Not a member of Pastebin yet?
Sign Up,
it unlocks many cool features!
- 6:06:49 PMXappolBot
- Hello cookiefonster!
- 6:06:54 PMvell
- yo cf
- 6:06:56 PMWojowu
- Hey cf
- 6:06:57 PMGreagol
- hello cookie
- 6:06:57 PMcookiefonster
- hi all
- 6:07:01 PMvell
- actual activity + hella people here
- 6:07:02 PMcookiefonster
- lot of people on todaty
- 6:07:07 PM
- what were you guys talking about?
- 6:07:07 PMFlitris
- 6000-8000 years ago
- 6:07:15 PM
- a variety of topics cf
- 6:07:22 PMvell
- cookiefonster: there are multiple overlapping conversations here, i'll fill u in with pm
- 6:07:39 PMGreagol
- flitris...
- 6:07:40 PMcookiefonster
- hope i don't kill the combo
- 6:07:42 PM
- convo*'
- 6:07:42 PMGreagol
- no comment
- 6:07:45 PMWojowu
- Nope
- 6:07:46 PMDeedlit
- wow, a New Earther
- 6:08:08 PMFlitris
- I'm not a new earther
- 6:08:09 PMcookiefonster
- new earther?
- 6:08:16 PMFlitris
- I don't even know what that is
- 6:08:22 PMGreagol
- I believe in God but creationism is just dumb sorry
- 6:08:36 PM
- he means Young Earth Creationist
- 6:08:40 PMFlitris
- That is self-contradictory
- 6:08:58 PMWojowu
- No, it's not
- 6:09:00 PMDeedlit
- um, no it isn't
- 6:09:11 PMWojowu
- There might be a God in the Universe which was created on its own, no?
- 6:09:14 PMFlitris
- You can't believe that the universe came from nothing and God at the same time
- 6:09:15 PMWojowu
- Brb
- 6:09:20 PMcookiefonster
- the new earth idea is absurdly dumb
- 6:09:33 PMFlitris
- God must have created the universe
- 6:09:33 PMDeedlit
- first of all, yes you can
- 6:09:43 PMcookiefonster
- with the HUGE amount of science evidence against it
- 6:09:53 PMFlitris
- like what?
- 6:10:00 PMcookiefonster
- flitris:' what compelling evidence is there that god created the unvierse?
- 6:10:03 PMDeedlit
- also, you don't have to believe either that the universe came from nothing or that the universe is 6000 years old
- 6:10:14 PMGreagol
- I didn't say I necessarily believe in ABRAHAMIC God
- 6:10:31 PMvell
- http://rationalwiki.org/wiki/Evidence_against_a_recent_creation
- 6:10:53 PMWojowu
- Thank you, vell
- 6:11:00 PMGreagol
- what have I done... a creationism argument on googology wiki
- 6:11:03 PM
- :(
- 6:11:25 PMDeedlit
- heh, you wanted to bring up a specific point about the big bang
- 6:11:29 PMvell
- Greagol: not the first one
- 6:11:48 PM
- so as for your original point about the big bang, what do you think is the true story?
- 6:12:05 PM
- i admit that my cosmology is not strong
- 6:12:11 PMWojowu
- I think Greagol just wanted to point out that it wasn't an explosion
- 6:12:32 PMFlitris
- then what was it?
- 6:12:38 PMGreagol
- Wojowu yes and that it in fact might be infinite
- 6:12:49 PMDeedlit
- and it didn't emerge from a central point
- 6:12:55 PM
- and expand into surrounding empty space
- 6:13:03 PMGreagol
- and if it is infinite it might have always been infinity
- 6:13:05 PMFlitris
- matter cannot be created/destoryed and the universe must have a beginning
- 6:13:14 PMGreagol
- a singularity can be infinite
- 6:13:18 PMWojowu
- Matter can be created/destroyed
- 6:13:30 PMGreagol
- Deedelit indeed
- 6:13:43 PMFlitris
- So the laws of Thermodynamics are all wrong?
- 6:14:00 PMWojowu
- What does thermodynamics have to do with conservation of matter?
- 6:14:02 PMvell
- Greagol: is it more correct to describe that the universe is infinite, and is expanding slower than it was back then?
