SchalaKitty

FF7R - Sephiroth Appearance Analysis [Massive Spoilers]

Apr 16th, 2020
720
0
Never
Not a member of Pastebin yet? Sign Up, it unlocks many cool features!
text 9.01 KB | None | 0 0
  1. The Four Types of Sephiroth Appearances and their Rules
  2.  
  3. [EDITED: 4/30/2020 - Just editing this to state up front that this was my personal analysis of the scenes, originally posted on 4/16/2020. It is not a translation of the Ultimania. I did leave a few edited notes on where the Ultimania either clarified or contradicted my analysis though. Otherwise, this document has been left untouched from my original thoughts.
  4.  
  5. If you have any questions or would like to discuss, I can be found at https://twitter.com/SchalaKitty]
  6.  
  7. Note: The rules here are based on what we know about Jenova-aligned beings, taking notes from both how Iflana described their powers as working, what we saw in the original game, some of Advent Children, and how the powers are described in the novel “The Kids Are Alright.”
  8.  
  9. Type 1 - Telepathic Illusion – Speaking directly to a subject via Jenova-cell linked telepathy. Subject visually perceives Sephiroth as present though he will not have any true ability to physically interact beyond making the subject perceive his touch. Elements of the environment may also be visually warped around him, and time may seem to slow down around him. This type of appearance is the most capable of verbal communication save for Direct Contact. Seems to require a specific memory or thought to establish the connection.
  10.  
  11. Type 2 - Passive Perception – Cloud perceives a Sephiroth Copy as Sephiroth himself. Debatable how much any speech that happens during these instances is in fact spoken by Sephiroth or is only how Cloud hears the Copy speaking. Stems from the Jenova ability to appear as a dead person who was important to the subject. People other than Cloud most likely only see the Copy as they appear normally.
  12.  
  13. Type 3 - Active Puppeteering – Sephiroth possesses a Sephiroth Copy in order to use their body as physical puppet within the living world to be able to interact with it. Capable of speaking directly, but seems to be more focused on maintaining physical control. Physical capabilities may be directly correlated with the strength of the Copy? Though magical/otherworldly feats are possible - sword summoning, temporary/short-range flight, flash-stepping, however the Jenova chamber was broken – all of this may be reliant upon proximity to Jenova's physical body. How he is visually perceived may be dependent on the subject? Most likely appears as Sephiroth to those who had encountered him in life, may only be seen as the Copy otherwise? (IE – the subject needs a memory of Sephiroth in order for him to be perceived properly)
  14.  
  15. Type 4 - Direct Contact – Possible in planes of existence outside of the physical, living world – AKA Destiny's Crossroads and the Edge of Creation. Has full range of fighting and magical abilities and is able to speak freely if he chooses to do so. All present perceive him as himself.
  16.  
  17. ------ Break down by Appearance ------
  18.  
  19. Any Feather Appearances – Type 1? - The Feathers are hard to classify under this system, but are probably meant to be a signal that Sephiroth is monitoring Cloud this whole time, even if he is not directly in communication.
  20.  
  21. Chapter 2, both appearances – Type 1, Telepathic Illusions – Pretty straight forward example. Probably the longest sustained illusion we see. Given the content – how Sephiroth is specifically goading Cloud – he most likely actively riling Cloud up to establish/strength his connection with Cloud. Jenova powers work best with strong memories – that's why dead loved ones were often used. Sephiroth instead focuses on the enmity between them to form a solid connection via Cloud's memories of the burning of Nibelhiem, Cloud hating him and obsessing over him is key to maintaining the connection. For the second appearance, it does seem that Aerith had no idea of being touched while Cloud does seem to be aware of the touches when they happen to him.
  22.  
  23. Chapter 3 – Type 2, Passive Perception of Marco AKA Copy 49 – Notice that no dialogue happens here and Tifa only sees the Copy, not Sephiroth.
  24.  
  25. [EDITED ENTRY] Chapter 4 - Type 2, Telepathic Illussion - I originally forgot this one but this is when Sephiroth whispers to Cloud while falling asleep. Ends up getting a call back with one of his boss battle lines being "Do you dream of me?"
  26.  
  27. Chapter 8, first appearance– Type 1, Telepathic Illusion – Seems to hijack a conversation Zack was having with Cloud? Given how he is shown in the original game to hijack Aerith's dream walking message to Cloud after the Temple of the Ancients, it's not too surprising that he could also slip in while Zack was communicating. Only appears after "Zack" does the same shoulder touch Sephiroth has been using.
  28.  
  29. Chapter 8, second appearance, - Type 2, Passive Perception of Copy 2 – Single line of dialogue, is probably Cloud perceiving it through Sephiroth's voice. Entirely possible that no one else heard it though.
  30.  
  31. Chapter 13 – Type 1, Telepathic Illusion – Connection kick started by discussion about the Ancients, and the content of the message proves that Sephiroth is monitoring Cloud's actions or at least can skim from his memories. Nice touch with pulling back from Cloud's POV to show how Tifa and Barret don't see or hear anything.
