Guest User

Greed is Good Transcript

a guest
Feb 12th, 2021
162
0
Never
Not a member of Pastebin yet? Sign Up, it unlocks many cool features!
text 10.20 KB | None | 0 0
  1. One thing I’ve always appreciated about Hunter x Hunter is how ever present its theme of desire is, to the point that even nameless and minor characters have clear, simple, and distinct wants they aim to fulfill through the actions we see them taking. We see such a clear line of desire in Gon’s work to get the badge from Hisoka, where Gon comes to realize he can understand what the fish and birds are thinking based on what they want, to the point that it forms a food chain. The fish went for the fly, the bird for the fish, then Gon for the bird. Similarly, his blind desires would have him taking the role of the fish in the upcoming exchange, where he went for the badge like it were a fly, leaving himself open to Geretta who went for Gon like a hawk, before Hisoka took advantage of the situation to make off with the most gain.
  2.  
  3. Hunters hunt, and by the rules of the Association they have to chase after something, making it all too fitting when the only one to fail is Killua, a boy too controlled by his family to strive for any desires he might have outside of their domain. But that is just the impetus, the beginning. Desire is fundamental even in animals. If one has no desires then they have nothing to reach for, but Hunter x Hunter spends much of its time examining the extremes, that of excessive desire, the examples I will primarily be discussing shown throughout the Yorknew and Greed Island arcs, each of which focus on one of the two main characters who are pushed by the strongest desires among the main four. Because while Yorknew ends with Gon, throughout it’s just as much, if not more so focused on Kurapika.
  4. Kurapika’s desire is twofold: to avenge his clan by bringing the perpetrators of the massacre to justice, and to retrieve their stolen eyes so that he may put them to rest properly. This journey for vengeance and the strength of his desire is something that gives him great power through his Nen. Nen can even mean to ‘desire’, so in this series of Hunters it is a fitting name for a set of abilities that allow characters to enforce their will on the world. As such, through putting ones life on the line, it can offer the strongest power of all (short of actual death), allowing a novice Nen user in the form of Kurapika to go toe to toe with members of the Phantom Troupe, a collection of some of the strongest Nen users we’ve seen in the series yet. In killing Uvogin, he incites their wrath, pitting their desires against one another. The Troupe operates in Yorknew to steal from the auction house, but with Kurapika’s interference, a second goal comes into focus as they aim to get their vengeance against that chain bastard, members conflicting with each other based on the individual weight they have in those desires. What I find interesting to consider about this conflict is how Neon’s ability factors in, the poems offering a ‘what if’ in their words of warning, allowing speculation on what might have been the unfolding course of events had the Troupe not taken more careful action.
  5.  
  6. What’s interesting is that while the deaths of Shizuka, Pakunoda, and Shalnark are rather set in stone, even the Troupe members note that if they go after Kurapika, his death won’t be so absolute, the vague wording merely stating that he will be bloody by the end of things. While the Troupe members he’d killed would certainly leave him bloody by the time he was done with them, what I believe the poem to be implying is more evocative of the thematic failure that the characters involved all desperately fight against, as at the end of all of it, both sides in the conflict are brought to a halt by their mutual desires to keep their friends from harm. The Troupe unfalteringly goes along with Kurapika’s words to save Chrollo, Gon and Killua understanding their pain at losing comrades the most directly, both from seeing it through Nobunaga and of course, feeling the same way themselves at the idea of losing their comrades. Because at the end of the day, Kurapika doesn’t want to sacrifice his friends either. Both sides have their desires, but the Troupe who couldn’t let either their heist or vengeance go lost the most, even if they gained the stolen treasures they did, while Kurapika killed only the fraction of the Troupe members he might have otherwise, and failed to get the eyes he sought to retrieve, he didn’t lose anything either. But in the poems, lack of restraint informs an alternate future where Kurapika kills more of the Troupe, the blood on his hands being (as I would infer) that of his comrades. To charge into achieving one’s desires with no restraint would increase the likelihood of success, but the cost of it would put everything else at risk. And the Troupe, acting to protect their comrades, showed that restraint first, changing the outcome for all of them.
  7.  
