempt 3 (after debug 1): I added a tracked lastSnappedTarget in scrolling.js (set when a wheel notch snaps, exposed via _rowScrollApi.getLastSnappedTarget) and updated renderGridBody in renderer.js to prefer that snapped value when computing/restoring scrollTop (and logging), so layout/restoration now honors the snap target instead of the pre-snap scroll position.
  112.  
  113. Result: No change.
  114.  
  115. Fix Attempt 4: I reintroduced tracking of the snapped scroll target and now prefer it during render. scrolling.js stores lastSnappedTarget on wheel snaps (cleared on unsnapped moves) and exposes it via _rowScrollApi.getLastSnappedTarget. In renderGridBody, we now use that snap target (if present) for startIndex and to restore scrollTop after rendering, instead of the pre-snap scroll. Please test whether the up-scroll gap improves; we can revert if not.
  116.  
  117. Result: Same offset issues. Downward scrolls (sometimes) have the issue now too.
  118.  
  119. Fix Attempt 5: Remove the restored pre-render scroll entirely—drop the gridEl.scrollTop = scrollTopBefore after render and instead set gridEl.scrollTop to the snapped target when we have one (lastSnappedTarget), otherwise leave it untouched. This aligns the DOM to the snap result and stops reapplying stale scroll positions. I’ll implement this change now for you to visually confirm whether the 3–4px gap disappears.
  120.  
  121. Result: Table data won't load.
  122.  
  123. Fix Attempt 6: I wired snap tracking end-to-end. The wheel handler now records the snapped targetTop for notch scrolls (clearing it on other moves), exposes it via _rowScrollApi.getLastSnappedTarget, and native scroll clears it. renderGridBody now uses the snapped target (when present) for startIndex calculations and restores scrollTop to that snapped value instead of the pre-snap scrollTop. Please try the current build and see if the 3–4px up-scroll gap disappears or changes.
  124.  
  125. Result: Same offset issues. Downward scrolls (sometimes) have the issue now too.
  126.  
  127. Fix Attempt 7 (after debug 5): For wheel notches, after computing the snapped target I now immediately set gridEl.scrollTop to that snapped value (and keep targetRef/lastSnappedTarget in sync). This forces the DOM to land on the snap position instead of reusing the old scrollTop that caused the 3–4px gap. Please retest up/down scrolls and see if the offset disappears.
  128.  
  129. Results: Smooth scrolling is now dead it seems, there is no animation. All scrolls have the same 4px offset.
  130.  
  131. Fix Attempt 8: I exposed the live scroll target (targetRef.top) via _rowScrollApi.getTargetTop and updated renderGridBody to use the snapped target first, then the targetRef, before falling back to the current scrollTop for computing startIndex and restoring. This should make renders align with the intended snap even before the DOM has fully moved, avoiding the 3–4px offset. Please retest up/down scrolls and see if the offset improves without killing animation.
  132.  
  133. Results: No change.
  134.  
  135. Fix Attempt 9: Wheel notch snaps now set a pendingSnapRef with the snapped value, and the animation loop applies that snap on its next tick before easing, then clears it. This should let the DOM land on the snap (fixing the 3–4px gap) without killing smooth animation. Please retest up/down scrolls and report whether the offset is gone and animation feels normal.
  136.  
  137. Result: Killed animated scrolling, still has offset.
  138.  
  139. Fix Attempt 10: If render sees scrollHeight=0 after appending the new tbody, we now inject a 1px spacer row to restore height, then perform the scrollTop restore. This aims to stop scrollTop from being wiped to 0 during virtual re-render. Please retest up/down scrolls and see if the 3–4px offset disappears.
  140.  
  141. Results: Didn't help.
  142.  
  143. Fix Attempt 11: Removed the dummy spacer and now defer scrollTop restoration until the table has nonzero height. After appending the new tbody, we attempt to restore immediately; if scrollHeight/table height are 0, we log and retry on the next RAF (up to 3 attempts), logging the outcome. This should prevent scrollTop from being wiped to 0 during the collapse window. Please retest the up/down scrolls and check whether the 3–4px offset persists.
  144.  
  145. Results: We’re still at the same root: on some renders (e.g., seq=46) the table collapses to zero height and never recovers—scrollH/tableH stay 0 through append, and even after three deferred restore attempts, so scrollTop stays 0 and clamp bumps it to minTop. Spacer calc says top=0 bottom=23932, but the tbody we append ends up height 0 (no rows/spacers), so there’s nothing to give the scroller height. That’s why the 3–4px offset persists.
  146.  
  147. Fix attempt 12: I stopped removing/replacing the tbody each render. We now reuse the existing tbody and clear its children, then append spacers and rows; the table element stays mounted, avoiding the zero-height collapse that was wiping scrollTop. The deferred restore logic remains. Please retest up/down scrolls to see if the 3–4px offset is gone.
  148.  
  149. Results: We’re still hitting the same root cause: in the failing sequences the table collapses to zero height during render, even after reuse/clear. In seq 19, after-clear and after-append both show scrollH=0 and tableH=0, so the tbody (and even the table) have no height; the deferred restore then does nothing and clamp bumps to minTop, recreating the offset.
  150.  
  151. Fix attempt 13: Added a guard at the start of renderGridBody—if the grid/table are collapsed (scrollHeight or table height is 0), we log and defer render to the next RAF instead of clearing/appending into a zero-height table. This avoids wiping scrollTop during collapse. Please retest the up/down scrolls and see if the 3–4px offset is gone.
  152.  
  153. Results: No difference
  154.  
  155. ----
  156.  
  157.  
  158. Roll back. Use what we have learned, and continue trying to resolve this.
  159.  
  160. Respond in the form of <Test/Debug/Fix Attempt> <Number>: <paragraph summary>. A debug is something you need me to gather debug logs for, a test is something non-permanent you changed that you want me to visually see if it made a difference; and a fix attempt is an attempt to fix the issue. Additionally, if it is a test or fix attempt, conduct it. If it is an additional debug, ask for permission first.
Advertisement
Comments
  • User was banned
  • User was banned
  • User was banned
  • User was banned
  • User was banned
  • User was banned
  • User was banned
Add Comment
Please, Sign In to add comment