Childhood Friends and Pinkie Promises

>Be Anon
>Be sitting at home on a Friday afternoon
>Watching a friend play vidya
>Original Sonic the Hedgehog, to be exact
>The end of the stage draws close, and you stretch out a bit, knowing what's coming next
>"U-Um, Anon, could you beat the boss?"
>You smile as you take the controller from Fluttershy
>As much as the concept of breaking robots to free animals appealed to her, she didn't like beating up Eggman as much
>Or maybe she felt sorry for hogging the game all the time, either way
>It doesn't take long to beat, since you've gotten all the bosses attack patterns down pat, and you hand the controller back to Flutters who squees in delight as she pops open the egg cage to free the animals and end the stage
>This has become something of a ritual ever since you introduced her to the games, back when you were still kids
>You aren't really sure how the both of you became friends with as socially awkward as you both are, but somehow it worked out and you hang out plenty despite the fact that she's gone on and made a bigger group of friends
>Unlike you
>"U-Um, Anon?"
>You realize you've been spacing out, and she's had the game paused at the beginning of the next stage while you mulled around in your thoughts
"Oh, yeah?  What's up?"
>"Um...Are you okay, you know, just having me as a friend?"
>You have to admit, it would be nice to have more, you were just never any good at approaching people
"More friends would be nice, but, you know."
>You just shrug the question off with that
>"Well, um, what if I introduced you to some of mine?  Rarity invited me to a sleepover tomorrow, and said I could invite you, so..."
>Well, that's news
>The hands-down prettiest girl in school inviting a boy to a slumber party?
-
"Erm, really?  I mean, if that's alright with her and you, I can go."
>She smiles a bit, and wraps you up in one of her quick hugs that always end with her eeping a bit and pulling back embarrassed
>Just then you hear your mom calling from upstairs
>"Fluttershy?  Your mom's here to give you a ride home."
>She pouts a bit, probably because her gaming time was cut short, but gets up to shut off the console before the pair of you head upstairs
>As you get upstairs you see your mom waiting, as well as Fluttershy's mom parked and waiting in the driveway through the kitchen window
>You figure you should probably ask right away, just to be sure.
"Hey, mom, Fluttershy invited me to a sleepover tomorrow, could you give me a ride to town for it?"
>She shrugs it off, saying "Sure thing."
>She probably just assumed it was going to be the two of you, with plenty of parental supervision
>It wouldn't be the first time, after all
>You weren't sure what to expect with Rarity added to the mix, though
>We'll just keep that bit in the dark though
>Pretty girls, teenagers, hormones, and all that
>You say your goodbyes to Fluttershy though
>The rest of the day and tomorrow proceeds like regular
>That is, filled with homework and farmwork
>And a bit of vidya
>But then, the moment of truth arrives
-
>Your mom drops you off at Fluttershy's house, and leaves before you can get to the front door
>Boy it's nice that mom trusts her so much
>She opens the door before you have the chance to, carrying a bag of nightly essentials much like you are
>"Oh!  Anon, are you ready to head out?"
>You look to the garage then, noting the seeming lack of activity
"Er, yeah, I assume we're walking?"
>She would nod then, stepping outside, turning out the lights in the house, and locking it behind her
>Huh, her parents are gone
>Way to go mom, you're leaving a pair of teenagers alone together
>Granted, you weren't really sure you even felt that way about Fluttershy
>Even if she did probably have the biggest rack in school
>Wait, hormones, boner, stop
>"A-Anon?"
>You snap out of your thoughts once more as Fluttershy interrupts them
>Probably thankfully this time
>This thought of having a sleepover with Rarity involved too was getting you a bit excited
>You hope her parents are gone too
>"Are you ready to go?"
"Right, yeah, let's go."
-
>The walk to Rarity's wasn't too long, according to Fluttershy
>It was a fairly quiet walk as well
>Not that that was a bad thing
>You couldn't help but fidget a bit as you went though, constantly cracking your knuckles
>Stupid nervous tics, you shouldn't be getting nervous, you should be getting excited!
>In the middle of all this, Fluttershy takes your hand
>You assume she's just trying to get you to stop fidgetting
>Her way of silently saying "It's alright Anon, you're going to be just fine meeting Rarity."
>At least, you think so.
>As you near Rarity's house, you see a car parked in her driveway
>Thankfully not her parents
>The engine is still running, and as you get closer you can see the logo of the local pizza place on it
>The delivery boy also gets out of it, walking up to the door and ringing the bell
>And you see Rarity answer the door
>She was dressed in a rather flattering silk nightgown, the color much similar to that of her hair, which, of course, was done up to perfection, along with her makeup
>The fit of it, meanwhile, left a lot for the eyes, and little for the imagination
>You check to make sure that you're not drooling as she pays for the pizzas
>Though, that looks like a lot of pizza for just you three...
