Link to the Past randomizer really wasn't that bad in retrospect.  A lot of my frustrations came from not being familiar with the game, I haven't played it in 3 years and I don't know many of the terms of the chest locations.  If I'm crazy enough to put in more time I might do it again.  I'm sure it's more fun the more you do it.

The seed we got was terrible though.  Boots were on the pedestal and getting there required half completing several dungeons to get the necessary items to get there.  On top of that Boots were required to get the Bow.