Not a member of Pastebin yet?
Sign Up,
it unlocks many cool features!
- Federal NDAA and SB 127, "California's NDAA:" Your Due Process Rights At Risk #dorner #StopNDAA #NDAA
- ~~~***@@@&&& NOTE! If you are concerned about what you see being written about here, do what you wish but one thing is for sure, let's not let lawmakers think that they are doing these things without our knowledge. Pound them with faxes, e-mails, let them know that WE KNOW WHAT THEY ARE DOING with NDAA and SB 127, that WE ARE WATCHING THEM, and that we oppose it! Contact link below. http://www.legislature.ca.gov/legislators_and_districts/legislators/your_legislator.html &&&@@@***~~~
- On February 15, 2013, a case was in conference at the U.S. Supreme Court which has import for all Americans. This case is known as Hedges v. Obama, and the plaintiffs have successfully, in a lower court, challenged the ability of the government to exercise the use of the National Defense Authorization Act (NDAA, federal law) to indefinitely detain citizens without charges or trial in a civilian court. The U.S. Supreme Court is considering, in part, whether to eventually permanently enjoin a part of the NDAA – basically, deciding whether or not it should be considered to be unconstitutional and void. Based on my brief conversation with one of the plaintiffs on Feb. 15, the opinion was not expected to be available; the case would, according to the plaintiff I spoke to, likely go back to the “2nd Circuit-- likely in Summer, SCOTUS is just reviewing case” at this stage. As it turns out, the plaintiff was correct: The U.S. Supreme Court released an “orders in pending cases” on Feb. 19, 2013, and the order on the NDAA case stated that “The application to vacate stay addressed to Justice Scalia and referred to the Court is denied.” For this case, and for indefinite detention under the NDAA, this means that there's no injunction of NDAA detention at this time, and the case continues in the 2nd Circuit Court of Appeals – a court that the President and his legal crew used to appeal a lower court decision on the case. Let’s hope the plaintiffs are successful and our due process rights are defended.
- Statistics indicate the pace of grants and the pace of decisions at the U.S. Supreme Court are only increasing, but that there is only one decision from the 2nd Circuit that has been both taken up by the Supreme Court and affirmed (with none reversed, and no significant data to indicate how the Court might respond to cases coming to it from the 2nd Circuit). The NDAA case is unprecedented in terms of its type and scope of effect upon the justice system and the due process rights so, it remains to be seen what the U.S. Supreme Court’s final opinion will be, but it is hard to imagine that especially in light of the trouble that the government has had in lower courts, and the Constitutional importance and precedent for trial by jury, in civilian courts, with charges, that the U.S. Supreme Court will side solely with the government in this case. When the case is eventually appealed after a 2nd Circuit decision up to the U.S. Supreme Court, it is likely that the Court will find a way to balance the matter and elaborate on details of legal procedures for what to do where someone is captured on a foreign battlefield, while acknowledging that for a U.S. citizen who is arrested or accused on U.S. soil, they must be given the same Constitutional rights as any other citizen. (I do not want to speculate about what the reaction of the general public will be if the U.S. Supreme Court were to decide that U.S. citizens should no longer have the right to a speedy trial by jury in a civilian court, and to know charges.)
- Unfortunately, federal law such as the NDAA is not the only threat to due process rights. Evidence has now been found that California has hidden its own legislative attempt to remove citizens’ access to due process within a bevy of seemingly unrelated proposed laws.
- Since the beginning of the 2013-2014 California legislative session, no less than 22 bills have been introduced relating to firearms or guns. There is no question that the California legislature is at this point attempting to come between citizens and their Constitutional rights, but the question has been, how far would they go? Now, it is obvious: The California legislature considers that it can come between you and your right to due process in a court of law.
- In what can best be called “California’s NDAA,” SB 127, which was introduced on Jan. 22, 2013, and was referred to Public Safety Committee on 1/31/2013, proposes the following:
- 1) To create a whole new class of persons who are determined by the State to be a "danger to others," not on the basis of expert opinion or court determination, but by proposed legislative definition, "as a result of a mental disorder or mental illness."