"Er, Flutters, how many others were invited to this sleepover?"
>"Oh, um, all my friends were."
>You can't decide if this got a whole lot hotter or a whole lot scarrier
>That question doesn't linger long though as Rarity notices you.
>"Darling!  You're just in time!  And I see you brought your friend too~"
>Wait a second...What was with the way she said that?
-
>You can't think of that long as Fluttershy pulls you up to the house
>You go right past the pizza boy, still standing where he was, probably just as smitten with Rarity's attire as you were
>And he was still standing there as Rarity shuts the door in his face after you're all inside
>Fluttershy finally lets go of your hand then as she goes to hug Rarity, though not the quick bashful ones she does with you
>They also start chattering about something, and now that you're so close to her, you start to feel awkward
>And so, to keep yourself from staring at them, you try to turn your attention to everywhere else in the house
>Honestly, it was a really nice place, fancy, almost looking like something a rich person would live in
>Though, you weren't sure at all if Rarity was rich, and your tastes were pretty country
>The lights were out on the main floor, and you could hear more girls chattering in the distance, probably the rest of Fluttershy's friends
>You could also hear what sounded like vidya too
>And judging by your intuition, you couldn't feel any parental supervision around
>"Anon, darling, would you be a dear and carry these for me?"
>You're broken out of your thoughts again, this time by a stack of pizza boxes being forced on you
>"Great, now let's get back to everyone else, shall we?"
>And even if that was worded as a question, Rarity and Fluttershy walk off to join the others
>Well, you suppose it's the gentlemanly thing to do to carry things for the ladies
-
>You're led to the basement, where all the other girls have assembled
>Rainbow Dash speaks up as soon as you all come into view
>"Jeez, what took you all so long?  And why'd you bring the pizza boy with you?"
>"He isn't the pizza boy!" Fluttershy chimes in "He's my friend."
>You find the nearest flat surface to set the pizzas down on, freeing up your hands to give an awkward wave.
"Hi.  I'm Anon."
>Getting the stack of pizzas out of your face also gave you free reign to look around the room
>Rainbow was sitting in front of the TV in the room, along with Applejack and Sunset
>They all seemed to be in the middle of playing Smash Bros before you came down
>Twilight and Pinkie were sitting back from them, apparently watching the match
>Though now all their eyes were on you
>Great
>You clear your throat awkwardly, not wanting to sit in the spotlight any longer
>And, noticing everyone else besides you and Fluttershy are in pajamas already...
"Got anywhere I can change?"
>Rarity takes your arm then, pulling you aside to direct you.  "There's a bathroom just down the hall, dearie.  You can change there."
>You just nod, taking your chance to escape the spotlight
-
>Be Fluttershy
>Be nervous
>And excited
>Or nervouscited like Pinkie liked to say
>As soon as Anon left the room, Applejack spoke up
>"Well, shoot, he don't look too bad."
>"Oh puh-lease." Rainbow butts in.  "Way too tall and bulky."
>"Hey now, not everyone has to be an athlete like you, and I'm sure he does plenty 'round that farm he lives on.  Gotta be some muscle there."  Applejack counters.
>"His grades and test scores even rival mine, and that's saying something."  Twilight adds.
>Rarity smiles.  "Quite the catch you got there, mm?"
>You can't help but blush a bit as your friends start talking about him like that
"A-Are you all sure this is going to work?"
>"I promise you and Nonnie are going to leave here lovie-dovers!  Cross my heart, hope to fly, stick a cupcake in my eye!"
>It was reassuring to get a Pinkie Promise on it, but it still felt like your heart was going to beat out of your chest
>Everything was in place though
>All your friends were here, ready to help push you and anon together
>Rarity's parents were going to be gone all night, meaning no interruptions from them
>Even Sweetie Bell was gone, staying with Applebloom and Scootaloo in their own sleepover at Applejack's
>Now, all that was left was...
>"Shouldn't you get changed too, dear?  Don't want to be the only one not in pajamas."
>She's right, you'll want to get changed, you do want Anon to see the pajamas you picked out for tonight right away after all
-
>Be Anon again
>Be nervous
>Still
>And excited
>Again
>Your mind does it's best to come up with more new and exciting fantasies of the possibilities being surrounded by 7 teenage girls could bring
>You wonder if you should have brought condoms as well
>No, that's wrong you think
>These are all Fluttershy's friends
>When you spent the night with her, it was always doing innocent things
>Some vidya, maybe movies, and then mandatory room separation while you sleep
>But then again, there are no parents here...
