Not a member of Pastebin yet?
Sign Up,
it unlocks many cool features!
- In the vast endless darkness of the ocean floor, Fishman Island was an oasis of light and fresh air. And yet, though it possessed that which was coveted by the fishmen and merfolk who inhabited it, its position was also something of a curse. Thousands of meters above was Mariejois, home to the core leadership and figureheads of the World Government, who's laws and systems had oppressed fishfolk for centuries. Even as amends were slowly being made, (Jinbei given a Warlord position to improve bonds, and slavery being abolished on paper some 200 years ago), little of that hatred had truly been addressed. Right under the nose of Marine Headquarters was Saboady Archipelago, a hotbed of trade in the market of human trafficking, the illegal acts allowed because it was desired by those at the top, regardless of the letter of the law.
- Even though the humanity dominating the world had no direct influence on Fishman Island, lacking any particular Marine presence or other authority that could defend it from the criminals or pirates it was plagued by, that went both ways. Among the ranks of the Marines, dozens of named characters and an uncountable amount of background ones, not a single one appears to be a Fishman. Whether none decided to enter those ranks, or none was ever allowed to, along with the rarity of Fishman Island's representation at the Reverie, occurring only once around when they were first recognized as people, and again during the story itself, it all paints a telling picture of the place Fishfolk have in the world around and above them. Without much of a say in governing matters, they are beholden to the humanity above. Slavery and pirate raids were not stopped, only stemmed, by the flag of Whitebeard, a pirate capable of giving protection where the Government failed, only for it to be replaced with the flag of Big Mom after his death, the less kind ruler demanding goods in exchange for a word of protection, but never an act: the Sun Pirates served her directly, after all, and none of her men made their presence known during the crisis, only once the water had settled. Though the Fishfolk had suffered constantly and deeply at the hands of humans, never did a human representing of the world at large ever look at them like beings worthy of attention, just objects to be bought and sold. Why should they be pushed to try and understand humans when humans had never tried to understand them?
- Those feelings, though not brought up by the masses in the light of Fishman Island, were given plenty of room to drip down into the Fishman District, a place away from the air and light of Fishman Island, where humans could not easily traverse. The blood that was spilled above trickled down into the hearts of those who lived there, who gladly cursed humans and the Queen who spoke kindly of them. Those who'd been empty, given nothing, instead took from what was around them. There were no humans in that underwater domain, where the light Otohime offered did not shine, the Queen never reaching out into that darkness. That was the environment that gave birth to Hody Jones and the New Fishman Pirates, for nothing had happened to them. They'd never been attacked, marred, or enslaved, yet their hatred was expansive. The pain in those around them who'd suffered or known others to suffer became theirs. They desired the darkness. Where Otohime wanted Fishfolk to tread into the light, Ikaros feared it. Daedalos had been dried out by the sun, therefore he too believed that, like the sea creatures they were, they were unfit for the surface, his comrades too accepting that darkness. The sun is a symbol recurring in the series, one of the dawn, of tomorrow, yet the New Fishman Pirates, by rejecting that tomorrow, cling to the past ills that still plagued Fishman Island. And for the acceptance of that darkness, that blindness, Hody's plan could be said to be doomed from the start. Hyouzou touted his strength as the best swordsman of Fishman Island, the second best being Hachi, a swordsman of little particular skill. For Hyouzou's ignorance in how far humanity's strength could reach, he was merely a frog in a well. Hody Jones, decently powerful among Fishmen and even more so with use of the drugs he'd developed, earnestly believed he could wreak havoc at Reverie, a location we come to see being defended by Fujitora, Ryokugyu, and Cipher Pol 0, powerhouses who would have likely made short work of Hody, who even loaded with drugs could not hold a candle against a Luffy restricted by his environment, one that prevented him from utilizing his strongest moves, like Gear 4th. In comparison, Arlong, who did go into that outside world, meeting the likes of Borsalino, did not challenge Mariejois, but instead went to the East Blue, the weakest of seas, settling for oppressing the weakest of humans for his ends. For Hody Jones, being a frog in a well himself, his plan was doomed before it could begin to reach that point.