- 6:14:07 PMGreagol
- I've encountered stuff like "you cannot put googolplex into an universe" -> we don't in fact know that
- 6:14:16 PMWojowu
- Thermodynamics just says that overall mass/energy is conserved
- 6:14:19 PMvell
- at least acc to the prevailing theory
- 6:14:22 PMGreagol
- vell slower compared to inflation
- 6:14:31 PMcookiefonster
- we know that it's true for the /observable/ universe
- 6:14:32 PMFlitris
- Conservation of matter is one of the laws of thermodynamics
- 6:14:37 PMGreagol
- but according to last data it is slowly speeding up
- 6:14:46 PMFlitris
- all matter
- 6:14:49 PMWojowu
- Flit, point me to a single source which claims so
- 6:15:04 PM
- And then explain to me how annihilation is possible in that case
- 6:15:08 PMvell
- years of being a creatoinist kinda left me behind on the whole big bang thing
- 6:15:13 PMGreagol
- cookiefonster indeed, but the analogy can be said - we are in a ship, we only see until the horizon
- 6:15:32 PMcookiefonster
- vell: you were at one poitn a creationist?
- 6:15:32 PMGreagol
- by no means it means that there is no ocean beyond the horizon
- 6:15:40 PMcookiefonster
- ewre you raised as one or something?
- 6:15:48 PMDeedlit
- vell: according to the latest data, the universe's expansion is accelerating
- 6:15:58 PMWojowu
- You know, it might be the case that what we percieve as a reality is in fact a computer simulation
- 6:16:07 PMcookiefonster
- yeeah
- 6:16:13 PMDeedlit
- that could certainly be true, Wojowu
- 6:16:15 PMWojowu
- (I misspelled percieve, didn't I?)
- 6:16:18 PMcookiefonster
- those are the kinds of existential questions that fuck with my minfd
- 6:16:19 PM
- like
- 6:16:24 PM
- i know for a fact that i'm conscious
- 6:16:25 PMvell
- Wojowu: perceive
- 6:16:29 PMWojowu
- Thanks
- 6:16:33 PMcookiefonster
- but is anyone else really a human like me, does anyone else actually exist?
- 6:16:44 PMvell
- cookiefonster: ah yes, the problem of solipsism
- 6:17:01 PMDeedlit
- yeah, I've pondered the same thing
- 6:17:06 PMcookiefonster
- only a few months ago did i learn that there wsa a word for that
- 6:17:07 PMWojowu
- As someone once said, we can't prove existence of anything apart from our consiousness
- 6:17:20 PMGreagol
- i hate solipsism
- 6:17:23 PMvell
- one that has always stumped me: why am i experiencing my own thoughts and sensations, and not someone else's?
- 6:17:28 PMGreagol
- its basically narcissism
- 6:17:37 PM
- masqueraded as philosophy
- 6:17:43 PM
- other people have brains
- 6:17:49 PM
- like mine
- 6:17:52 PMWojowu
- You know when I learned that solipsism is a word? less than 2 minutes ago
- 6:17:58 PMGreagol
- so they are conscious
- 6:18:15 PM
- solipsism is like "nothing is real, maane"
- 6:18:26 PMWojowu
- Greagol, brain doesn't have to be equal to conciousness
- 6:18:31 PMFlitris
- http://www.creationism.org/heinze/SciEvidGodLife.htm
- 6:18:40 PMGreagol
- the Matrix movie seemed to make an eruption of this kind of philosophy
- 6:18:43 PMDeedlit
- but haven't you ever wondered why the consciousness that you are experiencing belongs to the particular person that is you?
- 6:19:03 PMGreagol
- Wojowu true, but you have to go to dualism to believe that
- 6:19:35 PMvell
- Flitris: http://rationalwiki.org/wiki/Proteins#Protein_folding
- 6:20:08 PM
- * Wojowu is leaving in 10 minutes
- 6:20:30 PMGreagol
- even if proteins couldnt form by proven mechanisms it by no means means that universe was created 6000 years aho
- 6:20:38 PM
- it is a false dichotomu
- 6:20:41 PM
- dichotomy
- 6:20:55 PMWojowu
- Hey guys, ever heard of this? http://rationalwiki.org/wiki/Last_Thursdayism
- 6:21:00 PMGreagol
- yeah
- 6:21:12 PM
- anyways i find solipsism to be meaningless
- 6:21:21 PMFlitris
- I'm done here
- 6:21:25 PMGreagol
- on this reasoning i cannot even prove that I exist
- 6:21:43 PMFlitris
- If you want to believe that nothing came from nothing then fine
- 6:21:46 PM
- ← Flitris has quit (Quit: Page closed)
- 6:21:59 PMDeedlit
- yep, I expected that to happen
- 6:22:00 PMGreagol
- solipsism seems to be what sociopaths internally believe
- 6:22:09 PMWojowu
- Welp, I guess Flit won't give me link to his claim that matter is preserved
- 6:22:31 PMvell
- i love rationalwiki's quote on solipsism
- 6:22:31 PM
- "Is it solipsistic in here, or is it just me?"
- 6:22:35 PMWojowu
- Also note how Flit, I believ out of all, has said the least
- 6:22:55 PM
- Okay, maybe I said less, because I don't have any definite standpoint
- 6:23:25 PMDeedlit
- you don't have a definite standpoint on creationism/big bang?
