One Little Wish

>when winter came you were a little concerned about Muffet's well-being
>after all she saved up all that money to help her entourage leave the ruins so they wouldn't freeze to death
>but Muffet was lightyears ahead of you, she was already weaving cute sweaters with her webs, she even made you a cute sweater!
>it was comfy as fuck, perfect for lounging around in
>as winter began to settle in, you and Muffet slowly stopped going outside and just relaxing indoors
>one day you can feel her eyes on the back of your neck as you play your favorite videogame
>Muffet sits next to you and nuzzles her head into the nook of your shoulder
>"Anon, what is that?"
>you explain to her that it's a videogame, but this only puzzles her more
>the idea of using the controller to move people on the screen is a foreign concept to her, but she's curious so you decide upon something
>a date night featuring a cozy fire, some hot chocolate, snacks and some easy vidya to introduce Muffet to your hobby
>she clasps her hands and kisses your cheek, it sounded like a wonderful idea!
>thoughts of you two cuddling next to a roaring fire and playing videogames
>well
>it fills you with determination
>no, not THAT kind of determination
>hours later you two are bundled up together, sharing a blanket and sipping hot chocolate
>you didn't want to overwhelm Muffet so you decided to play some Super Dreemur Bros. since it was straight forward and easy
>she's able to play it rather proficiently so you decide to show her some more games
>in between deaths and trade-offs she nuzzles against you and occasionally kisses your cheek
>eventually she asks if there's anything that you two could play together
>you stand and tell her that there's lots of games that you two can play, you grab an armful of coop games and sit back down with her
>Muffet picks one and you two play together
>it's perfect, just sitting with Muffet and playing some good vidya together
>she strokes your hair with one of her hands while using her others to hold her controller and sip cocoa
>you sigh with content and kiss the top of her head
>her eyes flash with realization when you defeat a difficult boss
>"Hey Anon, are there games where we can play against each other?"
>You quickly explain to Muffet that there are games where you two can compete against each other but you weren't sure if she was ready for it yet
>"Uhuhuhu, are you sure about that Anon? I mean, after all, look at our scores, I've been doing way better than you have!"
>the pixels on the screen tell no lies, Muffet was indeed doing better than you
>it was because of all those arms she had dammit
>you sigh and nod your head, you did have games where you could face each other...
>Goddamn
>Muffet was actually kind of kicking your ass at your fighting games
>even when you told her that she could only use one pair of arms she still managed to win more matches than you cared to mention
>no matter what you do she creams you
>"Uhuhuhu Anon~ I thought you were good at fighting games..."
>Goddamn it, you were!
>She just had an advantage over you, it wasn't fair
>After getting defeated in Ruin Fighter 2: Turbo you decide to bring out the big guns
>beginners luck or whatever it was, it was going to end now
>you use every ounce of what you've had in you to fight against Muffet
>she's a tough fighter, but she's no match for you!
>now you begin to win, much to her chagrin
>Muffet is getting visibly miffed by your winning streak
>the fun ends when she sets her controller down and glares at you
>her eyes pierce your soul and her fangs seem to sharpen
>"You know Anon, you're pretty good..."
>you nod and try to inch away from her as much as you can without it being noticeable
>she leans closer to you
>her nose is touching the bridge of your own
>"But you're facing me with handicaps, I don't think that's rather fair..."
>not fair? her and her arms weren't fair!
>but you weren't about to speak out against that
>after all, she could probably bite your throat out or something
>but goddamn, if she wasn't very sexy right now
>Muffet's voice pulls you out of your imagination spot
>"How about we make this next game more... interesting?"
>caught off guard you nod and hear Muffet out
>a little apprehensively though, since last time you heard Muffet out you nearly lost your dick circulation
>She smiles and you feel the tension in the room drop
>"Alright Anon~ if you win without any handicaps... I'll be your slave for the rest of tonight and tomorrow... Anything you ask, I'll do it"
>Alright, you nod, this was sounding good... but there's always a-
>"But! if I win... I get to tie you up and you get the honor of serving all of my carnal desires..."
>W-what kind of bet was this? It seemed that either way you were going to come out on top. But you didn't want to bring this to her attention
>you accept Muffet's challenge and take a deep breath before selecting a game you were really good at
>this was it
>the sun was setting outside
>the fireplace was providing ambiance
>even though you and Muffet were fighting against each other you couldn't help but feel close to her
>especially since you were sharing a blanket together on a couch nestled into each other
>but that didn't matter!
>the game starts, you select your fighter and she selects hers
>you're both putting your heart and soul into fighting
>she beats you once but you quickly knock her on her ass in the next match
>you're both on the last fight now
>after trading taps and combos you're both at critical health
>Muffet giggles and presses her lips against your cheek
>"I hope you're ready to be my little sex toy Anon~"
>unfazed you chuckle and take a risky break to punch her shoulder softly
>you were going to win this time
>both of you are playing cautiously
>this continues until the timer reminds you that the match is over and if you don't finish now it'll end in a draw
>Muffet seizes this opportunity to rush you
>but you're quick to react and you block her
>buttons clack and trash talk is traded as your characters fight each other
>you squeeze your eyes shut and resolve to keep mashing buttons at this point
>MATCH SET!

You and Muffet are both bent forward, sweating and panting with each other. The fireplace crackles merrily next to you and Muffet's warm body is nestled close to yours. "A tie?!" Her voice is soaked in disbelief, you pry an eye open and sure enough you two had beaten each other into a draw. Then you burst into laughter, of course something like this would happen right? With all of your energy spent, you and Muffet collapse in each other's arms on your couch still giggling at the outcome. Now what were you two going to do, both of your bets were off the table.
"Anon, look... it's snowing..."
Oblivious to your tiny competition the world outside continues, the sun has casting an orange glow around the landscape and now fresh powdery snow begins to send glitters of light all around. Muffet grabs your hand and takes you over to the window, the two of you bask in each other's warmth and admire the wonderful pastoral Earth has given you. "Back in the Underground... We never got to see things like this. Well, sure, there was Snowdin but this..." Her free hands gesture to the beauty and splendor outsides your window. "The sun never rose, the sun never set in the Underground."
...
Muffet's eyes widen in surprise when you pull on a jacket and take her outside on your front porch. She blushes when you sit with her perched on your lap faced against the sun. A gentle breeze whirls around the two of you, bits of snow land in her hair and melt. When you feel her shiver you unzip your jacket and wrap the front around her. Content with the world, you and Muffet watch the sun gently crawl its way behind the trees wrapped in each other's love.
When the two of you go back inside, she makes two mugs of piping hot spider cider and a tray of cookies. You spend the rest of the night snuggling with each other on the couch until she falls asleep with her head nuzzled into your chest...