Kirbin vs Shrekosaurus_Rex


This is a really difficult debate to judge. Both debaters have essentially the exact same position, and one side being better than the other is on insanely thin margins.

Shrek is arguing that Graviton's gravity squeeze can essentially just instantly kill MechaGodzilla due to its size. Kirbin is arguing that MechaGodzilla's beam instantly kills Graviton. Both debaters essentially just have the counterargument "nah my character just tanks it."

I think Graviton would've been helped a lot by like, some kind of argument involving him being able to use his small size to evade MechaGodzilla's attacks, but the strategy here generally consists of Graviton just blocking attacks with his shields.

With that in mind, I think Kirbin has a stronger overall case. He argues vaguely effectively that MechaGodzilla has more than one vector of attack, and that Graviton needs to focus to do his big gravity squeeze. Furthermore, Shrek argues that Graviton will target only a specific portion of MechaGodzilla, which leaves other portions free. If Mechagodzilla's head gets targeted, he can use his tail or missiles. If his chest gets targeted, he can use the beam. I think kirbin creates enough doubt that Graviton can kill MechaGodzilla faster than any one of these options would come out and stop him from gravity squeezing.

Kirbin wins