- 6:23:37 PMWojowu
- Oh, no, I believe in Big Bang
- 6:23:45 PM
- I put that in wrong words
- 6:23:51 PM
- I know what I believe in
- 6:23:54 PMGreagol
- if Matrix existed, I would take the blue pill
- 6:24:07 PMvell
- and i didn't say much because after unlearning creationism, my knowledge is not well filled-in
- 6:24:07 PMWojowu
- But I have no way of supporting my claims
- 6:24:57 PMvell
- let's talk about flitris's notation thing for a moment
- 6:25:17 PM
- when i read this
- 6:25:18 PMWojowu
- !8ball Did Big Bang happen?
- 6:25:19 PMXappolBot
- CONCENTRATE AND ASK AGAIN
- 6:25:19 PMvell
- > Vell Fm means that the notation is in "Math" Mode i.e everything inside Fm(...) is mathematical, vs Fc which deals with chemistry and Fa which deals with Astronomy
- 6:25:34 PM
- it's obvious that this guy is trying to do...something
- 6:25:43 PMDeedlit
- !8ball eeeerrrgggghhhh did Big Bang happen?!!
- 6:25:43 PMXappolBot
- DON'T COUNT ON IT
- 6:25:48 PMWojowu
- vell: that message clearly demonstrates Flit didn't know what you are asking
- 6:25:49 PMDeedlit
- Oh noes!
- 6:25:51 PMWojowu
- !8ball Did Big Bang happen?
- 6:25:52 PMXappolBot
- OUTLOOK GOOD
- 6:26:07 PMWojowu
- !8ball Last Thursdayism, maybe?
- 6:26:07 PMXappolBot
- YES
- 6:26:14 PMvell
- what concerns me more is that
- 6:26:19 PM
- it seems like he thinks that he's revolutionizing something
- 6:26:35 PMWojowu
- Oh god, vell, you might be right
- 6:26:43 PMvell
- and not only that, but trying to revolutionize math AND chemitry AND astronomy
- 6:27:15 PMGreagol
- God created the Rayo number in 6 days
- 6:27:33 PMDeedlit
- it just doesn't seem to me that is his notation is useful
- 6:27:37 PMGreagol
- therefore DivineCreation(n) is the largest function
- 6:27:54 PMDeedlit
- yes we could rewrite everything into Fm followed by some arcane notation
- 6:27:59 PMGreagol
- my number is DivineCreation(Gigaboombaverse)
- 6:28:00 PMWojowu
- Deedlit, you don't say
- 6:28:01 PMDeedlit
- but why on Earth would we do so
- 6:28:17 PMvell
- i really wish i could get through to him, but he's a really stubborn kid
- 6:28:32 PMDeedlit
- Wojowu, hold back your shock
- 6:28:43 PMWojowu
- Only example he gave for Fm being better is iterated sin
- 6:28:54 PMvell
- i give up on trying to educate him, he is a crank in the making
- 6:29:16 PMWojowu
- Which just exploits the fact that notation sin^k(x) means number power, not functional power
- 6:29:32 PM
- As opposed to standard uses
- 6:29:32 PMvell
- refusing to admit he's wrong. trying to revolutionize accepted fields with shallow, pointless, and informal bullshit.
- 6:29:35 PM
- right down to being a young-earth creationist.
- 6:29:44 PMcookiefonster
- is flitris one?
- 6:29:53 PMDeedlit
- yes
- 6:30:02 PMGreagol
- heh
- 6:30:04 PMcookiefonster
- fuck fuck fuck fuck
- 6:30:18 PMGreagol
- i accidentally uncovered WHY does he have cranky ideas
- 6:30:22 PMWojowu
- Also, ragequit
- 6:30:22 PM
- <Flitris> I'm done here
- 6:30:22 PM
- <Flitris> If you want to believe that nothing came from nothing then fine
- 6:30:22 PM
- <-- Flitris (b83a9f07@gateway/web/freenode/ip.184.58.159.7) has quit (Quit: Page closed)
- 6:30:32 PMGreagol
- first you argued about math with him
- 6:30:46 PM
- and he had cranky ideas but im too dumb to see they're cranky
- 6:30:52 PM
- → Flitris has joined
- 6:30:52 PMXappolBot
- Hello Flitris!
- 6:30:57 PMvell
- wb
- 6:31:01 PMFlitris
- hey
- 6:31:03 PMGreagol
- hello...
- 6:31:05 PMWojowu
- Hey again
- 6:31:09 PMGreagol
- awkward moment :D
- 6:31:11 PMWojowu
- I didn't think you are coming back
- 6:31:28 PMFlitris
- I just needed to blow off some steam
- 6:31:31 PMDeedlit
- wb
- 6:31:32 PMvell
- np
- 6:31:39 PMcookiefonster
- hi again flitris
- 6:31:42 PMFlitris
- I hate getting into unneccessary debates
- 6:31:56 PMcookiefonster
- why unnecessary?
