01. Original Broadway Cast - Overture
02. Sebastian Arcelus, Wendt - Christmastown
03. Sebastian Arcelus - World's Greatest Dad
04. Gumley, Jacoby, Leavel, Wright - In The Way
05. Mandell, Sebastian Arcelus - Sparklejollytwinklejingley
06. Gumley, Leavel - I'll Believe in You
07. Jacoby, Leavel - In the Way
08. Sebastian Arcelus, Wright - Just Like Him
09. Sebastian Arcelus, Spanger - A Christmas Song
10. Sebastian Arcelus - World's Greatest Dad (Reprise)
11. Mandell, Sebastian Arcelus - Nobody Cares About Santa
12. Spangler - Never Fall in Love (With an Elf)
13. Gumley, Leavel - There Is a Santa Claus
14. Gumley, Jacoby, Leavel, McCormick - The Story of Buddy the Elf
15. Wendt - Nobody Cares About Santa (Reprise)
16. Gumley, Jacoby, Leavel, Spanger - A Christmas Song (Reprise)
17. The Company - Finale