EM roles

MAYBE ROLES

General thoughts:
-	Having more 3rds is good, in general. It forces the town to keep guessing on what they are; fewer means that it is more likely there is a fool, ww, lyncher, etc.
-	Non-meeting mafia roles are usually not fun. Games where only nk mafias are left are boring.
-	Variance in game experience is good. That is the sole reason sandbox 12p exists.
-	Scum claims are not necessarily bad. Mafia has to win somehow; if there were no scum claims, town would win everytime.
-	In contrast to the previous point, many scum claims are not fun to play as. A balance between the two is necessary.

Snoop -
	Yes. Unlike mechanic, the role is a little memey. Also, it's far more likely to do something useful like catch a cult or find the masons.
Pathologist -
	Maybe. I don't know enough about this role to say anything, but I wouldn't mind it.
Leader -
	No. Its effect is not fun, unlike lightkeeper, and is not fun to play as.
Invisible Man -
	Yes. It is a pseudo lazy cop, with the tradeoff being that it can hear night meetings in exchange for falsely detecting if the target does not talk.
Agent -
	Yes. A powerful role, but can also be fakeclaimed as with spy, tailor, or ww.
Enchantress -
	No. The role is not fun to play since you can only give one crystal. Crystals don't do enough to warrant it staying in the setup.
Huntsman -
	Maybe. I have no strong feelings about this role.
Secretary -
	No. See leader.
Lightkeeper
	Yes. See leader.
Keymaker -
	Yes. It is pretty much a weaker bs, but that is ok. Keys are an interesting to use correctly.
Butterfly -
	Yes. There are a lot of roles that interact with this role (borgs, illusionist, mimic) so it should be kept.
Trickster -
	Yes. Scum claims that can also be fun should be kept. Often leads to interesting games because of its effect.
Cthulhu -
	How dare you put this on the maybe list.
Cyborg -
	No, until the role is fixed. Then yes.
Nomad -
	Yes. I am surprised that it is here.
Prophet -
	Yes. See Nomad.
Alien -
	No. It is a worse mistle and can rarely win. The most fun this role has is telling people you probed their butt.
Creepy Girl -
	No. This one has been argued thoroughly, so I will add nothing.
Autocrat -
	Yes. See mastermind.
Librarian -
	No. Its effect is almost 100% useless, outside of whispering different things to different people and being easy to contact. Town usually just nls since it is annoying to "broadcast" whispers.
Silencer -
	No. Its effect is not that fun and often can't contribute to the mafia, similar to fiddler. Vote blinking defeats its purpose mostly.
Blinder -
	No. While potentially useful, it is too often weak and has to be carried by the meeting mafia.
Don -
	Yes. Useful for saving a 3rd, ruining a ml, or fakeclaiming gov.
Whisperer -
	No. It only exists to prevent telepath from being auto clear, so both should go.
Spy -
	Yes. A worse tailor, except it can safely coordinate with thirds or fake agent.
Fiddler -
	No. Often it is more of an annoyance than anything since people can still communicate with the fiddled by vote blinking. Similar reasoning to Blinder.
Plumber -
	Maybe. See Pathologist.
Diabolist -
	Yes. Like Voodoo, it has to play smart to get mileage out of its effect but sometimes gets easy kills (noavis, hunter suspects)
Apprentice -
	Yes. This role is strong and works well with a lot of existing mafia roles (tailor, any mafia with a town counterpart, yak)
Paparazzi -
	No. Basically nilla mafia.
Mastermind -
	Yes. While (unfortunately) drastically difficult for the mafia to deal with, its effect leads to a lot of unique games that I would argue are fun.