  8. An excessive want for what one desires can be called greed. Some might even say greed is good, and going by the name, Greed Island would be a place where such extreme desire is rewarded. Succeeding in the game can grant just a handful of treasures from an immense selection of wonders. Interestingly, of the primary contenders, Gon, Genthru, and Battera, we come to know exactly what two of these challengers want from the game, but the third remains an enigma, because it doesn’t matter. Where Yorknew explores desires restrained by a want not to lose anything, Genthru’s specific wants do not matter. All that matters is that he and his comrades want to win, everything else be damned. The specific lack of context is meant to highlight his methodology over what he might actually want from clearing the game. Genthru is greed, his brutal methods and power allowing any others outside his group to be sacrificed. Even Tsuzguerra’s forces cannot stand up to him properly. When Gon hears of the Bomber, he’s told that the players of the game see him as the epitome of what this game of death wants from its players, Greed Island seemingly rewarding the greed of this man with so few standards. Gon rejects that notion, but not because he is Genthru’s counterpoint. That role is filled by Battera, who gives away everything he has with only the intent to live quietly and humbly with the one he loves. His desire is strong, but ultimately it’s not enough, and the love of his life dies before the game can be completed. Much like the Hunter Exam, Greed Island can only be beaten by someone who wants to complete it, leading to Battera’s contradiction. The one who wants to beat it most of all, perhaps even more than Genthru and Gon, is Battera, yet Battera is not a Nen user. At the end of the day, he could not fulfill his own desires. Nen is a power that enforces one's will on the world for desires, yet Battera is not capable of this ability, paying others to do it for him. And yet those others, as strong as they were, were not fighting to beat the game or make off with its unique prizes, since those were meant for Battera. They would only walk off with money, something they could not only get anywhere, but as shown, it was something they would get whether or not they succeeded or failed. Willing to offer everything, what Battera had to give was, ironically, worth nothing, the tragedy of his struggle in that no one else associated with the game could ever care as much about beating Greed Island as he did, and thus could never win for the desires of another.
  9.  
  10. Even Gon, the ultimate victor, did not require beating Greed Island to meet his father, and the progress he did make towards that goal was a happy accident more than anything. But Gon’s desire was pure, to beat the game for the sake of beating it. Again, Gon isn’t without his greed, and we see this during the battle against Genthru. At any time he could have doused his opponent in oil and strip him of his powerful ability, but Gon got greedy for validation and recognition, opting to fight him to put his new skills to work after Genthru insisted that he wasn’t worth using Little Flower on. It’s a course of action that evokes his battle against Hanzo in the Hunter Exam, where he wanted a fair way to challenge him without having an advantage or being condescended to, in spite of Hanzo’s overwhelming power. His pure desire still earned him a win, and Hanzo’s respect, but it was not on his terms, informing his desires after the fact to properly earn his license by going against Hisoka. But against Genthru it was different, because after fighting to meet that goal, stacking up to Genthru and earning his fear and respect, he was satiated. Against Hanzo, Gon was greedy because his desires could not be reasonably met, but against Genthru, once he got what he wanted, Genthru gave up, rendering the plan unnecessary. But Genthru was greedy. Even seeing and fearing Gon’s strength, he took advantage of his naivety, crippling him with intent to kill so he could walk away with everything. But in that greed he underestimated his opponent, who (up until then) had been fighting for his greed rather than for his desire to beat the game, and once he switched back to those gears, he used a plan that could have been put into action at any time, made using everything to bring down Genthru. With a mastery of the game’s quirks and skills learned from the natural training in its systems offered, Gon brought Genthru down handily.
  11.  
  12. Genthru turned Greed Island into a game of murder, but Gon refused to stoop to his level, going into the battle with 6 Breath of the Goddess cards prepared, just in case. Greed Island was a game where, be it monster or other player, death was a very real possibility, on some level expected by all players, the mechanics even believed to be promoting murder at high levels of play. But after defeating Genthru and getting all 99 cards, the true nature of the game was revealed, one that very much evoked Ging’s words of appreciating those little detours. Murder and death might get a player to those last few cards, but they can’t steal knowledge of the world those cards came from. Gon played the game as intended: not to greedily reap its rewards and rush to the end, but to enjoy it, seeing much of it, earning the cards through exploring the world his father took part in creating, and as a result he won, having a desire to win, but not an excessive desire that left someone like Genthru just shy of victory.
Advertisement
Add Comment
Please, Sign In to add comment