Not a member of Pastebin yet?
Sign Up,
it unlocks many cool features!
- Introduction
- Congress people are forced to serve parochial (small scale) interests
- The founding fathers designed the government to be unable to do much by infusing it with checks and balances. It was a product of its agrarian time. This favors the continuation of the status quo.
- The founding fathers wanted the constituon to be able to adapt to modern times, but it hasn't, as amendments are difficult to produce, and fundamental changes to governmental structure aren't considered very heavily.
- The fix is a parliamentary system
- You could also change party primaries and campaign finance.
- Or reduce the importance of Congress. It's too parochial. Make presidents have the front seat.
- Chapter 1
- The founding fathers were very wealthy. That may have influenced the constituon. They were undemocratic by modern standards.
- It was seen that limiting voting through property was good because it prevented redistributionist policies
- Founding fathers were elitist racist sexist slave owners
- Their greatest fear wasn't that of tyranny, but that of majority.
- 10
- The FFs really liked Montesquei, who came up with checks and balances. He also proposed for two houses, one elected by the people and one full of elites. They'd check each other.
- Justices were appointed for life so they could be above politics.
- 20
- America is more diverse and connected
- 77x bigger
- The economy has grown a ton
- They didn't take into account how many foreign affairs we'd have
- The Chinese government became market based, and is now out growing the crusty commie government. Society and gov should stay in sync or bad things will happen.
- The Democrats became the first mass people's party (Jackson) followed by the whigs. Before then, political parties consisted of elites.
- People started to get government roles simply because they performed electoral duties for a party. Made the bureaucracy less qualified and more sluggish.
- 30
- It didn't matter too much, since the gov wasn't really depended on very often.
- But then modernization hit, and government catered less to self reliant urban farmers.
- Tons of immigrants.
- There was an emergence of labor unions and the middle class.
- It ran into growing pains, such as an over concentration of wealth and power, and a free-market economy plagued with "monopolies, price fixing, and trusts"
- Sweatshops
- The Progressives wanted a less elitist and more effective government.
- Woodrow Wilson argued that Congress was parochial in the book Congressional Government. Also attacked the separation of powers. Has good quotes 36
- 16 17 & 19 amendment was progressive handiwork. Income tax.
- They created a bunch of agencies such as the FDA
- 40
- Henry Jones Ford: Only the president can break through the bramble of congressional politics and push national interests.
- Theodore Roosevelt was an agressive and strong president
- Stewardship Theory: Presidents can do anything except what they're explicitly told not to do.
- Progressives basically created the modern, effective government
- Chapter 2
- Congress was at its best during the Lyndon Johnson era
- There was a Democratic majority and no political polarization.
- The Civil Rights Act of 1964 and the Voting Rights Act of 1965 were passed
- Model Cities program: A part of the War on Poverty that concentrated a lot of funding on a small amount of cities, in order to see if the money was able to have a positive impact.
- It was unlikely that it would get passed because it didn't benefit the majority of the senators. The senators wanted to expand the city count to 50, so almost everyone could get a model city.
- It passed but not after a ton of changes that included raising the count to even more than 50. The core idea was compromised.
- Members of Congress are parochial, myopic (nearsighted), and don't see the bigger picture
- There's no overarching and coherent national policy program, but instead countless smaller independent ones. There's a lot of duplication, overlap, and mismatch.
- Parties and committees aren't solutions to every-man-for-himself parochialism.
- The parties have just aligned themselves to match up with parochial geographic interests. The Republican South is rural, agrarian, religious and conservative. The Democratic Northeast is urban, industrial, secular, and liberal. Still serves local interests.
- Congress is unable to take action against pressing issues because there are too many points of failure for a policy
- If a policy is passed, it's ineffective because of all the compromises and accommodations it had to endure.
- Ineffective policies are hard to fix or get rid of, and persist for a long time.
- Serious social issues are unable to be addressed, such as immigration. There's no policy set out on this topic, and the rule of law has become a joke. This is harmful to our democracy.
