The Pirate's Treasure (MC x Natsuki) (NSFW)

The Pirate’s Treasure (MC x Natsuki)
(A.N. This is an alternative to my last fanfic, Heaven. Check it out, after you’ve finished this one, of course. If you’ve read Heaven, then yeah, the intro’s the same. Sorry!)
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
“Ah, Halloween” thought MC, as he walked down the Street with Sayori “The one night of the year when it’s socially acceptable to go to people’s houses and beg.” He laughed to himself, then glanced at Sayori. She was dressed as a fairy princess, in a pale green skirt, blue blouse, and light blue wings. She’d claimed that she’d made it all herself, and MC could believe that. He had also made his costume, but…

“I can’t believe you almost forgot the Halloween party!” Sayori huffed suddenly, pouting. “If you’d have remembered, I could have helped you with your costume!”

MC looked down at his own costume, and, he had to admit, she had a point. He’d completely forgotten about the party until a few hours earlier, and so his costume was… lacklustre. He’d taken what was at hand at the time, the toilet paper, and wrapped himself in it, coming out as an incredibly low effort mummy.

He laughed a bit “Yeah, whatever. We’re here now.”

This was true, as they had arrived outside Monika’s house. It was decorated to look like a haunted mansion, and there was a fog machine somewhere, further setting the mood for the evening. They walked up to the door, past fake gravestones and jack-o-lanterns, and rang the doorbell.

The door slowly creaked open, before…

Monika opened it fully, with a smile. She was dressed as a black cat, not too much skin showing, but enough to force MC to remember his goal for the evening.

“Oh, hey guys! C’mon in! The others are already here, and we’re setting up for a game of 7 Minutes in Heaven!” She led them into the living room, where FeMC, dressed in a bulky robot costume, Natsuki, dressed as a pirate, and looking smug, and Yuri, dressed as something MC was confused about, before remembering Yuri’s favourite author, Edgar Allen Poe, were sitting in a half circle, a bottle in the middle of them.

When she noticed that MC had entered the room, Natsuki blushed and looked away, focusing instead on the bottle in the centre. MC and Sayori sat down, and she spoke up.

“What took you guys so long? We were gonna start without you! I mean, I wouldn’t have cared much, but the game’s better with more people.” She asked, not looking directly at MC.

He laughed to himself, and rolled his eyes gently. “Classic Natsuki.” He thought.

After the group had chatted for a bit, Natsuki began to get impatient.

“C’mon, guys! Let’s play this already!” She grabbed the bottle, and spun it…

It landed on MC, who shrugged, smirked, and stood up, waiting to find out who his partner was. Natsuki spun it again, and this time…

It landed on her.

She didn’t show it, but on the inside she was a whirlwind of emotions; she felt happy, nervous, excited all at once. However, she contained herself and stood up.

“Fine. I guess I can handle you for seven minutes.” She said, before adding with a smirk “But can you handle me?” He smirked back, and they walked to the cupboard, and went inside.

It was a fairly spacious cupboard, big enough to comfortably fit the two of them, with a little bit of extra space left over.

Natsuki took herself to the opposite side of the cupboard, trying to work out how she could tell him her feelings. Little did she know, he was on the other side from her, thinking the exact same thing.

“C’mon Natsuki! For once in your life, take the initiative!” She thought to herself. After a minute had passed, she finally got up the courage. She knew that it was now or never.

“H-hey, MC. There’s… something I wanna say. I-I kinda… like you. In that way.”

MC was taken aback. He was just about to say a similar thing.

“W-well Natsuki… I like you like that, too.” He walked closer to her, and took her hands into his, the tissue paper wearing thin.
“Natsuki… I love you.” He moved closer to her face, and brought her lips into a kiss. It was short, but it was enough to convey their true feelings to each other.

She decided to take it a step further, a brought him into a kiss once more, this time her tongue pushing against his lips, asking for entrance, which he quickly gave, impressed by her boldness. She began to explore his mouth, and their tongues quickly became locked in a wrestle, which she won. She ended the kiss, and pushed him lightly to the ground.

He let himself collapse, and lay on his back, ready to be dominated by the small girl. She gave him a quick kiss, before running her hands down his chest. She felt his stomach through the thin toilet paper, and then lightly ran her hands below the waist, barely grazing over his crotch. To MC, even this light touch sent a wave of pleasure throughout his body. Natsuki noticed this and smirked.

“Heh, liking this, aren’t you?” She didn’t wait for a response, however, as she quickly tore away the toilet paper around his 6-inch shaft. It popped out, and she immediately grabbed it and began to stroke it roughly. MC moaned quietly, trying not to alert the girls in the other room. Natsuki put her left hand over his mouth, her right still stroking his member. He began thrusting into her hand, begging for release. He began panting harder, muffled beneath her hand. Just as he was about to release…

She stopped stroking. He tried to complain, but her hand still covered his mouth, so it just came out as a mumble. He stopped trying, as she removed her panties with one hand, and straddled him, holding his cock up, pointing towards her dripping wet pussy.

She lowered herself onto it, and held in a moan as his full 6-inches buried itself deep inside of her. He also moaned beneath her hand, as he felt her tight, warm, wet cavern surround his cock.

She hit the base of his shaft, and wiggled her hips around experimentally. Both of them felt a rush of pure ecstasy as he stirred around her insides. She lifted herself up, and brought herself back down again, riding him, and repeating this process of up and down, occasionally wiggling around on his member, still sending bolts of pleasure through them.

She took her hand off of his mouth and instead leaned on his chest, giving her the ability to go faster and harder, an ability she took full advantage of. She began to slam herself down onto his cock, loving every second of the intense feeling she got from it.

MC could feel his long-awaited release building up inside of him again, and from the look on Natsuki’s face, she was reaching her climax too. He leaned up too kiss her, and as their lips touched…

They came at the same time, his seed shooting inside of her as her juices flowed.

They both panted heavily, Natsuki laying down beside MC, before quickly realising where they were. Natsuki immediately shot up, slightly dizzy from their previous activity. She quickly threw him some blue “Super Absorbent” kitchen towel, which he wrapped his crotch in. She then pulled on her soaked panties, shivering from the cold sensation.

They returned to their positions on opposite sides of the room, acting like nothing happened.

The door was opened by Monika, who looked them up and down, and smirked, but said nothing. They went to re-join the group neither one acknowledging the other.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
SURPRISE! Yep, it’s Spooktober, so that means surprise fanfic!  ^-^ Anyway, see you guys next time, and thanks for reading!