- 6:31:56 PMvell
- i disagree with it being unnecessary
- 6:32:05 PMDeedlit
- if you don't want to talk about Creationism, that's fine
- 6:32:05 PMvell
- these aere important topics and things that people rightly feel strongly about
- 6:32:27 PM
- also what deed said
- 6:32:44 PMGreagol
- i dont feel strongly about it
- 6:32:56 PMDeedlit
- I do
- 6:33:00 PMGreagol
- if someone is a good person i dont mind their beliefs
- 6:33:08 PMDeedlit
- oh certainly
- 6:33:21 PMFlitris
- thats what I mean, I just don't want to talk about them because it will always lead into (no matter how nice it starts): "Well you simple-minded, a cultist, etc." which is what i've been through alot
- 6:33:37 PMcookiefonster
- flitris:
- 6:33:51 PMDeedlit
- well, no one here has said anything like that, as far as I can tell
- 6:34:00 PMWojowu
- Got to go, guys
- 6:34:07 PMvell
- later woj
- 6:34:08 PMDeedlit
- bye Wojowu o/
- 6:34:16 PMGreagol
- my grandfather thinks Stalin was a good guy and has some absolutely insane political ideas outside of that yet he's a perfectly normal, kind person...
- 6:34:16 PMFlitris
- See ya woj
- 6:34:22 PMGreagol
- byebye
- 6:34:48 PMFlitris
- Ah I can see how
- 6:34:49 PM
- ← Wojowu has quit (Remote host closed the connection)
- 6:34:51 PMvell
- Greagol: i think there are cases wher eyou should mind peoples beliefs
- 6:35:07 PM
- would you hire someone if you knew they were a white supremacist?
- 6:35:29 PMGreagol
- if he does not harass nonwhite workers then yes
- 6:35:54 PMFlitris
- oh jeez what have I done....
- 6:35:58 PMvell
- even if that person was very openly racist on social media, etc?
- 6:36:03 PMDeedlit
- but the problem is you don't know that beforehand
- 6:36:03 PMcookiefonster
- flitris: /why/ do you believe in creationism and the like?
- 6:36:23 PMGreagol
- vell it depends
- 6:36:27 PMFlitris
- Because it makes sense to me
- 6:36:54 PMvell
- Greagol: it's definitely a subjective and complex question
- 6:36:59 PMFlitris
- now your going to ask how and etc.
- 6:37:39 PMvell
- but i think it's too simple to say "beliefs don't matter"
- 6:37:46 PMcookiefonster
- yes
- 6:37:49 PM
- how does it make sense/
- 6:37:50 PM
- ?!
- 6:38:02 PMvell
- cookiefonster: i don't think it's a good idea to grill flit on this
- 6:38:20 PMDeedlit
- probably not
- 6:38:33 PMGreagol
- vell well for example my grandpa does not condone Stalin's crimes, he just approves him because he "won the war" and "Stalin was a soldier and I trust a soldier"
- 6:39:27 PM
- vell maybe if he was an active racist i wouldn't hire him, but i wouldnt hate him if he keeps his beliefs quiet
- 6:39:28 PMvell
- i'm not saying that you should hate or disown your grandfather, ofc. my argument is that the statement "beliefs don't matter if you don't act on them" is not always true
- 6:39:44 PMDeedlit
- that does sound like he is okay with Stalin's crimes to some extent
- 6:40:06 PMGreagol
- he grew up in 1950s Czechoslovakia
- 6:40:32 PM
- so it's more of a case of staying with what he was taught as a child
- 6:40:58 PMvell
- for example, i think donating to racist or anti-LGBT organizations would be grounds for firing somone, especially a high-level executive in a company
- 6:41:02 PMDeedlit
- yeah, how you grow up is so important to your core beliefs
- 6:41:24 PMGreagol
- vell but that IS acting on it
- 6:41:28 PMvell
- if they're a sufficiently public figure, it's bad to have the company associated with such a person
- 6:41:37 PM
- true
- 6:41:53 PMGreagol
- he's not an active Stalinist, he just resents the current order more than the previous one
- 6:41:54 PMDeedlit
- that would be quite controversial, if it was donating to anti-LGBT organizations
- 6:42:10 PMvell
- Deedlit: yeah i'm thinking of the brendan eich controversy
- 6:42:11 PMDeedlit
- because being antigay doesn't currently have the stigma of a racist
- 6:42:31 PMFlitris
- well I uh made a large number notation
- 6:43:12 PMvell
- Flitris: ?
