Marbles
Gum Wrappers
Bottle Opener
Nuts and Bolts
Lingerie Catalog
Birthday Card
Mints
Work Gloves
Scalps
Demonic Charms
Ancient Stone Idol
Dried Eyeballs
Toes-on-a-Stick
Can of 3-in-1 Oil
Crude Claw Sharpener
Bloody Shoe
Eerily Lifelike Baby Doll
Pocket Lint
Human Ear
Putrid Entrails
Action Figure
Fried Circuitry
Chinese Finger Prison
Bottle Caps
Corkscrew
Expired Rail Pass
Romance Novel
Soiled Handkerchief
Rat Pelts
Dried Flowers?
Vial of... Something Green
Brimstone
Sharpened Femur
Dried Spleens
Noses-on-a-Stick
Horn Polisher
Bloody Glove
Charred Family Portrait
437 Pinky Embryos
Beret & Mime Makeup
German Hatchback Car
Green Goo
Bag of Bone Fragments
Human Ashes
Bottle Opener
Demon Parasites
Pocket Bible
Human Finger
Rubber Ducky
Action Figure
Dead Battery
Tweezers
Moldy Warm Pocket
Chipped Tomahawk
Bloody Wowsham
Popsicle Stick
Crawfish
Red Stocking
Chain of Paperclips
Alumni Mug
Hand Flexor Thing
SPF 666 Sunblock
Meatball Sub
Pocket Qu'ran
Broken Wristwatch
Soap on a Rope
Toy Car
Glow Stick
Spicy Buffalo Wing
Meat Thermometer
Barbeque Sauce
Prosthetic Limb
Glass Eyeball
Tap Dancing Shoes
Comic Book
Irish Postcard
Cancun Shot Glass
Small Figurine
Jumper Cables
Jon's AMEX
Crumpled Map
Broken Flashlight
Ballpoint Pen
Camera Flash Bulb
35mm Film
Chewed Foot
Birthing Lube
Orcs & Elves XVII
Monocle and Top Hat
Flies in Ointment
23 Mate-less Socks
Pixie Dust
Old License Plate
Heads of 23 Mice
Flattened Bullets
Gunpowder Residue
Broken Arrowhead
Imp Business Card
Human Jaw Bone
Grotesque Figurines
Smashed PDA
Breath Mints
Toupee
Melted TV Remote
Empty Vials
Makeup Mirror
Duck Call
Rubber Hamburger
Graduation Cap
Liposuction Scars
Copy of Orcs & Elves
Fried Comm Link
Human Ear
Rotting Teeth
20-sided Die
Expired Earth Credits
The One Ring
Frisbee
Paint Brush
Paintball Gun
Tablet Stylus
Book of Mormon
Fortune Cookie
Chop Sticks
Chili Paste
Bridal Gown
Moist Tissue
Tooth Necklace
Pregnancy Test
A Noop
Squishy Eyeball
WWJD Bracelet
Cask of Wine