Kirbin vs. Corvette

Kirbin VS Corv

Both participants here put forward a great showing, each one defending their own character well while aggressively attacking the other. I was interested in the way that they tackled the speed argument with Muteba, with several aspects of the scaling coming into question, and Kirbin managing to defend against the points very solidly when I'm sure other debaters might have had difficulties. Unfortunately for me, my decision on who wins this battle really centers on the part of the debate I hated the most, whether or not Wakatsuki clenching his muscles means anything. Ultimately, I think Corv cast enough doubt on whether or not Indestructible and Wakatsuki flexing his neck muscles were similar enough to scale to (or whether he even flexed his neck before Muteba hit him) to make me think Muteba's piercing isn't relevant by Predalien's standards. This is bad for Muteba, because the Predalien can easily pierce him, something that didn't really seem to be argued against. Most of the other arguments seem irrelevant in the face of Muteba being able to be injured by the Predalien, and the Predalien not really being able to get hurt by Muteba. That seems to make the case open and shut for the Predalien.

Winner: Corv