- That lack of understanding of humanity was all too fitting for how the New Fishman Pirates operated, their narrative one of perfection. Fishfolk were blessed with power from the sea, natural power that fit the ocean-dominated planet of theirs better than landlocked humans. Arlong dictated the conflict as a holy one, Fishfolk and their god given power leading to their oppression as the result of human envy. And that was their framing: Fishfolk were inherently superior, and could do no wrong, while humans and human sympathizers were the enemy. Hody was unmistakably evil towards humans, using them as slaves much like the Heavenly Dragons did to Fishfolk, sparing no lives or livelihoods. But it was fine: a fishman could do no wrong if it was for the cause of crushing the humanity that was far worse. That black and white view left no room for mistakes or nuance. Zeo refused to let his actions be construed as anything but perfect, twisting his errors into secret masterstrokes, for otherwise would put them on the same level as the endless failings of flawed humans and intrude on the absolute righteousness of their cause. And perhaps the deepest irony of the group was mentioned by Dosun. As they rejected a deeply flawed humanity, Dosun placed the accountability for the New Fishman Pirates and their actions not on themselves, hollow as they were, but on the humanity that pushed them into attacking and usurping their own kind. For the actions of many humans, the New Fishman Pirates condemn all of them. By placing accountability on those humans for being human, Hody and his crew, though never having been slaves, ironically let themselves be controlled by the humanity they were prepared to lash out against. Daruma was a destroyer of human establishments without a shred of thought for consequence. In destroying the factory for Big Mom's sweets, he would incite her wrath that Luffy would have to bear. Though Hody proclaimed a desire to be ruler, first king of Fishman Island, then Pirate King, ruler of the seas, he was capable of producing or maintaining nothing, only destruction, his brief attempt to command Fishman Island, nearly bringing it to absolute ruin.
- Trapped in the darkness, surrounded by a will only to destroy, Hody Jones is a far cry from Arlong. Though Arlong was filled with hate, his experiences were at least, his own, and as a result he was far more capable in ways Hody couldn't match. Where Hody could only destroy, Arlong commanded Cocoyashi through Arlong Park. Though its design evoked a desire for the majesty of human constructions, it was one in service of the fishmen in his crew, folk Arlong legitimately cared for. Tiger was a hero to him, but in the wake of his death, the story he spread was fabrication, a narrative twisted for a particular purpose. Arlong wanted Fishfolk to resent humans, and he succeeded, Hody accepting the story at face value, even if it further separated him from the Fisher Tiger of truth. Tiger had truly died keeping his hatred hidden so that it would not be inherited. By hiding those feelings he was able to save Koala, a human he despised learning to care about Fishfolk, to the point of learning their fighting style and joining a group resisting those oppressors. But through a story ignorant of Tiger's desires, Hody Jones inherited everything Tiger didn't want to be passed down. Truly hating those evils, whether they were committed by the Fishfolk he loved or the humans he hated, Tiger would not stoop to them, refusing to kill or further spread hatred that would cause more pain in his best effort to overcome himself. The princes once said that strength can be obtained by overcoming hatred and pain. Tiger and the Sun Pirates battled and experienced pain and loss, but Hody had nothing, so he had to find his strength elsewhere.
- The Energy Steroids were a corruption. In exchange for temporary strength, the New Fishman Pirates destroyed their bodies steadily, feeding into their destructive mindset where their lives were but a means to an end. And yet those drugs were also a rejection of their own ideals. Arlong and his crew battled Luffy with a heavy reliance on their racial attributes, those god given abilities they believed put them above humanity. But those attributes couldn't stand up to the weight driving the Straw Hats who defeated them, who placed no particular value on blood, overcoming the limitations of their race and putting more weight on who they are rather than what they were. Hody too seemed to evoke this same ideology, destroying human pirates while shackled, those chains symbolic of the oppression they faced at the hands of humans, his performance a statement that even with that oppression, the power of fishfolk in their natural habitat far outstripped humanity. Against Zoro, one who'd already demonstrated how racial attributes didn't make up for inability in other areas, revealed Hody's weakness, easily defeating him even in his natural environment. It was only through those steroids that Hody was able to make up the difference, even if doing so only revealed how little his own natural power was truly worth, the temporary measure possessing long term consequences for his inability to overcome himself.