- 2) It expressly states that the bill would "remove the authority of a court to issue a certificate for that person to possess a firearm or any other deadly weapon." (Here the Legislature attempts to actually remove the power of the courts to evaluate whether or not something is legal – and it is clear that the legislators authoring and sponsoring this bill are literally attacking the rule of law.)
- 2)a) The obvious problem here is twofold, one in that the proposal is so broad as to cover literally any weapon that one could imagine, and two, and this is where the matter should be very significant for all civil liberties groups, that the proposed bill actually suggests "remov(ing) the authority of a court" to review a person's status. For the reader’s information, the list of categories of persons who are considered to be prohibited either temporarily or permanently prohibited from possessing a weapon (a two page list, extensive) can be found at: http://oag.ca.gov/sites/all/files/pdfs/firearms/forms/prohibcatmisd.pdf
- One of the categories shown under California’s existing law for prohibited persons, is:
- “Any person who is found by a court to be a danger to himself, herself, or others because of a mental illness”
- The key difference between the existing law and the proposed law (SB 127) is that California’s existing law, of course, allows for review and finding by a court. This is because of due process requirements of our Constitution.
- 3) Under (proposed) SB 127, due process is proposed to be removed entirely by California state statute for anyone who could be construed by the State legislature or law enforcement, to fall into the category of someone who may have a "mental disorder or mental illness."
- 3)a) It should be noted that there is currently a legislative push at the federal and state level, to move the standard of review for involuntary civil commitment law from "danger to self or others" to "need for treatment." This clearly not only targets disabled persons but wraps up in it the possibility that persons who are not disabled could be labeled as having a "need for treatment" based on a political predisposition of the State and thus could be hustled away to jail or institutionalized (again, if this bill is passed, there would be no ability for a court in California to review a decision to commit or imprison someone). This will not only be used against persons who own guns, but will be used to chill speech and punish and imprison activists of all stripes. The push toward this approach (of imprisoning people without due process based only upon a "need for treatment") is thought to have begun with a recent suggestion by Charles Krauthammer, who wrote an article suggesting it, but the reality is that involuntary civil commitment (ICC) laws, have been used extensively for some time by law enforcement while engaging in abuse of discretion. As a disabled individual living a perfectly normal life, with full mental capacity, I find these laws, and their use, to be inappropriate and unconstitutional in many ways. I have never been institutionalized, yet I am aware of the fact that it happens often, that others suffer it unnecessarily, and that the powers of ICC laws, the 72-hour hold, and longer (indefinite) detentions are frequently utilized, and we do not hear about them ~ possibly because so many are not given a chance to appeal the decision of what is happening to their lives.
- The reason that the actual effect of the proposed SB 127 (which would be to remove due process and appeal rights of the individual in California courts) is made difficult to see, is because the bill is couched in terms of “firearms,” “disordered persons,” and “sex offenders,” terms which are easy to see and support legislation to regulate ~ but which obscure the true implications of the proposed law.
- The text of the proposal reads:
- “No person who, after January 1, 2014, has been adjudicated by a court of any state to be a danger to others as a result of a mental disorder or mental illness, or who has been adjudicated to be a mentally disordered sex offender, shall purchase or receive, or attempt to purchase or receive, or have in his or her possession, custody, or control, any firearm or any other deadly weapon.”
- Examining this closely, all that is necessary under this proposal is for a court to recommend that you are a “danger” for you to have no recourse in the courts of California – no due process rights to appeal the determination.
- Outside of the court, under existing procedures and law, a law enforcement officer could advise that you be placed in a 72-hour hold, and / or be held for a further period under the State’s ICC laws. Historically, in California, people who have been subjected to this, have had recourse in the courts so that they can contend with, and appeal, any determination that the officer, a psychiatrist, or a lower court may render in such a matter. California's Lanterman-Petris-Short Act, passed in 1967, gave legal rights to those who previously could have been locked up indefinitely and treated against their will. Yet even with this in place, many are locked up against their will: According to Randall Hagar, a task force member of the group that worked last year to reform the Lanterman Act and director of government affairs for the California Psychiatric Association who commented on this to the LA Times in April of 2012, “I'd go so far as to say that involuntary treatment has increased since implementation” of the act. “Nearly 200,000 people in California get their outpatient services every year in a jail setting,” he said. "Something is really wrong with this picture.”