>You shake your head, trying to get yourself to stop dwelling on fantasies and get changed
>Though, with what Rarity was wearing, maybe you should check out the other girls too...
>Damnit Anon, focus
>You take a deep breath, finally changing into you pajamas
>Plaid flannel pants and a plain t-shirt
>Not much, but they were comfy
>You take one last deep breath, ready to head back out into the fray
>At least, you think you are
>Either way, you open the door and head out
-
>And you're immediately greeted to the view of Fluttershy, now in her pajamas
>And they're nothing like the pajamas you're used to
>Typically, she likes to wear pajamas that near cover her from head to toe, but now...
>She was wearing a t-shirt, though nothing like yours
>It was a v neck t-shirt, and a rather low cut one at that, giving an ample view of cleavage
>It was also rather long
>From the bottom of her shirt down, her legs were bare
>You almost had to imagine she was wearing some short shorts under it
>And then, of course, to top it all off, she had her cute little bunny slippers on her feet
>This is still Fluttershy after all, but DAMN
>You then realize you've been staring for quite some time, and her face is lit up bright red
>You can feel a bit of a blush come to your own face as well as you clear your throat and awkwardly avert your gaze
"Ah, um...s-sorry."
>"Do you...like it, Anon?"
>Do you like it?  You're struggling to keep your boner down and your thoughts pure and she asks if you like it?
>Yeah, you could say you like it
>But can you say that to her?
>You open your mouth, but can only manage to stammer out an incoherent mess of ah's, um's, and nervous laughs
>So no, you guess you can't
>Please, someone, something, save me from this awkward hell
>And then you hear your savior
>Vidya
>You dash back to the party room and grab up a fourth controller before anyone has a chance to stop you
>Nailed it
-
>"Oh, hey there Anon, you wanna play?" Applejack asks
>You very much do want to play, you need to calm down some
>You give her a nod, not sure if you want to trust words right now
>They graciously stop the match they were on, much to the complaint of Rainbow, letting you get starte right away
>And boy does that help you relax
>Throughout the games the girls who aren't playing just watch or cheer the players on
>You even get some cheers yourself, which actually feels pretty nice, especially since these girls barely know you
>You notice that two voices are missing from the cheering section though: Fluttershy and Rarity
>When you focus a bit more intently, you can hear them talking quietly in the background, though you can't quite make out what they're talking about
>That bit of extra focus quickly costs you a life though, and you notice Rainbow jeering you out of the corner of your eye
>Okay, fine, it's on now
>The games continue for some time, the girls occasionally swapping in and out to get pizza, drinks, or other such things
>You don't swap out though
>You need this time to relax
>Plus, you aren't all that hungry or thirsty
>...And cold pizza isn't that bad
>Okay, nevermind, you were wrong
>You trade out your controller, which gets taken up by Twilight
>...Who quickly drops you from 1st place to 4th.  Damnit
>Whatever, pizza time
-
>You approach the guardian of the pizza boxes, Pinkie
>Who appears to be munching on a piece of hawaian pizza
>Truly, a woman out for your heart
>"What'cha want, Nonnie?  Cheese and pepperoni are gone already, but there's plenty of hawaian if you want to share!"
"You must be the one that ordered that, then?  I love you, that's my favorite."
>Okay, maybe those video games relaxed you a bit too much, Pinkie's giving you a funny look
>"I'm not the one you're supposed to be falling in love with, Nonnie."
>Or maybe it's that, but what does she mean by that?
>Whatever, you're hungry, so you grab a slice of pizza from her and sit down
>As you eat your slice, you notice that Fluttershy and Rarity are still sitting back and chatting with each other
>And now that you think about it, neither of them have switched in for gaming either
>"Something on your mind, Nonnie?"
>Well, Pinkie seems a lot less shy about disrupting your thoughts
"What did you mean by what you said before?"
>"What do you mean what do I mean?  It looked like you were thinking too hard!"
"...No, no, the comment before that."
>"Ooooooh, thaaaat comment.  You'll see!"  And Pinkie gives a huge smile to top it off
>Well, that was informative
>You decide to relax with your pizza though, scanning over the room
>You can't help but turn your eyes back to Fluttershy and Rarity on a regular basis
>Their pajamas were pretty sexy in their own ways
>Though, it strikes you that all the other girls' were tamer, more plain
-
>You're once again snapped back to the present by Pinkie knocking on your head
>"Helloooo, anyone home?"
