Wout12345

Re: On The EULA

Aug 19th, 2014
5,797
0
Never
Not a member of Pastebin yet? Sign Up, it unlocks many cool features!
text 15.60 KB | None | 0 0
  1. Just for anyone else reading this: this is a response to MogMiner's blog post "On The EULA", which can be found here: http://polygonal-moogle.com/uncategorized/on-the-eula/
  2.  
  3. Dear Mog, Ryan or whatever way I should refer to you,
  4.  
  5. I'd just like to point out some things I thought while reading your post. I'm not going to get into any overly formal introduction, as I can imagine you must be quite busy anyway, so let's just get right into it.
  6.  
  7.  
  8.  
  9. "I’m sorry that Mojang went so long without clarifying the terms of the EULA that have been in place for the past 2-3 years. To anyone involved with the game, the restrictions and limitations would seem readily apparent, but as is plain to see, they were not so apparent to the people who play Minecraft and who run Minecraft servers."
  10.  
  11. TRIVIAL RESEARCH STUFF, READ AT OWN RISK OF WASTING TIME
  12.  
  13. Well ... I'll just trust you here, considering you work for Mojang, but it's still a close one. I've been checking some archived pages (too much links, I'll put them at the bottom), and it looks like what effectively was the Minecraft EULA contained the following sentence:
  14.  
  15. "Plugins for the game also belong to you and you can do whatever you want with them, including selling them for money."
  16.  
  17. That was, from until September 2nd 2011, unfortunately all captures afterwards failed for some reason, so I don't know what happened afterwards until December 23rd 2013, where captures start from the new EULA page, this time hosted on the Mojang website instead. From there on the sentence reads like this:
  18.  
  19. "Modifications to the Game ("Mods") (including pre-run Mods and in-memory Mods) and plugins for the Game also belong to you and you can do whatever you want with them, as long as you don‘t sell them for money / try to make money from them."
  20.  
  21. What I'm trying to say here, is that I don't think there was any need for clarification. There was need for a notification. Server networks like The Hive were trying to run a business model on professional plugin development, which was quite clearly allowed until about 3 years ago, and was quite clearly not allowed since about 8 months. The thing is, I may not be a professional network owner, but I never heard anything of this drastic change, and so did most of the community.
  22.  
  23. On a little side-note though, I hope you can update that page soon, as the current server jar forces you to agree with it, yet, it does not allow for any sort of plugin monetization, although you explained that you tolerated and even seemed to encourage professional cosmetic plugin development.
  24.  
  25. END OF RESEARCH STUFF
  26.  
  27. Okay, I have to admit, it has been a bit of a semantics issue up to this point. I also shouldn't come here to yell at you how you or Mojang did things even worse than you're apologizing for. I will, however, criticize the statement that everything was clear to Mojang themselves. Although I don't support everything in Sterling's open letter (http://sterlingplays.com/) from a couple of months ago, I think the story from Minecon is quite relevant here. As he explains things way better than me, I'll just let him talk here:
  28.  
  29. "One example of many clear indications that you supported our servers and business models was that Mojang has invited us onto panels and to exhibit booths at Minecon. Last year included a panel called ‘Running a Server‘ that talked about how to run a professional multiplayer server and where revenue models were explicitly discussed.
  30.  
  31. I personally discussed our rank system with a member of your business team at Minecon last year and he confirmed we were in compliance with the EULA. The only rule was to not sell Mojang IP (ie. selling access to a diamond sword), which none of the large networks do."
  32.  
  33. This isn't simply a lack of clarification or notification, but an inconsistency within Mojang. I don't think I have to elaborate on this further, so let's just continue.
  34.  
  35.  
  36.  
  37. "Pretty much any other game company would take a scorched-earth policy towards people violating the EULA. They have teams of countless lawyers, all looking for violations and ready to pounce at the first sign of things that seem untoward. Mojang is different."
  38.  