- It is clear, therefore, that the Lanterman Act is in need of reform, yet the proposals under SB 127, “California’s NDAA,” which would remove due process and appeal rights existing under the law, would simply result in a greater level of imprisonment of numerous people who have no place in our prison system, with those subjected to abuse being able to resort only to Constitutional challenges against the law itself were it to pass and be implemented – just like what has happened with the federal NDAA case which has recently gone up to the U.S. Supreme Court. Furthermore, as such laws are often used and stretched well beyond their purpose, it is extraordinarily likely that a broad range of people will be swept up, and deemed a “danger” based on political expediency, abuse of discretion, targeting of vocal activists, or any other number of reasons. Yet, no matter what we think of the law’s purpose, or of those to whom this law would supposedly apply, this attempt to create a statutory obstacle between a person and their right to due process and the system of appeals inherent in the courts, truly reveals the level to which the California legislature would stoop.
- From the April 8 2012 LA Times story on the LPS Reform Task Force report, “The report has provoked outrage, most notably for its push to redefine "gravely disabled" to include an individual's “capacity to make informed consent to treatment and assess their ability to care for their health and safety.” “If I could send a message to the Task Force…I would like to tell them to please keep their mental health laws off my body," said Charmaine Asher of Yorba Linda, 25, who has been diagnosed as suffering from major depression and treated against her will.”
- To understand why we have come to this disturbing point in which the federal government (Congress and the President) have signed into law elements of the NDAA in 2012 and 2013 that are offensive to our due process rights, and where now, we see certain California legislators apparently mimicking this approach in proposed State law, we need to look back into our 9/11 history to understand how those events shaped legislators’ attitudes toward laws relating to our due process. During both the Bush era and now, during the Obama Administration, there have been attempts by government to claim that the AUMF (Authorization for Use of Military Force, the joint Congressional resolution passed on Sept. 14, 2001) extends throughout the United States. The White House claimed in 2005 that a broad and sweeping authority to monitor U.S. citizens here and abroad was implicitly granted in the joint Congressional resolution authorizing the use of force passed shortly after 9/11. But in the Washington Post of Dec. 23, 2005, Senator Daschle stated that the Bush administration requested, but was denied, the authority it now claims it was granted. I quote Daschle: "Literally minutes before the Senate cast its vote, the administration sought to add the words 'in the United States and' after 'appropriate force' in the agreed-upon text. This last-minute change would have given the President broad authority to exercise expansive powers not just overseas -- where we all understood he wanted authority to act -- but right here in the United States, potentially against American citizens. I could see no justification for Congress to accede to this extraordinary request for additional authority. I refused." Numerous other legislators did, as well.
- As Daschle's statement makes clear, the legislative extent of the AUMF was never expressly granted by Congress to extend implementation of the powers within the United States. But don’t take my word for it: Even the CRS report on the the AUMF – a report issued by Congress itself – confirms this. ( You can find a copy of the report here: https://www.fas.org/sgp/crs/natsec/RS22357.pdf ) Yet the Obama Administration has tried very hard to make the case that the AUMF does allow it sweeping powers within the United States, both in the NDAA detention case, and now for a Cybersecurity Executive order. Clearly, the AUMF does not grant President Obama the powers within the United States that he claims, as a brief study of the issue confirms.
- Many legislators have been unable to escape the “9/11 attitude” even when they personally acknowledge that in a post-9/11 world it is especially important to stand up for American values, including the rights expressed within our Constitution. Their fear of change in society causes them often to react in knee-jerk ways to attempt to individually or collectively restrain rights, in hopes that this will somehow hold back the march of progress or time itself. It will not. The world will change, and we will change with it. But we can continue to respect each other as we do so. To begin with, lawmakers of today should start by ensuring that no action they take ever infringes upon the fundamental Constitutional rights nor attempts to lash out against other branches of government due to fear of the effects of the system of checks and balances upon which we have relied, rather successfully, for so long.
Advertisement
Add Comment
Please, Sign In to add comment