- 6:43:54 PMFlitris
- Vell I'm just trying to keep the conversation from not heating up, hopefully
- 6:44:16 PMDeedlit
- vell: wow, I'm surprised that that happened to Eich over a $1000 donation
- 6:44:17 PMvell
- Flitris: can we have a look-see?
- 6:44:19 PMGreagol
- Deedlit he does not like some things that Stalin did
- 6:44:24 PMDeedlit
- I guess LGBT is making strides
- 6:44:33 PMvell
- here's a fun fact, the last US state to overturn interracial marriage was alabama in 2000
- 6:44:58 PMcookiefonster
- 2000?
- 6:45:01 PM
- wow didn't know
- 6:45:22 PMvell
- i grew up thinking government-endorsed racism is a thing of the past in the US
- 6:45:30 PMFlitris
- https://sites.google.com/site/notationnation/a-large-number-notation
- 6:45:45 PMcookiefonster
- vell: ditto
- 6:45:52 PM
- my state is still yet to legalize gay marriage
- 6:45:54 PMDeedlit
- Greagol, I understand, but if you say "well I don't like some of his actions but he is still a good guy", when those actions result in many deaths, that is some amount of condoning I would say
- 6:46:07 PM
- but I don't want to say anything more negative about your grandfather
- 6:46:12 PMGreagol
- Deedlit yes but i wouldn't condemn or disown him
- 6:46:25 PMDeedlit
- I understand completely
- 6:46:29 PMvell
- my parents and siblings are all anti-gay marriage
- 6:46:33 PMGreagol
- there are plenty of people who justify the Vietnam war on the opposite side for example
- 6:47:05 PMvell
- i have at least a handful of moderately anti-LGBT friends :\
- 6:47:33 PMDeedlit
- I hope I don't
- 6:47:41 PM
- I have a number of gay friends
- 6:48:40 PMvell
- i actually don't know too many openly lgbt people irl. i have one trans friend and i'm bi myself
- 6:48:41 PMGreagol
- and he says some things that are right, his views are skewed, but then, he grew up under a goverment heavily "inspired" by Stalin so he knows some things I don't, it is a different case when say some writer in the US defends a dictator they would never live under
- 6:49:01 PM
- i have multiple lgbt friends
- 6:49:19 PM
- well except for the l and b part
- 6:49:26 PMDeedlit
- I think the Vietnam war is largely regarded as a mistake from the US side
- 6:50:23 PMFlitris
- well cya guys I might be on later though
- 6:50:31 PMDeedlit
- cya Flitris
- 6:50:33 PMvell
- later flit, i'm having a look at flux notation rn
- 6:51:14 PMcookiefonster
- i don';t know a lot of lgbt's either
- 6:51:14 PMGreagol
- byebye
- 6:51:19 PMcookiefonster
- i'm straight myself
- 6:51:28 PM
- i know one kid who's bi, that's about it
- 6:51:39 PM
- in fact i don't really know /who/ is lgbt
- 6:51:48 PMvell
- thanks to hanging out in feminist forums, i know a bunch of lgbt people online
- 6:51:58 PMDeedlit
- yeah, I don't really have a "gaydar"
- 6:52:20 PM
- my college roommates who were gay didn't fit the stereotypes at all
- 6:52:21 PMFlitris
- ok anyone e-mail me responses
- 6:52:26 PM
- ← Flitris has quit (Quit: Page closed)
- 6:53:45 PMcookiefonster
- deedlit: this is my first time seeing the word "gaydar"
- 6:54:09 PMDeedlit
- heh
- 6:54:29 PMGreagol
- deedlit what would you do if he was your grandpa?