  39. I'd like to take the time here to not criticize but to support this message, as to not turn this whole response into a critique. Mojang has always been a rather humble company whose liberal policies, together with the creative nature of Minecraft, have allowed the community to flourish. This, however, is also the reason why a lot of players like me are so sensitive to events like these, as we fear for the loss of this attitude.
  40.  
  41.  
  42.  
  43. "Mojang is a company that believes in the inherent good in people, that a community left to itself will do the best thing that’s possible for that community, that people will not take advantage of this and will instead use this to cultivate a community that is best for everyone involed.
  44.  
  45. I’m sorry that the company was wrong."
  46.  
  47. I ... would dare to say the company was right. But because of other reasons. Yes, your stance towards these networks have allowed them to grow in whatever way they see fit. Yet, it is an evil which, in my opinion, will always exist. I think I got this point from someone else (maybe Sterling), but the argument goes that the people you're trying to target with the latest "change" are also those that are the farthest out of your reach.
  48.  
  49. I lately saw a post (http://galaxy2alex.blogspot.co.at/2014/08/the-eula-1-day-after-enforcement.html) by one of the Mojira moderators, checking the situation on several large networks on August 2nd, one day after the supposed deadline. While reading, I couldn't help but noticing that the networks I had played on so far (Overcast Network, Hypixel's, The Hive, Mineplex and PlayMindcrack) were all either complying with the EULA or trying their best to do so. That's not to say that I'm a good network-picker, but that these networks I heard about over time through the community, still had quality gameplay worth staying for regardless of the advantages "donators" got (I really don't support Sterling's idea that on Mineplex and other networks e.g. extra classes are only a gameplay variation, not an advantage).
  50.  
  51. In other words, the ones I valued the most were the ones who were willing to change their business model. That's not a coincidence in my opinion. And neither do I believe the networks not complying are doing it out of game development integrity as they supposedly don't support the changes which were made. Let's face it: these networks are not responding, were already known for scamming their customers, so what's stopping them from hosting their servers and handling their finances in a location out of Mojang's legal reach?
  52.  
  53.  
  54.  
  55. "I’m sorry for the countless parents who have e-mailed the Mojang support team almost in tears, asking us why it was that their little angel was banned from “our” servers after having spent $150 of the parent’s money on a trivial bauble like a set of diamond armor, or a gilded nameplate, or an Ocelot pet."
  56.  
  57. I already thought this was one of the major issues for Mojang. However, although I would understand your frustration with these e-mails, I can't condone it as a reason to target all networks out there, a strategy with flaws like the one mentioned above. Scams also happen in real life, and even though these perpetrators are way easier to catch than potentially untraceable network owners, the main advice still remains: use common sense.
  58.  
  59. I hope you don't consider this too low of a move, but ... I'm willing to put the responsibility on the parents. The responsibility to inform themselves of what their kids are doing online before giving in to their demands. In my opinion the lack of research also heavily contributed to the Meeting of The Mines and, quite recently, MineOrama scandals and should be dealt with globally speaking.
  60.  
  61. On top of that, we have to take the numbers of people which are being affected here into account. As I open my Minecraft client, what do I see? Overcast Network, 804 players. Hypixel Network, 7779 players. Mineplex games, 13,385 players. That's over 20,000 people during a regular European Tuesday night. I consider myself one of those. You may not hear us, but nevertheless, we're really enjoying ourselves. After all, who speaks out to support the way things are right now?
  62.  
  63.  
  64.  
  65. "I’m sorry that I am sick and tired of people accusing Mojang of being worse than EA, when spending three days at meetings hashing out exemptions to the EULA is something that is unprecedented as far as game companies go and would more than likely never have happened otherwise."
  66.  
