Not a member of Pastebin yet?
Sign Up,
it unlocks many cool features!
- Home
- All Sections
- Search
- StarTribune
- Log In
- Subscribe
- Home
- Local
- Sports
- Business
- Opinion
- Variety
- Obituaries
- Classifieds
- Autos
- Housing
- Jobs
- More from the Homepage
- prev
- Ed Schultz, former MSNBC host and Fargo radio personality, dies at 64
- St. Paul's Handsome Hog chef to compete on Food Network's 'Iron Chef America'
- RandBall: Bjelica is gone to 76ers, but Tolliver is upgrade for Wolves
- Denny Hecker released after serving 7 years for fraud
- Trade war with China is here, and China plans to hit back
- Trump loses effort to block 2 California sanctuary laws
- After social media storm, Duluth's delayed 4th festivities going on today
- Illegal animal traps baited with peanut butter found near trail in Minneapolis
- Raging rivers reach near record levels across southwest Minn.
- Patrol reveals why deadly fire consumed woman's van on Eden Prairie hwy.
- Conagra to close Boomchickapop's Mpls. headquarters, move work out of state
- Ed Schultz, former MSNBC host and Fargo radio personality, dies at 64
- St. Paul's Handsome Hog chef to compete on Food Network's 'Iron Chef America'
- RandBall: Bjelica is gone to 76ers, but Tolliver is upgrade for Wolves
- Denny Hecker released after serving 7 years for fraud
- Trade war with China is here, and China plans to hit back
- Trump loses effort to block 2 California sanctuary laws
- After social media storm, Duluth's delayed 4th festivities going on today
- Illegal animal traps baited with peanut butter found near trail in Minneapolis
- next
- Editorial 16364271
- Editorial: Adoption bill puts birth parents at risk
- Legislation would give adoptees access to birth records.
- July 7, 2008 — 4:03pm
- Text size
- comment0
- share
- tweet
- email
- Print
- more
- Should adoptees have access to their original birth records, allowing them to identify birth parents without their consent?
- A bill before the state Legislature would give some adoptees access to their original birth certificates, essentially elevating the interests of adoptees above those of birth parents who requested anonymity.
- Changing the rules decades after the fact seems unfair, but state rules should balance the rights of all parties by helping adoptees get access to valuable health data without compromising privacy.
- Since 1982, birth parents in Minnesota who choose to give up a child for adoption have been required to fill out an affidavit either allowing or preventing the disclosure of their identities at the request of the child, once that child has reached adulthood. In that time, about one in 10 birth parents have opted to prevent disclosure, according to the Minnesota Coalition for Adoption Reform, which is promoting the "open records" change in adoption law.
- The proposal would apply only to adoptions made before the enactment of the 1982 affidavit procedure. Birth parents in those pre-1982 adoptions who want their identities to remain concealed would need to file an affidavit.
- Heart-warming stories of reunions of adoptees and birth parents receive significant public attention and give open records advocates a strong platform on which to make their case. Meanwhile, birth parents who want their records kept private, almost by definition, lack a voice in the public debate.
- ADOPTEE ACCESS
- Eight states have laws that give adult adoptees full access to their birth records, which lists the names of the birth parents, with three states enacting those laws last year alone. Should Minnesota be next?
- Currently, adoptees who want access to their records can appeal to a judge, who would then weigh the interests of the adoptee against those of the birth parent. That can be an expensive and time-consuming process, but one where a third party adjudicates and requires adoptees to make a case beyond genealogical curiosity.
- Adoptees can also request that their adoption agencies contact their birth parents or provide information such as health histories. Any legislation should give adoptees access to health information even if birth parents choose to remain anonymous.
- The proposed bill would change a sensitive and fundamental aspect of the adoption process retroactively. Doing so could have the unintended consequence of discouraging birth parents from considering adoption in the future, even when it's the best alternative for them and their child, because of concerns that the state might change the rules again in the future.
- The individual circumstances of birth parents and adoptees are so varied that it seems unwise and unfair to completely discard such a key privacy provision in a covenant as sensitive as adoption. Before requiring birth parents to come forward, more should be done to encourage disclosure and require sharing of health information without violating the privacy of birth parents.
- 0
- View Comments
- Down arrowLivefyre
- FROM AROUND THE WEB
- Google May Not Show You This, Enter Any Name
- TruthFinder
- Cardiologist: “This Is What Happens When You Eat A Steak"
- Gundry MD
- Born Before 1969? Claim These 27 “Senior Rebates”
- Senior Discounts Club
- The Facial That Celebrities Say Takes 10 Years Off Your Face
- Town and Country | Hanacure
- Man Turns Old Airplane Into His Home; Look When He Opens The Door And Reveals The Inside
- IcePop
- Illinois: Gov’t Will Pay Off Your Mortgage If You Have No Missed Payments
- Mortgage Quotes
- by Taboola
- Sponsored Links
- More From Opinion
- 12:33pm
- 300 dpi 5 col x 7.25 in / 246x184 mm / 837x626 pixels Michael Hogue color illustration of office cubicles staffed with older workers. The Dallas Morni
- Those open office designs? They may be isolating people.
- New research suggests that walls make the most engaged, cooperative workspaces.
- July 3
- Putting research before politics to curb gun violence
- Texas foundation is off to a promising start with new initiative.
- July 3
- The Supreme Court building is the site of anti-abortion and abortion-rights protests annually on the Jan. 22 anniversary of the Roe vs. Wade decision.
- Readers Write: U.S. Supreme Court and abortion, the court and the president, the Editorial Board and labor unions, 'cabin rental frenzy,' newspaper coverage
- "Respect precedent"? Please do.