>You cover your knocked noggin with one hand and shoo away your hyperactive nuisance away with the other
>She just giggles as she backs out of shooing range
>You do notice that the video games seem to have run their course though, and the girls are looking for something else to do
>And Rarity seems to have just the solution
>"Is anyone up for a movie?"
>Group consensus seems to immediately come up as 'yes', and so she goes to find a movie to put in
>Meanwhile, Fluttershy walks up to you, taking your hand and pulling you away from Pinkie and the pizza boxes
>Seems she wants you to sit by her
>You don't complain as she pulls you to the back of the room, near where she and Rarity had been sitting before
>In that time, Rarity has gotten a movie in to play and dimmed the lights
>All the other girls are sitting up near the front, leaving you and Fluttershy alone
>She cuddles up to you as the movie starts, and it seems it's some kind of romance movie
>You aren't really much a fan of romance, but you are in a slumber party filled with girls, and admittedly it's better than the Hallmark crap your mom always turns on
>And the whole time, it seems Fluttershy is doing her best to press herself against you
>To the point it's becoming hard to focus on the movie
>And ooooh so much easier to focus on her boobs
>Constantly pressing against you and rubbing against you
>There's no stopping your boner now
>You wonder if she's doing this on purpose though, or if it's just an accident
>You look at her and she seems to be focused on the movie, but she's still grinding her body against you
>Hugging you tightly
>Finally the time comes in the movie where the male and female protagonists kiss
>She looks up at you then, and you can't help but wonder if maybe she wants to kiss you too
>But...Fluttershy?  She can barely hug you normally without getting embarrassed
>You feel conflicted, and finally panic, making a quick excuse about having to use the bathroom before leaving her
-
>Be Fluttershy again
>Be on the verge of tears
>That look in his eyes said he wanted to kiss you
>Or at least you thought it did
>But...But he ran
>"Darling, are you alright?"
>The movie was over now, of course
>The lights were back on, and all your friends were looking at you, concerned
>You quickly wipe the back of your hand over your eyes
"Y-Yeah..."
>That was an obvious lie, you weren't alright
>Even though you've done everything...or near everything Rarity suggested to seduce him, he still hasn't fallen for you
>And she said men were easy
>"Alright, this calls for desperate measures!" Rainbow calls out as she gets up and marches over to her bag
>Nobody has time to ask her what she's doing before she pulls out a bottle of whiskey
>"We tried Rarity's way, now we're trying mine: liquid courage.  Anon is a wimp!  I say we give him some of this, and he'll be all over you in no time at all."
>Most of the girls looked hesitant about trying her method, but not you
>You were out of options, and desperate
"Let's do it."
-
>Be Anon again
>Be sitting in the bathroom
>Also be painfully aroused
>You keep replaying those few moments in your head, again and again, debating back and forth with yourself what you should have done
>Did she really want to kiss you?
>Or did you just think she wanted to kiss you because you were aroused?
>And why was she rubbing up against you so much?
>Is this even Fluttershy?
>Then there's that comment from Pinkie...
>You take some deep breaths to try to calm yourself down
>As much as you wanted to, you can't hole yourself up in the bathroom for the rest of the night
>You just hope you didn't upset her, suddenly leaving like that
>Come on Anon, deep breaths
>And you, boner, shoo
>You take your glasses off and stare at yourself in the mirror
>Get a hold of yourself
>You flush the toilet then
>There wasn't anything in it, but you at least needed to pretend you weren't lying out of your ass
>You then run some water, pretending to wash your hands, but you take the opportunity to splash some cold water on your face
>Then, with hands dried, face dried, and glasses back on, you were ready to go back out
>You hoped
-
>As you get back out to the room, you see that the lights are back on, and the girls seem to be setting up for some kind of game
>Involving cups, cola, and...
>Is that a bottle of whiskey?
>"Okay!" Says Rainbow, as soon as she notices you're back "We're getting to the good stuff now.  Name of the game is never have I ever."
>"We go around the circle and say things we've never done, and the people who have drink."  She finishes
>Well, sounds easy enough, but did alcohol really need to get involved?
>A look around the room shows that all the girls seem to be okay with it, and you really don't want to put the spotlight on yourself being the only one to say anything
>So, fuck it
>You take your spot in the circle of 8, with Fluttershy immediately on your left, and going left from there was Rarity, Twilight, Sunset, Applejack, Rainbow, Pinkie, then back to you
>You are each passed your cup of cola and whiskey, and the game starts
>Things start rather tame, the things everyone saying they haven't done being the sort of stuff that's easy and normal to do
>But the drinks start flowing quickly, and soon, everyone's getting braver
>Things people say they haven't done start becoming lewder
>And of course you're no exception
>And honestly, all this drink is making you take a much closer look at all these girls
>Especially Rarity, who, honestly, as far as you're concerned, is the image of perfection.  Perfect hourglass figure, not too big, not too small, just...perfect
>Though, looking at the others...