- 6:54:57 PMcookiefonster
- i sjut realized: i don't know what a gaydar is
- 6:55:05 PM
- https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gaydar
- 6:55:10 PM
- so i ust found out
- 6:55:18 PM
- i thohught gaydar referred to sexual orientation
- 6:55:33 PMDeedlit
- Me? I didn't talk to much with my granddads, as they didn't speak much English, but I certainly wouldn't _do_ anything
- 6:55:44 PM
- other than possibly argue with them from time to time
- 6:56:08 PMGreagol
- i did talk politics with him but in a friendly way over some beer or wine
- 6:56:37 PMDeedlit
- yeah, I don't tend to be that confrontational
- 6:57:10 PMvell
- my maternal grandparents are pretty conservative
- 6:57:11 PMGreagol
- to be honest he clarified some of my misconceptions i had from history books which were skewed in an opposite way, all while i remained critical
- 6:57:30 PM
- vell my grandpa is socially conservative
- 6:57:34 PMDeedlit
- that's good
- 6:57:52 PMvell
- my paternal ones didn't speak much english, and i wasn't old enough to talk politics w/ them while they were alive
- 6:58:04 PMGreagol
- you wouldn't believe it, but most "old school" communists from USSR satellite countries are very socially conservative
- 6:58:39 PM
- i crack up when people in the west associate liberalism with communism
- 6:58:52 PMDeedlit
- yeah, that's ridiculous
- 6:59:05 PMvell
- Greagol: "liberal" has pretty different meanings in different parts of the world
- 6:59:24 PMGreagol
- i know
- 6:59:26 PMDeedlit
- it depends on what your current government/society is
- 6:59:30 PMvell
- yeah
- 6:59:40 PMGreagol
- here it means free market + social liberalism
- 6:59:46 PM
- in Slovakia
- 7:00:07 PMXappolBot
- BONG BONG BONG BONG
- 7:00:13 PMvell
- around here we call it "libertarianism"
- 7:00:43 PMGreagol
- but liberalism here is not as intense as libertarianism
- 7:01:02 PM
- i associate libertarianism with pretty much 0 goverment regulation
- 7:01:16 PM
- liberals here want a small goverment but not a 0 one
- 7:01:59 PMvell
- politics is so complicated that people can't even agree on the words for it :P
- 7:02:51 PMGreagol
- yeah
- 7:03:44 PMvell
- at least in mathematics we have standardized terms like "natural number" and "polyhedron"
- 7:03:53 PM
- (/sarcasm)
- 7:04:23 PMGreagol
- I will make a political ideology based on googology
- 7:04:28 PMcookiefonster
- just look at the wholoe what psi function stuff
- 7:04:39 PM
- that isn't terminology but same idea osrt of
- 7:04:39 PMGreagol
- every citizen will be forced to count to googol from birth
- 7:04:46 PMvell
- cookiefonster: that's more something peculiar to our group
- 7:04:55 PMcookiefonster
- well
- 7:05:06 PM
- deedlit did a bunch of blog posts of a standard of ocf's or something
- 7:05:09 PM
- what happened to that?
- 7:05:22 PMvell
- ...i dont think he ever said it's standard
- 7:05:35 PM
- Greagol: then there will be sub-parties dedicated to different set-theoretic systems
- 7:05:57 PMGreagol
- vell of course
- 7:07:02 PMGreagol
- punishment for making salad number will be tritri years in a reeducation camp memorizing the R function by rote
- 7:07:15 PMvell
- "personally i think Sen. Paul Mahlo's proposed cardinal policies aren't compatible with our nation's infrastructure"
- 7:07:21 PMGreagol
- :D
- 7:07:22 PMXappolBot
- :D
- 7:07:56 PMvell
- the platonist bias in our media is apparent
- 7:08:40 PMGreagol
- Jonathan Bowers will be our president
- 7:08:53 PM
- and Augustin Rayo our deity
- 7:08:55 PMvell
- i'm outraged at the news that he vetoed tha axiom of choice
- 7:09:39 PMGreagol
- how would we deal with Ultrafinitists in our new country?
- 7:10:01 PMvell
- we used their work to prove that there are exactly zero of them
- 7:10:10 PMGreagol
- :D
- 7:10:11 PMXappolBot
- :D
- 7:10:13 PMGreagol
- good choice
- 7:10:16 PMDeedlit
- OCF's are probably not common enough to say a particular version is "standard"
- 7:11:53 PMvell
- bowers stated at a press conference tuesday that "the axiom of choice is detrimental to our goal of the reinhardt caridnals"
- 7:12:05 PMDeedlit
- lol
- 7:12:27 PMvell
- pro-choice activists are outraged at his decision
- 7:12:55 PMDeedlit
- pro-choice, nicely played
- 7:13:16 PMvell
- "our foundation fathers wouldn't have wanted this"
- 7:13:38 PM
- "our economy is going to collapse into countability at this rate"
- 7:13:56 PM
- shit i missed the "we hold bowers countable" pun
- 7:14:12 PMDeedlit
- lmao
- 7:14:40 PMGreagol
- "our economic growth rate has surpassed the f_w+99(99) rate"
- 7:15:35 PMDeedlit
- "Sen Lowenheim Skolem's latest law spells the end of uncountability"
- 7:15:45 PM
- Now know one can be held countable
- 7:15:48 PM
- *no
- 7:16:09 PMvell
- bowers stated in response to these accusations, "i have vowed to keep my policies weakly compact"
- 7:16:59 PM
- his opponents describe the consequences of his decision as "Pi11-indescribable"
- 7:17:38 PMGreagol
- "our inflation rate has exceeded the Church-Kleene ordinal in the fast growing hierarchy"
- 7:18:16 PMvell
- "these aren't normal conditions. our economy will never reach a fixed point this way"
- 7:19:39 PMvell
- one action that has gained bowers some support, however, was his environmental act to "save the finite trees"
- 7:20:30 PMcookiefonster
- ahahahabh
- 7:20:41 PMvell
- "we need to develop technology to keep our agriculture homeomorphically embeddable."