- July 3
- ORG XMIT: tms20180702150014
- Editorial cartoon: Drew Sheneman on civility
- To see a collection of work by Star Tribune editorial cartoonist Steve Sack, click here. To see some other syndicated cartoons we’ve published, click…
- July 3
- The autism spectrum: Much progress has been made, but much remains to be done
- Reconvening the state autism task force would be a good, constructive step.
- Top Stories
- Container ships wait to be unloaded at the Port of Oakland on Monday, July 2, 2018, in Oakland, Calif. The Trump administration on Friday, July 6, 201
- Trade war with China is here, and China plans to hit back
- 11:20am
- Trump loses effort to block 2 California sanctuary laws
- 23 minutes ago
- After social media storm, Duluth's delayed 4th festivities going on today
- 55 minutes ago
- Most Read 1 Veterans deserve answers on exposure to burn pits • Editorial
- 2 Welcome news: Ryan Cos. picked to develop former Ford site in St. Paul • Editorial
- 3 Fifty years after a turbulent '68, America still works • Editorial
- 4 Liberian refugees have earned the right to stay in U.S. • Editorial
- 5 'First-in-the-nation' gathering will empower young American Indians • Editorial
- World
- U.S. Secretary of State Mike Pompeo boards his plane at Andrews Air Force Base, Md., Thursday, July 5, 2018, to travel to Anchorage, Alaska on his way
- •US says no softening in stand as envoy heads to North Korea
- •Rescuers race to drain water inside Thai cave before rains
- Nation
- Judge Brett Kavanaugh is sworn into the U.S. Court of Appeals by Justice Anthony Kennedy, right, as his wife, Ashley, holds the Bible during a ceremon
- •Social conservatives express concerns about Supreme Court contender
- •Trump praises military for keeping US 'safe, strong, proud'
- Politics
- Mick Mulvaney, the CFPB interim director appointed by President Donald Trump, announced in January that he would reconsider the rule, delaying its app
- •Consumer protection agency, Congress balk at payday lending reform
- •Report: Emails link ex-Missouri governor, dark-money group
- markets
- get quote
- symbol lookup
- Dow 24324.48 +149.66 +0.62%
- S&P 500 2733.01 +19.79 +0.73%
- Nasdaq 7576.98 +74.30 +0.99%
- 20 minute delay
- last updated 02:42 PM CDT
- New App
- Star Tribune launches redesigned, updated news app
- Star Tribune launches redesigned, updated news app
- The new app works on Apple and Android smartphones and tablets.
- Celebrities
- FILE - In this Nov. 2, 2016 file photo, actor James Woods attends the premiere of the film "Bleed for This" in Beverly Hills, Calif. Woods' agent has
- •James Woods suggests his agent dropped him over politics
- •Scarlett Johansson's plans to play trans man spurs backlash
- Inspired
- Children played on the playground equipment next to the large crowd watching the Johnny Holm Band perform on stage at the Summertime by George outdoor
- •Rotary Club leads the way in improving quality of life in St. Cloud
- •Shakopee woman helps women battling breast cancer with Hope Chest
- poll
- You don't have to travel far up the shore to find great waterfalls. Charlotte Nash takes a photo of Amity Creek Falls along Seven Bridges Road in Dulu
- Poll: What is the best Minnesota road trip destination?
- Twins
- Brewers center fielder Keon Broxton made a leaping catch at the wall on a ball hit by the Twins' Brian Dozier during the ninth inning. Despite a later
- •Twins lose 3-2 to Brewers to end 1-8 road trip fiasco
- •Reusse: When teams like Twins lack a good catcher, it's a sure sign of trouble
- MN United
- Forward Darwin Quintero got the Loons off to a quick start against Toronto FC with a goal in the eighth minute Wednesday at TCF Bank Stadium -- the fi
- •Quintero's hat trick carries Minnesota United past Toronto FC
- •World Cup experience 'a dream' for Minnesota United's Calvo
- Lynx
- (From left) The Lynx's Seimone Augustus, Sylvia Fowles, Rebekkah Brunson and Maya Moore looked dismayed after a turnover during the second half of a 7
- •At season's halfway point, Lynx look like Jekyll/Hyde
- •Sylvia Fowles and Maya Moore look to bounce back vs. Sparks
- Magazine
- Amelia Santaniello cracked up after showing her husband, Frank Vascellaro, a photo of her a college friend had just emailed her. Frank had just announ
- •The Frank and Amelia show: Inside the marriage of WCCO's power couple
- •The Cheryl Reeve Q&A: 'To get real change, you need bold actions'
- Featured Gallery
- Hawks Castle
- See a 'Downton Abbey'-style castle on Lake Minnetonka
- (22 photos) Huge home was once visited by Vice President Dick Cheney.
- Featured Video
- Elizabeth Scott, center, of Minneapolis gets a kick out of puns about the band Abba.
- At new Twin Cities pun contest, word nerds have groan to love it
- At a monthly pun competition, the audience's "awwwws" can rival the wordplay on stage.
- StarTribune
- Follow Us On:
- Facebook
- Twitter
- Google+
- Pinterest
- Instagram
- Tumblr
- Company
- About the Star Tribune
- Contact us
- Work For Us
- News in Education
- City Pages
- High school sports hubs
- Mobile and tablet apps
- Advertise with us
- Talk with a business consultant
- Media kit
- Classifieds
- Buy
- Star Tribune Store
- Photo Reprints
- Archived articles
- Full Page Archive: 150+ years
- Back Copies
- Commercial reprints
- Licensing
- Customer support
- Help and Feedback
- Manage your account
- Newspaper subscription
- Digital access
- eEdition
- Vacation hold/billing
- Website
- Terms of use
- Privacy policy
- Site index
- RSS
- © 2018 StarTribune. All rights reserved.
Advertisement
Add Comment
Please, Sign In to add comment