>Twilight was a real cutie, slender, but still having some nice curves
>Then, Sunset.  Definitely hot, just the right mix of bust, waist, and hips for a nice hourglass figure
>And Applejack, probably one of the less feminine of the group, but boy did she have a nice ass
>And Rainbow, again not all that feminine, and very slender and athletic
>And finally Pinkie, who is pretty cute, and has really nice tits and ass, even if she is a tad pudgy
-
>Before long, the game was over
>The booze had run dry and everyone was a varying level of drunk
>Twilight in particular probably looked worst of all
>Fluttershy, next to you, was looking a bit sad, so you turned to her and gave her a big hug
>She perked up a bit with the hug
>Well, at least until you opened your mouth
"Thank you...For inviting me..."
>You kept hugging her, but it seems she just went back to being sad
>Maybe that's just the kind of drunk she was, you didn't have enough brainpower at the time to figure it out
>The group decided it was time for bed then, and everyone started stumbling around to set up their blankets and sleeping bags
>Though, with a quick look around you realized there was no Rarity
>You get up, parting from Fluttershy as you go to find where Rarity disappeared to
>It doesn't take you long to figure out as you wander into the hall and see a light coming from under the bathroom door
>You decide to wait there for her
>And it doesn't take her long to come out and notice you
>You open your mouth before she has the chance to say anything
>Maybe it was just the alcohol, and with what Pinkie said...This had to be the reason she let you come to a sleepover with her
"Rarity...I love you."
>It takes a moment for her to fully comprehend what you're saying
>"W-What?  Anon,.."
>You don't let her say any more, though, as you approach her and stop her words with a kiss
-
>Be Fluttershy again
>Be...You aren't even sure how you feel right now
>You may have gotten your hopes up a bit when Anon hugged you
>But he was just being friendly
>You didn't want him to be friendly though
>You wanted him to love you
>He had wandered out into the hallway, and it seemed everyone else had gotten in bed for the night
>You didn't know what else to do, besides...
>Yes, you'll just have to work up the courage to say it yourself
>Anon is out in the hall right now
>Alone
>And you even have some booze in you to help!
>You're sure you can do this
>You get up and make your way over to the hall
>And come just in time to see Anon kissing Rarity
>Rarity pushes Anon off of her right away, his lack of balance sending him right back to hit his head on the opposite wall as she comes running back in
>But this just makes you realize
>He doesn't even like you, does he?
>He just likes Rarity
>Inviting him to this party was a mistake...
>You don't even know if you want to check on Anon right now and make sure he's alright
>The hit to his head didn't look all that hard, but he hasn't moved since he got pushed
>You just want to curl up and cry right now
>But...You can't just leave him there like that
>So, not knowing what else to do, you go sit in Anon's lap and cry into his chest
-
>Be Anon again
>Be seeing stars
>And not the good kind
>Alcohol and a knock to the head are really not a nice combo
>You're actually surprised your stomach is staying put
>Thanks stomach
>Through all this, and through the fog in your mind you notice someone come sit in your lap
>And through the ringing in your ears you hear...crying?
>After the moment it takes for the daze to clear, you look down and see Fluttershy crying against your chest
>You go to wrap one of your arms around her, and as she looks up to you, your other hand goes to wipe the tears off her face
>Your head is in a bit of a mess right now
>You can't think of why she would be crying
>You don't want to see her cry though
>She sniffles a bit after that, speaking up.  "Why couldn't it have been me, A-Anon?  I-I love you, and I want you to love me too, s-so why do you love Rarity?"
>It's slow work, but that starts filling in some of the pieces that were currently missing
>You confessed to her
>Even tried to kiss her
>And then...this
>You try to come up with something to say to her, but it's no use
>She gets up and runs back into the room with the other girls, leaving you still slumped against the wall
-
>After Fluttershy runs off, Rarity comes back into the hall, apparently calmed down from the startle you gave her
>"A-Anon, dear, are you alright?  You didn't hit your head too hard, did you?"
>You go to the back of your head to feel where you hit it
>Tender, but it's not wet, so there's no blood, thankfully
"Yeah, I think I'll be alright...I probably deserved that though, didn't I?"
>"No, of course not...I'm sorry I pushed you like that."