- 7:20:48 PM
- shit Greagol you already made the "finite promise game" joke
- 7:21:21 PMGreagol
- :D
- 7:21:21 PMXappolBot
- :D
- 7:22:32 PMcookiefonster
- man we need activity likr this more often
- 7:23:51 PMvell
- one thing i was thinking of is to schedule meetings
- 7:24:05 PM
- to schedule a time when we try to get as many peopl eon as possible
- 7:24:46 PMcookiefonster
- completely off topic
- 7:24:46 PM
- but
- 7:24:53 PM
- here's a neat timeline map i found of the homestuck intermission
- 7:24:54 PM
- https://sites.google.com/site/kainsirusque/homepage/vmap_p.PNG
- 7:26:14 PMcookiefonster
- gfreagol, vell, still here?
- 7:26:24 PMGreagol
- [00:28] <Deedlit> define F_0(n) = fin(n) [00:28] <Deedlit> and deifne F_{n+1}(n) = F_n(F_n...(F_n(n)...) [00:28] <Deedlit> *define [00:28] <Deedlit> then gugolthra is about at F_99(100)
- 7:26:38 PM
- can you deedlit please explain more :)?
- 7:27:06 PM
- its a log from when i tried to imagine the process to get Gugolthra
- 7:27:33 PMvell
- cookiefonster: i am, if anything, more confused than before
- 7:27:39 PMGreagol
- what do the ... mean? how many brackets and recursion will be there?
- 7:27:44 PMDeedlit
- well, you seem to understand the process of taking a function and going to a function that iterates it n times starting from n
- 7:28:15 PM
- I meant F_n^n(n), which is F(F(...(F(n)...)) with n F's
- 7:28:23 PM
- er replace F with F_n
- 7:28:39 PMcookiefonster
- vell: i reread the whole intermission when i found that timeline
- 7:28:50 PM
- and it suddenly made a zillion times more sense
- 7:29:38 PMGreagol
- yes but stacking the F function F times only got us to w+2
- 7:29:47 PM
- how does it go to w+99?
- 7:30:00 PMDeedlit
- Greagol: so far, you've taken a function fin at level w+1 and iterated it, to get a function at level w+2
- 7:30:12 PM
- then you iterated it again, to get a function at level w+3
- 7:30:42 PM
- you're basically doing the same thing every time, so we can automate it
- 7:30:48 PM
- you had something like
- 7:30:54 PM
- F(n) = fin^n(n)
- 7:30:59 PM
- H(n) = F^n(n)
- 7:31:12 PM
- but if we just use letters we'll run out eventually
- 7:31:17 PMvell
- dang you know who was missing from this conversation?
- 7:31:17 PM
- sbiis
- 7:31:26 PMDeedlit
- yeah
- 7:31:48 PM
- Greagol: so how about F_1(n) = fin^n(n)
- 7:31:57 PM
- F_2(n) = F_1^n(n)
- 7:32:06 PM
- F_3(n) = F_2^n(n)
- 7:32:12 PM
- F_4(n) = f_3^n(n)
- 7:32:20 PM
- clearly we can keep doing this forever
- 7:32:48 PMGreagol
- I see
- 7:32:52 PMDeedlit
- we can just write a general rule, F_{m+1}(n) = F_m^n(n)
- 7:33:09 PMGreagol
- so we continue until we get to the 99th function
- 7:33:13 PM
- ?
- 7:33:19 PMDeedlit
- Sbiis tends to come on around 6-8 PM PST
- 7:33:30 PM
- Greagol, yes
- 7:35:09 PMGreagol
- does each sucessive function repeat the previous function n times to get a new one?
- 7:35:16 PM
- → Prochors has joined
- 7:35:16 PMXappolBot
- Hello Prochors!
- 7:35:18 PMDeedlit
- yes
- 7:35:21 PMGreagol
- hello
- 7:35:21 PMDeedlit
- Hi Prochors
- 7:35:27 PMProchors
- Hello again.
- 7:37:14 PMGreagol
- so for w+2 i would do something like Hypergraham http://googology.wikia.com/wiki/Hypergraham , for w+3 I would put the same number of brackets as result of the previous number?
- 7:37:20 PMvell
- you missed a juicy as hell discussion about creationism and politics
- 7:37:35 PMProchors
- Awww
- 7:37:37 PM
- D:
- 7:37:54 PM
- At least I have biscuts and Windmill music.
