Coco vs Ken

Round 2
Coco vs Ken
Response 1
Coco
* Wesker strong
* Wesker tough
* Wesker fast
* Wesker has a gun and is skilled
* Death is strong, durable, fast, skilled and can teleport.
* Hody is strong, bites hard, tough, and fast.
* Wesker beats Guts.
* Death beats Tak.
* Hody Beats Scorpion
Ken
* Coco's proposed 1v1s are totally moot.
* Team Ken has imitative
* Team ken fast
* Team coco anti-feats
* Hody/Wesker won't shoot anyways
* Team Ken zones out team coco
* Team Ken pierces good
* Team Coco sucks at resisting piercing

Response 2
Coco
* Guts anti-feats
* Scorpion is slow as shit
* Tak has no piercing and is the only good person on Ken's team
* Ken's anti-feats for Wesker are invalid
* Wesker would use his gun
* Death is stab proof and has good bullet time
* Hody is fast
* The 1v1s Coco proposed are still valid due to that just being proximity

Ken
* lolcocodumbXD
* Guts isn't slow
* Wesker is inconsistent
* Guts cut good
* Guts tanky
* Death sucks
* Hody sucks
* Berserker armor isn't a debuff
* Wesker doesn't use his guns
* Hody's scaling sucks

Conclusion:
Alright. Well, I think Ken wins. For one, Coco's initial condition just straight up doesn't work, which is a colossal point against him as mentioned because no one can see each other. If your description of combat flow is off, you're off to a bad spot but this isn't exactly unrecoverable. The issue is however that Coco doubled down rather than acknowledging the change, which doesn't help.

That said, I think Ken deconstructed Coco's team better than the other way around. While I think some feats were just 'fodder' and thrown in to get told 'nuh uh', there are a few things where I agree with people's assessments. I think the scaling to how One Piece setting uses flintlocks was a major detail for one. That said, I don't think Ken was completely flawless in execution. Mostly because I don't really buy his Wesker anti-feats for stats, only that Wesker isn't a perfectly bloodlusted creature that will always do what is best in the situation.

That said, I think Wesker is really Coco's only good character. Hody's scaling is non-existent, and Ken points out Death's speed is pretty bad as well. Because Ken actually had a strategy that worked and his team's stats were protected better, he wins.