>You want to say that she had every right to, but you figure that's just going to lead to a chain of back and forth you don't really feel like starting
>She would come to kneel down by your side then.  "Do you need help getting back up?"
>You give a little bit of effort into getting up on your own, and there's your stomach with the complaints
>Thanks stomach
"Could you just go get my blankets?  I think I'll just sleep out here..."
>She paused, opening her mouth as if she wanted to object to that, but doesn't in the end
>She just gets up and goes to retrieve your things
>At least she gives you a small apology hug as she returns, before wrapping your blanket around you for you and leaving
>You sigh a bit as she leaves, shifting yourself ever so slightly to get a more comfortable position on the wall and fall asleep
-
>Morning comes uneventfully after that
>Your bed against the wall left you a bit sore, and you aren't sure if it's a hangover or the concussion leaving you with this headache, but you'll live
>Something of a melancholy mood hangs over the group, the rest of the girls all having gotten up before you
>You can see it now that you aren't drunk though
>This was all just some scheme put together by the girls to push you and Fluttershy together
>You aren't sure what to make of Fluttershy's confession to you last night, but you have the feeling she wouldn't want to talk to you anymore after that royal fuck up last night
>All you can think to do is pack up your things, get changed, and head home
>Or, well, head to Fluttershy's house where your mom is expecting to pick you up
>The girls are at least talking amongst each other again, but you don't pay attention to what's being said
>You just want to get back home and get some better rest
>But as you approach the front door to quietly slink out, out of nowhere, the guardian of the door, Pinkie, appears
>"Hold it mister!  You aren't going anywhere!"
>You sigh, too tired to put up with her hyperactive antics
"Pinkie, please, just let me go."
>"No way, Jose.  I Pinkie Promised that you and Fluttershy would leave here lovie-dovers, and there's no breaking a Pinkie Promise!"
"Damnit Pinkie, just..."
>But you can't finish that statement as, again out of nowhere, you're quickly restrained by Applejack and Rainbow Dash
>The three girls then proceed to drag you through the house to a guest bedroom where Rarity and Fluttershy seem to be talking
>At your approach, however, Rarity leaves, you're thrown in, and the door gets closed behind you
-
>To top it off, you can hear what's probably a chair barricade the door, and Pinkie's voice on the other side
>"Now, you're not leaving here until I hear some lovie-dovie'ing!  So, have fun!"
>Well, you definitely weren't expecting that
>You look up to Fluttershy for some kind of answer, but she just silently averts her gaze
>That's helpful
>Well, considering you're still on the floor from where you were thrown, you decide to get up, taking the seat that Rarity had previously occupied next to Fluttershy on the bed
>You look over to her, noticing she's blushing slightly
>Once again, you're somewhat confused as to what's going on
>You thought she'd be mad at you for what you did, or something besides, well, this
>You sigh, figuring that she probably isn't going to start talking
>And you probably have some apologizing to do
"Fluttershy, I...I'm sorry.  I feel so stupid for not being able to see what was going on last night, and even stupider for trying anything with Rarity...I...I don't know what I was thinking."
>She looks over to you then, that small blush still on her face, and a few tears in her eyes
>You scoot closer to her, going to wipe her tears away for her again
"Come on now, don't start crying.."
>Your hand lingers on her cheek after saying that, and she nuzzles into it a bit before reaching up to take your hand in hers
>She looks up at you with those same eyes she gave you during the movie last night
>But knowing what you do now, you can't panic like you did before
>Instead, you did what you should have done last night
>You lean in and kiss her
-
>It was slow starting at first
>Neither of you really had any experience kissing
>So you go slow, appreciating the feel of her soft lips on yours
>Timidity and lack of experience gradually makes way for passion, however, and the both of you quickly get more intense
>It isn't long before the two of you pull apart to catch your breaths.
>You have to ask though
"Fluttershy, are you sure you're alright with this...alright with me?"
>She would nod in response then, her face a bright red.  "Come make me yours, Anon."
>Mission control to boner, you are clear to launch
>With a statement like that, how could you resist?
>You dive right back into the kiss, just as passionate as you left it
>And surprisingly, Fluttershy took the hand of yours that she was still holding and guided it up to her breast, which you eagerly start groping
>You definitely weren't disappointed, except maybe for the shirt and bra in the way
>Let's take care of that
-
>She still hadn't changed out of her pajamas, it seemed
>Not that you're complaining
>Well, actually, you were, it was time to get her out of them
>Your free hand slips under one side of her shirt, and your other hesitantly parts company with her chest to get the other side
>Fluttershy, seeing what you were doing, helps you get her out of it, which is nice considering she was sitting on it
>The shirt gets cast aside, and you take a good look at her bra
>A rather cute faded pink with a little trio of butterflies on one side
>Honesty rather cute, and it seemed fitting for her
>You couldn't stop there though, that had to go too
>Despite the horror stories you've heard, you reach around her back to remove it yourself, even giving her neck a few kisses as you work
>She lets out a soft moan at the kisses, and you get her bra off without too much effort
>What's with all the horror stories about these things again?