- 7:37:55 PMDeedlit
- not quite
- 7:38:49 PM
- you define a new function for w+2 that iterates the G function (like Hypergraham) and for w+3 you iterate that w+2 function
- 7:42:52 PMGreagol
- for example? i remember i knew it, just wanna refresh my memory
- 7:43:28 PM
- Prochors what particular aspects of large numbers/googology interest you?
- 7:43:28 PMDeedlit
- so we could define G_2(n) = G^n(n) and that would be at level w+2
- 7:43:40 PM
- and then G_3(n) = G_2^n(n) would be at level w+3
- 7:44:27 PMProchors
- Greagol: Two things, the insanity yet persicioin aspect, and the pure unattainability.
- 7:45:00 PMGreagol
- unnatainability?
- 7:45:09 PM
- what's your favourite large number?
- 7:45:53 PMcookiefonster
- back
- 7:45:58 PM
- i was afk, watching tv
- 7:46:08 PMGreagol
- Deedlit, ^ in this case means what?
- 7:46:32 PMDeedlit
- f^m(n) = f(f(f(...(f(n)...)) with m f's
- 7:46:50 PMGreagol
- i see
- 7:47:24 PM
- does it depend on value of m?
- 7:47:32 PMProchors
- Unnatainability as in the inability for it to have physical presence, and that's a tie between Meameamealokkapoowa Oompa and Zootzootplex.
- 7:47:33 PMDeedlit
- yes
- 7:47:40 PMProchors
- Sorry, I was focused on another chat.
- 7:47:42 PM
- ._.
- 7:48:13 PMcookiefonster
- tie between meameamealokkapoowa oompa and zootzootplex?!
- 7:48:19 PMDeedlit
- m is the number of times you apply the function
- 7:48:31 PMGreagol
- prochors well if universe or time are infinite so can these numbers
- 7:48:47 PMProchors
- I guess, but it's hard to prove either one is.
- 7:49:19 PMGreagol
- deedlit i know, but does m=2 transcend to another level like w+2, w+2 just like if m=fin(100)
- 7:49:24 PM
- prochors indeed
- 7:49:34 PMcookiefonster
- it's more interesting to have a /finite/ number that exists in a /specific/ wqay
- 7:49:46 PMGreagol
- cookiemonster i know
- 7:49:53 PMProchors
- Mhm.
- 7:50:06 PMGreagol
- but if the universe is infinite in space and time, it contains every finite number :)
- 7:50:26 PMProchors
- The whole infinite finite numbers thing confuse me.
- 7:50:34 PM
- How can you have an infinite number of finity?
- 7:50:48 PMcookiefonster
- greagol'; io
- 7:50:49 PMDeedlit
- Greagol, advancing one step is going from f(n) to f^n(n)
- 7:51:02 PMcookiefonster
- greagol: cookiefonster*
- 7:51:12 PMDeedlit
- going from f(n) to f^2(n) gets you a larger function, but it doesn't get you to the next step in the FGH
- 7:51:36 PMGreagol
- prochors, just consider ordinals
- 7:51:52 PMDeedlit
- Prochors, it's basically the fact that idea that the whole is bigger than any part
- 7:51:56 PMGreagol
- deedlit so m has to be identical to n
- 7:52:28 PM
- Prochors, if the universe is infinite, Graham's number of particles is just as small as 10
- 7:52:41 PM
- every finite number is just as far from infinity
- 7:52:41 PMDeedlit
- Greagol it doesn't have to be, but it does if you want to go up one step
- 7:53:38 PM
- each number n is the size of {1,2,...,n}, which is just a part of {1,2,3,...}
- 7:53:39 PMGreagol
- deedlit so g(g(g...(g64)))) with g64 brackets would go to w+2 but not with g64-1 brackets?
- 7:53:44 PMcookiefonster
- greagol: in googology, it's not anything new to say "there is no largest number"
- 7:53:48 PM
- we know, and we don't care
- 7:53:52 PMDeedlit
- so each number n is smaller than the entirety of natural numbers
- 7:53:56 PMGreagol
- cookiefonster i know
- 7:54:09 PMcookiefonster
- now here's where sbiis could pull out a fun-to-read wall of text
- 7:54:30 PM
- wow, "fun to read" and "wall of text" sound odd together
- 7:54:44 PMDeedlit
- Greagol - no, g64-1 brackets would basically be one step up
- 7:55:02 PMProchors
- As a Grammarian, when I see "of coarse" in every page of Sbiis', it makes me cringe.
- 7:55:10 PMDeedlit
- but of course if one keeps deviating, it gets more and more difficult to compare it with standard hierarchies
- 7:55:18 PMGreagol
- deedlit how come? how about g63 brackets?
- 7:55:27 PMcookiefonster
- prochors: yeah, his grammar is ... strange
- 7:55:37 PM
- → CosmicAC has joined
Advertisement
Add Comment
Please, Sign In to add comment