Qawf Ralton vs. PoB

Power Girl's win conditions that I found viable
* Heat vision is something that Natsu cannot eat and will damage him
* Power Girl lifts while Natsu doesn't
* While she's vulerable to magic she's not cripplingly weak to it

Natsu's  win conditions that I found viable
* His fire magic can bypass PG's durability and harm her
* His strikes can output similar levels of power to PG and he wraps them in fire blasts
* Natsu can eat the heat of PG's heat vision

Overall I lean more towards Ralton in regards to Heat Vision vs Natsu's ability to eat sources of heat. The radiation has anti-magic properties, is radiation, and I feel like it could burn Natus. However, Po's final point about its speed has to be considered. Heat Vision was never properly shown to be far faster than Power Girl and her reacting to it at close range would reduce how fast it would be in a speed equalized setting by a lot.

Ultimately speaking I just don’t see PG handling the fire from Natsu well enough. The two feats that could suggest otherwise are the Star one, which wouldn’t count since Supergirl would just be heavily amped by the radiation the entire time, and the Brimstone one. But Ralton never went in on some of Brimstone’s more hilarious heat showings that would make her virtually fire proof even in this circumstance.

OOT Request

I’ll say this, I agree with Ralton that the giant fire wave is massively out of tier. The sheer amount of rock it melted/vaporized means that his surface area argument is meaningless. You can’t have it be both ways in regards to durability reduction with magic. If Superman gets hit by that I’m fully confident he dies to it.

However I do agree with Po that Superman being hit by it is questionable due to his speed. But his point about Natsu not using it doesn’t work, since Natsu would be bloodlusted against Superman and I don’t see why he wouldn’t use massive AoE ranged attacks.

But overall I don’t see Natsu winning with this attack. I could easily see it if Po pressed the heat aura as some oppressive or game winning element, but he never did. So while Natsu has the capacity to win reliably its not to the point where Superman could never win in my view.

Conclusion

Overall I think PG is faster, I think PG’s heat vision could damage Natsu, and I think she hits hard enough to do stuff. But I don’t think that’s enough. I don’t think she was shown to hit hard enough to brick past Natsu’s durability, I don’t think she was shown to be able to handle his concentrated heat attacks, and I don’t think she can handle consecutive magic fired amped punches from Natsu. Po wins in my view.