Guest User

Untitled

a guest
Jul 10th, 2023
127
0
Never
Not a member of Pastebin yet? Sign Up, it unlocks many cool features!
text 8.16 KB | None | 0 0
  1. Ok, I will turn down the snark, but I feel like I was just using the tone you were using against Eirikrjs here. You called him "racist", you said you would address his "ignorance and lies", you even accuse him of never even playing SMT in the first place. I don't think this post was made in good faith. If you had simply shared your view that you think this is about the Christian Kabbalah instead of framing it as an objective debunking full of insults to someone else, I don't think anyone would complain at all. Still, sure I will be more polite than you were to Eirikrjs.
  2.  
  3. This time I'll try to divide my argument into different points, if you are going to respond, please address them as I'll lay them out, so we can have an orderly discussion.
  4.  
  5. POINT 1: We have the documents you posted on the end of the article from Atlus. They speak only of the Sephirot. Not of the Qliphoth. A big part of your argument is about the difference between the Sephirot and the Qliphoth, I would say it's even a central point, since it's why you say Eirikrjs's interpretation is wrong. Yet the documents make no mention of the Qliphoth. The Atlus documents show no indication that they were using the Qliphoth specifically, only the Sephirot.
  6.  
  7. POINT 2: You raise some questions about the interpretation of the Kabbalah being used as a journey to Kether, yet that is exactly what is depicted in the documents you posted.
  8.  
  9. POINT 3: As you yourself mention in the passage "The Qliphoth variant of Binah, Satoriel", the Qliphoth had their own names, separate from the Sephirot. If Atlus so clearly wanted to invoke the Qliphoth instead of the Sephirot, it is a strange decision indeed to not simply use those names.
  10.  
  11. POINT 4: The Menorah Demifiend received along the game have names like "Menorah of Foundation" and "Menorah of Beauty". Their names match the meanings of the Sephirot, not the Qliphoth.
  12.  
  13. POINT 5: You point out that Eirikrjs doesn't know about the 32 paths of wisdom, only the 22 paths of the Tree of Life. Yet the difference is merely that the 32 paths of wisdom include the 10 sephirot, so it doesn't really change his argument in the article that some of the Kabbalistic "journeys" depicted like the menorah collection order and placement orders don't fit within the paths of the Tree of Life.
  14.  
  15. POINT 6: You argue that the fact that 6 out of 11 fiends being Christian-themed means that this is all about the Christian Kabbalah. I find this on its face a bit confusing since if they wanted the Christian theme to be so obvious, surely they would simply make all 11 Christian. I would give you that Dante can just be an exception but it's bizarre to include Buddhism and real world gang references if that was their intent.
  16.  
  17. POINT 7: Christian Kabbalah never developed as a huge field of studies the way that Jewish Kabbalah did. You say a lot of times in this article things like "Christian Kabbalah considers this and that" but what exactly is the source that you are using? There have not been too many prominent Christian Kabbalists and they often have extremely contradictory views. Sure, there's variation within Jewish Kabbalah as well, but they do at least basically converge on what's on the Zohar.
  18.  
  19. POINT 8: A lot of your interpretation seems to come from this website specifically: https://theomagica.com/on-the-nature-of-the-qlippoth, from my brief search, it seems like he does not have academic credentials related to the Kabbalah, only in Communication and Psychology. So already, there's a red flag there, but also, he does not specify when he is talking about Christian vs Jewish Kabbalah. In fact, if you look at his sources, you will see that they are overwhelmingly about the Jewish Kabbalah. There are in fact, more sources about the esoteric Hermetic Kabbalah than about Christian Kabbalah, and judging from the rest of the site, it seems like that esotericism and occultism are his main interests. So I ask, how do you know that the interpretations you pulled from the site are specifically "Christian" and not from other points of view?
  20.  
  21. POINT 9: A lot of your interpretations seem to come from a past version of the qliphoth article on Wikipedia accessible here: https://web.archive.org/web/20210506024338/https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Qliphoth
  22. Most of the information there comes from one book by Bill Heidrick which was later removed from the article for not being an adequate source. Furthermore, Bill Heidrick also writes from an esoteric Golden Dawn perspective, as you can see in his own website: https://www.billheidrick.com/, not from a Christian Kabbalah perspective.
  23.  
  24. POINT 10: A lot of your post is about the specific interpretation on how the qliphoth match each of the fiends. I honestly don't have the energy to go through all of them so broadly I'll point two problems:
  25. 1. You are using a lot of sources which are not necessarily based on Christian Kabbalah.
  26.  
  27. 2. Most of the interpretations seem like a stretch to me anyway. Being a fellow skeptic, I'm sure you're aware of the way people sometimes will make roundabout interpretations to fit their life into some tarot card reading for example. Most of the Qliphoth have negative meanings, so it's not hard to find some vague connection of those qualities to evil demonic forces.
  28.  
  29. To give a couple of examples of problematic interpretations: Hell Biker representing the "The Filthy Wailing Ones of God" seems like a gigantic stretch just based on his motorcycle and also ignores the rest of the paragraph of the book "The Kabbalah & Magic of Angels" from which you got that, where Samael, the Qliphoth equivalent of Hod, is described as a giant serpent with twelve wings that rules over two million fallen angels. Doesn't really sound at all like what we have in the game which is just a reference to a real-life biker gang.
  30.  
  31. Another one would be in the section talking about Kether, where you don't mention the primary meaning of Thamiel (the qliphoth equivalent) listed on "The Kabbalah & Magic of Angels" which is that it represents duality, a division of the godhead, a fracturing of something that is supposed to be One. This description doesn't match Pale Rider and it feels like a bit of selection bias to include only the parts which you can fit into your theory.
  32.  
  33. At the end of the day, like I said earlier, you could shift those qliphoth around to the other fiends and still come up with some roundabout way of how they work. Thagirion represents ugliness? Well, they're all rotting skeletons so it fits any of them. Golachab represents desire to destroy? These are all evil demons fighting each other for menorah anyway. You will not find actual strong connections between the fiends and the Qliphoth. "The Kabbalah & Magic of Angels" even mentions a bunch of demons which are actually related to the Qliphoth like Belphegor and Satan. These demons are in SMT already, why not use them if they wanted to be accurate to the Qliphoth?
  34.  
  35. EXTRA POINT: This is not intended to be a formal argument, but more of an observation on this whole thing. Pretty much Eirikrjs's entire point is that Megaten just uses the Kabbalah imagery and concepts to be "cool" without fully integrating it in a way that makes sense. Is that so hard to believe in a series that depicts Thor siding with the US army or the Egyptian god Seth as being one half of Satan? You claim in this article that you don't think much of superstition and mythology aside from its entertainment factor, well, it seems to me that Atlus thought the same and just picked a bunch of stuff from different sources and just mixed them in a way that looked and sounded cool without doing a ton of research about it. I actually think there is nothing wrong with that, but if someone wants to criticize these games as a poor depiction of Kabbalah or whatever other mythological/religious beliefs, that is a fair criticism. It's not one that affects my personal enjoyment of the games, but people are entitled to their opinion and if they want accurate portrayals of religion and mythology, Megaten is just not for them.
  36.  
  37. CONCLUSION: I think there is basically zero evidence that Nocturne intended to utilize Qliphoth instead of Sephirot and actually zero evidence that it was supposed to be a specific Christian interpretation of the Kabbalah instead of Jewish.
  38.  
  39.  
  40.  
Advertisement
Add Comment
Please, Sign In to add comment