>Well, whatever, you've got more important things to worry about
>Like how you're now staring at the finest pair of breasts in the school
>Fluttershy's face lights up an even brighter red at your staring
>"I-Is something wrong, Anon?"
"I just don't know how I missed seeing how perfect you were, Flutters."
-
>You cut your staring off then, your hands eager to dig back into the big, cushiony mounds of her tits
>Going back to groping, exploring, and almost even massaging them
>Your mouth, meanwhile, gives her just a quick kiss before you start kissing at her neck, then down her chest to her left breast
>You can't help but feel like you're teasing her, kissing in circles that draw slowly, slowly closer to that precious areola and nipple
>Throughout all this, Fluttershy can't help but breathe heavier, occasionally vocalizing soft, shuddering moans
>You stop though, just before reaching her areola, apparently in a teasing mood
>She stares at you, wide eyes asking the question her mouth didn't
>You just smile back to her, going back to give her another kiss, nibbling softly at her lower lip as you did, getting a bit of a sharper moan out of her
>But enough teasing now
>Your mouth goes back down to her areola, your tongue tracing rings around it much like you did with your kisses before
>And finally, when you reach the nipple, you suckle on it a little, your tongue flicking the tip of it as you do
>Your left hand gets to work on the other, running circles around that side before your mouth switches sides
>And now that your mouth is busy giving the same treatment to her right, your other hand goes to work softly pinching and tweaking the one your mouth just left
>Judging by her voice now, she's plenty excited, and as much fun as her breasts were, there was even more ahead
-
>As it turns out, she was wearing short shorts under her shirt
>But as of now, those are just another article of clothing that needed to get removed
>You go back to her lips for another kiss, gently pushing her back onto the bed as you do
>Meanwhile, your hands go to the waistband of her shorts
>She understands what you're doing, lifting her hips for you so you can get them off easier
>And so, not wanting to waste time, you pull off her shorts and panties all at once
>You give a passing glance to them before you discard them, but only note the wet spot around the crotch
>It's nice to know you're doing a good job, at least
>She scoots back on the bed a bit and you get down, giving you a better position to look
>And oh, what a view
>Just a small tuft of pubic hair, and the lips of her vulva looked smooth and soft, with no fleshy bits hanging out like you saw way too often in porn
>It almost even looked like it was blushing too
>You reach out to touch it, running a finger up and down the slit, marveling at how hot and wet it was
>And then, with your other hand's assistance, you gently open it up, getting a small eep from Fluttershy, who was likely somewhat embarrassed with the scrutiny you were giving her
>You can't help but want to tease and explore her lower half too, but she cuts you off before you can get started
>"A-Anon?  C-Can I see yours t-too?"
-
>Well, you suppose you wouldn't mind getting some attention in return
>And these clothes were getting a bit claustrophobic
>You stand back up and go to take your shirt off, but she quickly sits up and stops you, apparently wanting to return the favor you showed her
>She gets out of bed, standing in front of you, nervously bringing her hands to the bottom of your shirt before peeling it up, her hands feeling you the whole way up
>You certainly weren't the most attractive man, a bit of pudge covering what muscle you did have
>That didn't seem to bother Fluttershy though, who continued to run her hands over you after discarding your shirt
>But she wasn't quite at her goal yet, and slowly she made her way down to your pants, undoing the button and zipper on your jeans before pulling everything down
>Which, of course, causes the boner that had been ready and waiting this whole time to spring out, eliciting a small gasp from Flutters
>You were sure this was probably just because she had never seen one before, you knew you were just around average in that department
>She brings your pants and underwear down to your ankles though, and you step out of them for her before she tosses them off
>And then she turns her attention to your member
>Bringing her hands up to it, softly holding on as if she was afraid to hurt you
>You run a hand through her hair as she kneels in front of you, trying to reassure her
"You can go ahead, I'll be fine."
>She looks up to you and nods, starting to get a bit bolder as she starts to rub up and down your shaft
>She gradually gets more agressive, and your breathing starts to get a bit heavier, with some soft moans of your own thrown in
>As a bit of precum starts to form at the tip, she even goes in to lick it, possibly curious about the taste
>It doesn't take long before you can't hold yourself back though
>You're ready to go all the way
-
"Fluttershy...I want to go all the way."