  32.  
  33. Special Note for Chapter 16 Onward – Both Copy 2 and Copy 49 are being Puppeteered during this Chapter. It is entirely possible they were Puppeteered in tandem to release Jenova from her tank but that is speculation on my part.
  34.  
  35. Chapter 16, VR Room – Type 1? - Only really hard to define one. Barret and Tifa see at least some of the illusion/corruption of the movie at the end of the sequence as they reference Meteor but they don't mention Sephiroth specifically so they probably did not perceive him. This occurring in the VR room complicates cataloging it neatly. [EDITED NOTE - Confirmed in the Ultimania to be an illusion and that Barret and Tifa saw only Meteor, not Sephiroth]
  36.  
  37. Chapter 16, Palmer Sighting – Type 3, Active Puppeteering – Palmer having met Sephiroth in life is able to – or maybe forced to – see the Copy as Sephiroth himself.
  38.  
  39. Chapter 16, Cloud's Breakdown In Front of the Elevator – Possible Type 1, Audio Only – Also possible that the audio we hear is simply Cloud's memories from the Nibelhiem Incident. [EDITED NOTE - Confirmed in the Ultimania to only be Cloud's memories]
  40.  
  41. Chapter 16, Jenova Containment Room – Type 3, Active Puppeteering – There's also some Nibelhiem memories mixed in here, but during the main scene with everyone Sephiroth acting through one of the Copies here. It's hard to tell exactly what everyone else is seeing during this sequence – Tifa and Aerith most likely also sees Sephiroth, but it's questionable if Barret and Red do. [EDITED NOTE - Confirmed in the Ultimania that from here on out, the party sees any active Puppets as Sephiroth]
  42.  
  43. Chapter 17, Hojo's Security Cameras – Type 3, Active Puppeteering – Interesting that they confirm that the Copy appears as Sephiroth on camera. But it is also possible that because of Hojo's longtime connection to Sephiroth, we're seeing his perception? Either way, it is certainly possible that the illusions can fool cameras.
  44.  
  45. Chapter 17, The Presidential Suite – Type 3, Active Puppeteering – this one is a little hard to sort out exactly what is happening due to Jenova's physical presence in the room as well. Before the battle, indicates that the Jenova body itself is being puppeteered while afterward, it seems to have just been Copy 49. Probably a bit of tandem work facilitated by Jenova's body?
  46.  
  47. Chapter 17, Post-Boss Battle – Type 3, Active Puppeteering – Copy 2 picks up Jenova's body after Copy 49 dies and takes her body to the roof to then jump off it.
  48.  
  49. Chapter 18, Appearance at the Toll Booths – Most Likely Type 3, Active Puppeteering? – Hard to tell if this is Copy 2 and/or Jenova's physical body? Either way, everyone sees and hears Sephiroth in this scene and he's able to interact with the Whispers to open the gate to Destiny's Crossroads. [EDITED NOTE - First visual appearance was an illusion, second appearance is actually Direct Contact or "?" as confirmed in the Ultimania]
  50.  
  51. Chapter 18, Destiny's Crossroads Boss Battles – Type 4, Direct Contact – Is essentially completely present as this is outside the normal physical plane of existence. Seems to be able to Control/Absorb the Whispers due to his position as a key stone in the Planet's Fate?
  52.  
  53. Chapter 18, Edge of Creation – Type 4, Direct Contact – Again, this occurs outside the normal physical plane of existence so Sephiroth is fully present here.
  54.  
  55. I talked about this on Twitter in a ciphered thread (read here: https://twitter.com/SchalaKitty/status/1250498614369169408 ), but in one line here, Sephiroth swaps pronouns in Japanese from his normal post-Nibelhiem “私 / Watashi” back to this pre-Nibelheim pronoun “俺 / Ore.” In English this line is “But I... will not end.” In Japanese it is “俺は 消えたくない” (Closer to “I... don't want to vanish/disappear”). I'm mainly pointing it out because it feels significant to have that particular pronoun choice in this scene where he is alone with Cloud and trying to appeal to him directly – might be indicative that some part of Sephiroth's original personality might still exist? Hard to say but interesting nonetheless.
  56.  
  57. I will also add – just because I found this interesting in rewatching scenes in Japanese – that the use of
  58. 消える(vanish/disappear) is thematic and starts back in Chapter 2. The localization kinda obfuscates this by using different verbs but it comes up a few times in that first scene with him.
  59.  
  60. BONUS: Chapter 14 – Aerith's Dream Walking – Type 1, Telepathic Illusion – Basically showing off the same power she uses in the original game to speak to Cloud after the Temple of the Ancients. I really like that there are clear indicators that Cetra powers might not be too different from those of Jenova with this scene along with how Aerith is able to calm both Marlene and Red XIII. More than likely, Aerith seems to only able to do this via sleep/dreaming while alive – she is able to have much more freedom in communication after her death when she's a part of the Lifestream as seen in Advent Children.
Advertisement
Add Comment
Please, Sign In to add comment