- Though flawed, Hody Jones, as the personification of the darkness of Fishman Island, would always be a threat to the light as long as he continued to go unrecognized. Queen Otohime stood in the light, always looking to the light. Fishman Island was on a sea floor surrounded by darkness, the sky far above possessing a light they could not imagine. She spoke from the heart, aiming to inspire the populace to move to that sun, to find the courage to connect with humanity and better understand them, healing that long rift between the two races by pushing them to live alongside each other rather than remain secluded. But it was exactly because of the brightness in her eyes that she did not so easily see the shadows lurking nearby. All her hopes were on the outside, even in small ways. She slapped a snot nosed child, yet saw her own snot nosed daughter as cute. The light blinded her, this small contradiction in mindset evocative of the larger one. Just as she focused energies outward while ignoring the same bad spots closer to home, she wanted her people to put aside their past hatred and go to the surface while completely failing to properly address their own present. With Otohime unable to recognize the darkness, and Tiger aiming to bury it, the course to the sun remained unclear. Otohime was akin to a navigator, charting the path for the Fishfolk races, but though she held the heart of the Fishfolk, she could not capture their spirit. That spirit was embodied in Fisher Tiger. An adventure who took to the surface Otohime so admired, in doing so he was made into a slave, evoking the exact fear so many Fishfolk possessed towards the sun that might burn them if they got too close. Tiger accepted and acknowledged that, burning the sun into the skin of the slaves he'd freed in his escape, as he did to his supporters who followed him, founding the Sun Pirates in his hopes of overcoming the past hatred and moving towards tomorrow. In being the first and only Fishman to strike against their oppressors, he stirred those of Fishman Island in ways Otohime struggled to. Recognizing Otohime's efforts, he would not kill humans, while she, recognizing the pain that drove Tiger, would not begrudge his honest intent even as it interfered with her efforts. But Tiger could not see the light, the suffering he'd survived at the hands of humans filling his heart with darkness, while Otohime, shining so, failed to truly acknowledge the shadows. If Otohime was a navigator with no ability to lead the people's spirit, then Tiger was a captain without a course, unable to follow Otohime's path. And on the sidelines was Jinbei, a helmsman. Strong and respected enough to guide his kind after Tiger's death, he was not a captain, nor could he truly accept the navigator's path, leaving him lost.
- Up to then, he was merely a Fishman like many others. Respecting Tiger, hailing from the same Fishman District, he had a disdain for humans, but on his journeys he slowly began to change. Through Koala, a girl who evoked the same sentiment as Otohime, he saw the continued need for humans and Fishfolk to understand each other directly, but he was unsure if such a thing could be possible. Even so, by becoming a Warlord to assist Otohime's goal, and in coming to interact with the humans she wanted to reach out to, he started to connect and understand, even if only personally. But even though he'd followed Tiger's will, through Arlong he became responsible for 10 years of tragedy that befell the East Blue. Despite a lack of intent in spreading hatred, through accepting the Government's attempt to strengthen bonds, he caused more pain through their faulty Warlord system. Nami suffered in ways that were all too familiar to the Fishfolk, not so different from a slave herself, having witnessed a loved one die in front of her. Had she come to hate Fishfolk as a result, though tragic, it would have been all too understandable. And yet, she didn't succumb to that hate. Through her journeys she had her own experiences. She befriended Camie and came to forgive Hachi, she saw the human systems in place that led to their suffering. Where Otohime wanted Fishfolk to go to the surface and understand humans, Nami came from the surface to them, coming to understand them, her journey the reverse of Otohime's desire, and one that showed that her path was indeed valid, giving Jinbei the answer to the question he'd asked a young Koala so many years ago. But Nami had only been able to come to that answer after recognizing the darkness in humanity, while Fishman Island was still very much in the process of coming to understand its own darkness. While Otohime's heart was in the right place, how could humans understand Fishfolk if the Fishfolk didn't even understand themselves and their own hatred?
- Falling victim to that darkness, she begged her children not to hate the perpetrator, whoever it was, human or Fishfolk. Hody Jones claiming that the perpetrator was human, despite being a blatant lie, was completely accepted at face value. The darkness had already set in: the people of Fishman Island never imagined the possibility that one of their own would have killed Otohime despite being well aware of the extremists under their nose. In their biases towards humanity, Hody's lie was a convenient way to continue to overlook the shadows clawing up from the Fishman District. But Otohime's light was not snuffed out, instead being inherited. Shirahoshi did know of her mother's murderer, but bore the burden of that knowledge alone, for years. But what she carried with her for those ten years was not the thought of any action against him, but a simple desire to pay her respects to her mother in person. She inherited the heart of Fishman Island, and Jinbei acknowledged the seed of hope she'd planted, the strength she possessed for overcoming her pain. And where she inherited Otohime's heart, Tiger's spirit was carried on through Luffy, one who had the strength and courage to strike out against those who made others suffer. Yet, not being controlled by any hatred despite knowing pain, holding no pretensions with which to get in the way of understanding others, he was also able to accept the need for humans and Fishfolk to understand one another. Through this synthesis of both the heart and spirit of Fishman Island, a light could finally be shed on the darkness.
