AnonyOdinn

#DOMALeaks: The US Supreme Court, Congress, and You

Mar 24th, 2013
123
0
Never
Not a member of Pastebin yet? Sign Up, it unlocks many cool features!
text 5.51 KB | None | 0 0
  1. #DOMALeaks: The US Supreme Court, Congress, and You
  2.  
  3. In the first #DOMALeaks, 'The Hypocrisy Chronicles' at http://pastebin.com/hxtZBe2H details of the case against #DOMA were provided, and a list of Congressmembers who had suddenly jumped on board the train to do what they should have done before... oppose #DOMA. This was provided as a way of identifying what the position of your Congressmember was on the legal brief to oppose #DOMA and to provide a path to legislative advocacy or other meaningful action.
  4.  
  5. Mainly the purpose of this #DOMALeaks is to get out information on what is happening at the US Supreme Court level, explain a little about it, and to provide some information on what Congress is (or isn't) doing at this time as well.
  6.  
  7. At the time this pastebin is issued (March 24, 2013), oral argument is scheduled for the US Supreme Court on #DOMA, to take place on March 27, 2013. At the moment, until this link is changed or updated, you can find details on the case at the US Supreme Court, here:
  8. http://www.supremecourt.gov/docket/DOMPRP8.aspx
  9. You will not need any login credentials to view the documents, they are public access.
  10.  
  11. So below we'll examine the reasoning of one of the most odd filings seen in the case and provide some reasoning to debunk it.
  12.  
  13. Here one of the most interesting filings is what will simply be referred to as the 'Hollingsworth' filing although there are various. It is here: http://www.supremecourt.gov/docket/PDFs/Reply_Brief_12-144.pdf
  14. In it the filers claim that "marriage is a gendered institution" (here the immediate thought is, just for starters, what does this gender mean to many millions of Americans?) and say in their filing, "Bishop’s authoritative
  15. 1852 treatise on the law of marriage explained that “it has always . . . been deemed requisite to the entire
  16. validity of every marriage . . . that the parties should be of different sex,” and that “[m]arriage between two
  17. persons of one sex could have no validity.”
  18.  
  19. Wow, that was kind of amazing. So we should rely on some guy named Bishop, from 1852... because he says so?
  20.  
  21. I don't think so.
  22.  
  23. Then there are all the claims about States' rights. George F. Will claims it's all about States Rights and goes on and on about this. http://www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/george-f-will-doma-infringes-on-states-rights/2013/03/20/fa845348-90bb-11e2-bdea-e32ad90da239_story.html
  24. He says, and I quote, "Federalism, properly respected, enables diversity as an alternative to a congressionally imposed, continent-wide moral uniformity. Allowing Washington to impose such conformity would ratify unprecedented federal supremacy regarding domestic relations, a power without judicially administrable limits. By striking down DOMA — by refusing to defer to Congress’s usurpation of states’ powers — the court would defer to 50 state governments, including the 38 that today prohibit same-sex marriage."
  25. It's an interesting idea, but #DOMA is about far more than States rights that he seems to be so concerned about. Will isn't really concerned about GLBT progress or about the rights of GLBT folk that have been suppressed by law or other methods. That story began by quoting the US Supreme Court from a past case, saying "“[U]nder the Constitution, the regulation and control of marital and family relationships are reserved to the States.” But that's not what the Constitution says and that's not what the US Supreme Court has decided in this case.
  26.  
  27. If we were to be honest, let's just admit that giving rights to some people and not to others is fundamentally unconstitutional -- and it's not even a state's rights issue.
  28. What was it that pesky US Constitution says again?
  29.  
  30. Oh yeah:
  31.  
  32. "The judicial Power shall extend to all Cases, in Law and Equity, arising under this Constitution, the Laws of the United States, and Treaties made, or which shall be made, under their Authority;--to all Cases affecting Ambassadors, other public Ministers and Consuls;--to all Cases of admiralty and maritime Jurisdiction;--to Controversies to which the United States shall be a Party;--to Controversies between two or more States;-- between a State and Citizens of another State,--between Citizens of different States,--between Citizens of the same State claiming Lands under Grants of different States, and between a State, or the Citizens thereof, and foreign States, Citizens or Subjects."
  33.  
  34. And under Amendment 10:
  35.  
  36. "The powers not delegated to the United States by the Constitution, nor prohibited by it to the States, are reserved to the States respectively, or to the people."
  37.  
  38. Ah, the People! That would be everybody else in a State, who is not a member of a State government!
  39.  
  40. People. That's who really count.
  41.  
  42. People's rights -- not states rights.
  43.  
  44. (So in other words, if the States are to be given 'power' to keep enforcing unequal grant of rights and denying LGBT people equal legal rights and access to such institutions that all else have then they will be sued. And this will keep happening again and again. This is not so hard to understand really.)
  45.  
  46. NPR had a pretty good story recently on what Congress is doing (and the flip flops that often come when a high profile case comes up the US Supreme Court). Check it out.
  47. 'They all voted for DOMA - But now these Senators are Split.'
  48. http://www.npr.org/2013/03/23/175114618/the-senators-who-oppose-doma-despite-having-okd-it?ft=1&f=1001&sc=tw&utm_source=twitterfeed&utm_medium=twitter
  49.  
  50. Well that's all for now, keep an eye on that US Supreme Court page, and there will be more in the near future.
Advertisement
Add Comment
Please, Sign In to add comment