>She looks up at you as you say that, letting go of you as she stands back up and wraps her arms around your shoulders
>You give her a quick peck on the lips before she speaks up
>"Anon...I want to too."
>You smile, ready then to just throw her on the bed and ravish her, but you forgot one crucial element
"Wait...I don't have any condoms."
>Fluttershy just smiles, breaking off from the hug and walking to the bed, reaching under the pillow, and coming up with...a condom?
>"It's okay, Anon...Rarity gave me one just in case."
>You can't help but think to yourself 'Rarity, I love you'...Though, on second though, maybe just 'Thank you' will do, you've got a much more attractive girl right in front of you
>You just walk up to Fluttershy, wrap your arms around her and give her your most passionate kiss yet
>It doesn't last long though, because you can't help but throw her up on the bed
>There's a satisfying pomf as she lands, and you quickly sieze the condom from her too
>Again, another thing you've heard horror stories about, but again, it's not too hard to figure out
>You discard the wrapper and get up onto the bed, hovering over Fluttershy
>It was time
-
>You look down at Fluttershy from your position over her
>She looked a bit surprised from the sudden throw up onto the bed
>You go down to give her a kiss, a small apology for that, but at least you thought it was fun
>But once that was over, the look in her eyes told you that she was ready
>You nod to her, turning your attention lower and getting yourself in position
>You rub the head of your member up and down her wet slit a bit before getting ready at her entrance and slowly easing in
>You see her wince with pain though, which gets you to stop
"Flutters?"
>"J-Just keep going."
>You nod to her then, continuing your slow progress into her tight love tunnel
>Until finally, you bottom out
>She still looked like she was in a bit of pain though, and not knowing what else to do, you decide to distract her with some pleasure
>Your hands go back to her breasts, kneading them, while your fingers lightly pinched at her nipples again
>You get some soft moans out of her again, and gradually, the expression on her face softens
"Are you feeling alright now?"
>"Yeah...Y-You can start moving."
>You nod in response, obeying your lover's wishes as you start to pull back out
>The silky embrace of her nether regions felt wonderful as it tried to cling to you, and as you pushed back in, you were eagerly accepted back into it's warm embrace
>It seemed as though Fluttershy was starting to feel good as well, her soft moaning gradually becoming just slightly louder and heavier
>You almost wished this could last forever, but sadly, all good things must come to an end
>As your pace gradually quickened, you could feel yourself coming closer to climax
"Fluttershy, I'm..."
>She knows it's coming too though, and opens her arms up for you, to be even closer as you reached the peak
>You gladly embrace her as you cum, Fluttershy's insides seeming to milk your dick for all it's worth as you do
>And you spend your respective afterglows wrapped in each other's arms
-
>You roll off of her to lay at her side, slipping the condom off of your slowly softening dick and tying the end shut
>Who says porn doesn't teach you anything valuable?
>You both turn to each other and cuddle then, relaxing together
"You know, maybe we should have another sleepover soon...But maybe just the two of us this time."
>She nuzzles up to you in response before saying "That sounds really nice."
>You're then both surprised by the sound of a chair sliding down against the door to the room
>And a startled cry from Pinkie, who also sounded as if she toppled over
>You look into each other's eyes, knowing you both had the same question on your minds
>Was she listening to that the whole time?
>You both get up and scramble to put on your clothes, hearing some scrambling on the other side of the door too
>And, when both of you are ready, you open the door to catch Pinkie doing her best impression of a cartoony 'no, I'm not guilty!' look, complete with whistling
"Pinkie, were you listening to us the whole time!?"
>"Well, it's not my fault you forgot!  I said I wanted to hear some lovie-dovie'ing!"
>Well, shit, she had you there
>Still, she could have left after she heard where it was going
>You sigh in response, turning to Fluttershy
"Flutters, why don't you get changed so we can head home."
-
--Later--
>Luckily, your parents never found out that you hadn't actually spend the night at Fluttershy's
>Though, on the other hand, it didn't take them long to figure out that the two of you had started dating
>Sadly, that was the end of sleepovers
>But dating had it's own rewards
>And you quickly found out you didn't need a night in a house to get frisky
>And you actually got around to buying condoms, just to be safe
>That wasn't the only good thing to come of the sleepover though
>Your exposure to all of Fluttershy's friends started a number of slowly budding friendships
>Though again on the flipside you probably became one of the most envied/hated guys in school for being surrounded by so many girls
>But that didn't matter to you, because you had the only girl you needed

~:Good End:~