- Hody Jones, as the embodiment of the past anger and hatred from the inhabitants of Fishman Island, manipulated a mounting situation to have Noah, the ship that rested in the heart of the Fishman District, crash down on Fishman Island and destroy it in its entirety. Hody Jones had no past pain to overcome, instead serving as that which Fishman Island had to overcome, literally trying to crush the island with its unaccounted for history. Fukaboshi told Luffy that he could let Fishman Island be destroyed, removing their past, but the past can't be destroyed, and Luffy would use the strength he had to protect everything. In trying to destroy Noah he nearly destroyed himself, Shiahoshi's intervention saving both Luffy and the past that could not be erased, her powers coming from a past even deeper. Only together could humans and Fishfolk both find the path forward. Jinbei and Shirahoshi in tandem with the Straw Hats saved Fishman Island. Against Dosun, who blamed humanity for their own madness, Chopper, who'd suffered discrimination from humans himself, instead accepted the monster he was and found greater power. Ikaros feared the sun, feared progress, where Franky embodied that progress, creating the Thousand Sunny, his light overpowering the one who couldn't stand it. Zoro, made well aware of his own weakness at the hands of Mihawk, had left the well that was the East Blue, continuing to find new strength, where Hyouzou, still trapped alongside the New Fishmen Pirates, had no means to grow. Daruma, a destroyer, met his match against Usopp, who's Impact Wolf reflected that senseless power held for the sake of holding power alone. Zeo, insistent on the infallibility of his kind, offered up the lives of himself and his men as their operation crumbled around them, Brook fundamentally rejecting their senseless acts, as death accomplished nothing. The martyrdom of Hody's crew would be fruitless, because the will they'd inherited was not personal, or particular. Where Shirahoshi held Otohime's will, Hody Jones took only only corruptions from Arlong and Tiger, never having understood them in the first place. Nothing had ever happened to him. Which is to say, nothing about him or his deep hatred was unique.
- Dangerous as he was, for being so hollow, Hody was not the problem, but a symptom. The slavery, the blood transfusion laws: humanity may not have had major authoritative presence on Fishman Island, but their laws still greatly affected them, as isolated as they might be. In allowing slavery even though it was supposed to be illegal, Fishfolk could not even remain home safely until Whitebeard flew his flag in defense of their people, let alone venture outside, for fear of being made a slave. Though the same blood ran through both species, the blood transfusion laws would imply that mixing that blood was wrong. Hody described human blood as impure, using the human law as excuse to kill fishfolk who broke it, willing to uphold that human oppression because it fit his anti-human narrative. But it's because Hody was hollow that merely defeating him alone would not solve anything. With the Fishman District being a breeding ground for hatred, with Hody being a victim of nothing, any Fishman there had potential to become another Hody Jones. He told Shirahoshi that she could have stopped him had she told the truth about Otohime. He wanted her to let out that hatred, but she refused him. Even if she had, even if Hody were stopped, it would not stop the agents of the Fishmen District or address the hatred of the Fishfolk. He would have simply been another martyr for the cause. As long as there was only hate to inherit from the Fishman District, there would always be another Hody Jones.
- Luffy, Shirahoshi, and Jinbei's victory over Hody was merely short term. Alleviating a symptom. But in the wake of the crisis, King Neptune saw those who'd been led by Hody, and accepted them. Not as criminals, but as children of the island lost in the dark, choosing instead to bring them into the light, finally acknowledging the shadows that had long been ignored. With their own eyes they would be given the chance to see the light. Where Hody had only seen pain and hate, Otohime put her life on the line to ensure the young wouldn't bear witness to someone else's hatred. Actions speak louder that words, something Luffy made abundantly clear as he came to the aid of Fishman Island. Whether or not he was a hero was for them to decide. He's not a self-righteous defender, just a man trying to protect that which he and his comrades value. Luffy could never undo centuries of oppression in a single bout, but by protecting what was close to him, by looking at Fishman Island and addressing it head on he achieved what no human had before, nearly at the cost of his life. Slowly dying from his wounds, human laws kept those at the sidelines from going to his aid. But Jinbei was a pirate. The systemic issues at fault did not need to be heeded by an outlaw. Where Hody and Arlong had tried to wash away the blood of the past by shedding more blood, Jinbei instead gave his blood, the same type that flowed through Luffy's veins, refusing to let more run. The blood of the past couldn't be erased, but with time it could dry. Laws and systems can be changed, but people would be people, man or Fishfolk, and through that simple demonstration, the path to the sun could be seen.
Add Comment
Please, Sign In to add comment