- Our immigration law keeps high value people out
- Obama's healthcare reform isn't an exception, since they've actually been trying to do it for sixty years.
- It was still an incoherent patchwork mess
- 70
- The tax code is a mess w loopholes served at assisting special interests
- The Tax Reform Act of 1986 removed thousands of special interest tax breaks
- Congress slowly screwed it back up again
- No one knows how long the tax code is
- National School Lunch Program 1946
- Companies lobbied for their products to be used on the menus
- black or really poor kids werent widely served until the 60s
- The Schwan Food Company was afraid pizza was going to go off of the menu because of a redefinition of the nutritional value of pizzas, so they lobbied
- 75
- Every law needs tweaking as time goes on, and nothing is perfect.
- Congress is bad at adjusting and scrapping laws.
- Merchant Marine Act/Jones Act: All things shipped between US ports must use US ships. It was made to help sell off unused WWI ships, but is still used today.
- Pressure from ship companies to keep it
- The New Deal policy of subsidizing crop production is still with us
- It is no longer helping family farmers. It's corporate welfare.
- 80
- The program was axed, but then re instituted, even worse tho
- Aid to Families with Dependent Children gave incentives to have kids out of wedlock, not get married, and break up their family. Targeted African Americans.
- Richard Nixon tried to fix it through Friedman's negative income tax (Family Assistance Plan) but it didn't pass
- Carter tried too
- Clinton replaced it with the Temporary Assistance for Needy Families program which instituted work reqs and time restrictions
- No Child Left Behind (Bush) tested schools nationally and punished those that were falling behind.
- Every Student Succeeds Act made it so testing still happened, but consequences were decided on a local level
- 90
- Government delegates a lot to local govs (Dept of Education) or companies (Lockheed) (student loans)
- Kludgeocracy
- The Constitution wires it so that legislators and the president are very different kinds of political actors that are destined to clash
- Presidents allow us to rise above the parochialism and myopia (95)
- The Interstate wasn't happening until Roosevelt appointed the committee
- 100
- Congress is parochial while presidents are national
- Presidents act presidentially. All products of the system. Trump
- They are long term w legacies 102
- They think about the whole
- 105
- Presidents are under powered and need to compromise at every turn
- Presidents have been making a bunch of institutions to help them have more control, they're listed
- Fierce motivation to make America and in turn themselves great 107
- GWB didn't even care about short term press, just long term 110
- Congress has been shitting up healthcare reform and presidents have been the one creating change 114
- 120
- The ACA is stitched together with compromise and special interests
- The Presidential Quest for Energy Independence
- Presidents lead the charge, Congress blocks
- Project Independence w Nixon
- Energy is the most parochial congressional issue
- Consumer and producer states
- Carter
- Good summarizing quote on energy 128
- George W Bush and Social Security Reform
- Barack Obama confronts Climate Change
- Cap and trade and Waxman-Markey
- Clean Energy and Security Act
- 140
- As presidents, they had all these values (good quote)
- All presidents are expected to behave presidentially 141
- Devised for an agrarian society 143
- President should be able to propose bills to Congress, where they can only veto, not revise. 145
- Permanent fast track authority
- Presidents have been increasing their power through building up their institutions and also executive orders, agreements, national security directives, and proclamations. 150
- Councils committees and offices
- Unilateral actions are no substitute for laws
- Fast track has been used during international trade agreements 153
- General Agreement on Tariffs and Trade GATT
- Executive Agreement: Negotiated arrangements with other nations. Doesn't need to go through Congress.
- NAFTA is too big to be an agreement
- Fast track first appeared in the 1974 trade act 155
- If they fail to vote in time it just becomes law
- Fast track pumps out coherent laws and avoids parochial or special interest
- Presidents unique outlook 159
- You can't reform Congress 164
- Obama tried to pass a bill on immigration reform but they refused to set the agenda to vote on it
- Downsides 168
- It would make it hard for Congress to represent local interests
- Political instability. But the current system is way too stable
- Promotes big government
- Americans don't like the current gov 174
- Founder worship 177
Advertisement
Add Comment
Please, Sign In to add comment