  67. I have to admit I wasn't aware of the fact you spent three days on it, respect for that. Yet, there's something which I still think was completely missing in the EULA discussions: network involvement. Of course, they're companies, they will always try to get the best out of it, which is why I considered negotiations, not letting them go freely. What I heard what happened, though, was that a corporation which, let's face it, has the least financial issues, decided on their own how they would regulate a group of small companies which had no way to defend themselves nor provide them with precise data about their revenue. Regardless of the outcome, Mojang discussed amongst themselves what constitutes a viable business model, without any experience, without inviting professionals in the field. It was, and still is, my major concern with this whole issue.
  68.  
  69. By the way, I can't say I've got solid proof here to back up the claim no network staff took part in those meetings, it's simply something I seemed to hear nothing about. Feel free to prove me wrong and I'll take back my words.
  70.  
  71.  
  72.  
  73. "The vast majority of us on the team, even facing down the debacle that was upon us, took it upon ourselves to spend upwards of three days discussing how best to allow people to continue making money off of what is ostensibly something they have invested little in other than server hosting costs, which could be paid trivially by any job, not one revolving around fleecing preteens."
  74.  
  75. This is one of the reasons why the lack of network involvement sounds troubling to me. Although I don't doubt your intentions, while reading this I just feel like too little people within Mojang have experience with the subject, even on the player-side. Maybe I'm just uninformed myself, maybe the majority of the servers the EULA targets are those selling diamond sword for $100 ... But I won't just assume that either. When I think of professional servers or networks, I think of those I play on myself, the ones I see my favourite Youtubers play on. I think of beautifully-designed worlds, complex maps, GUI's which explore the limits of the capabilities of an unmodded client, clever gameplay, and last but not least, a staff which works around the clock to keep the games fun and hacker-free. What I do not think of, is "little" investment.
  76.  
  77. Of course, all of this is contingent upon the work of you, of Mojang. However, I do not see why that should decrease any of its value or the effort it took to realize it. For once, I can speak on my own behalf as well, being a Minecraft content creator (a small one on an amateur level, that is). Mountains don't rise out of the ground by themselves, command blocks don't write themselves and buildings with depth aren't just designed procedurally. Unlike Mojang, we're working in a very confined space, with its advantages and disadvantages, but most importantly, we are a large community. It's easy to look at people's creations in awe, but it's also easy to forget the countless people involved who devoted themselves to make this possible.
  78.  
  79.  
  80.  
  81. "They are interested in taking advantage of a controversy in the name of precious YouTube views or page hits so that they can feel vindicated without having made any sort of effort to rectify the situation against which they are railing."
  82.  
  83. For the most part, though, I feel like you're describing journalism here. The desire to inform, not to take political action. In my opinion, this is a justified stance to take as well.
  84.  
  85. However, I can see you're mostly talking about people writing blog posts which are simply rants on the way the system works without suggesting anything instead. *cough cough* I was just trying to bring a bit of nuance to that statement, nothing else.
  86.  
  87.  
  88.  
  89. "It would be something different if the people who genuinely enjoy the game and feel nothing towards this issue were vocal about it."
  90.  
  91. I can't deny this. After all, I believe I even mentioned this earlier (without even having read this beforehand). This still mostly is hypothetical speech in my opinion, though.
  92.  
  93.  
  94.  
  95. "If the people who are in favor of what Mojang is doing truly made a stand and tried to present some sort of cohesive front against the non-stop tide of negative attitudes, something might actually get done."
  96.  
  97. Well, this just sounds quite weird to me at first. If Mojang's actions receive stronger support than they do now, then in what way would that increase the chance of Mojang reconsidering their actions? I must have misunderstood something there.
  98.  
  99. Furthermore, while we're on this topic, I'm going to take the time for a second to talk about the community response. Maybe I'm just being selective, but ... I don't see the heavy opposition. I'll take your word for it that there's a bunch of trolls out there ready to caps at you, since we all know the reputation of the Internet, however, when reading responses to Mojangsters' tweets, I always see mostly support. I suppose you could consider that the standard and be using some kind of other scale here, but in the end, I typically feel like I am the odd one out, and that's not even talking about my style, but simply about the side I'm taking in general. It usually seems like a hostile environment where words are to be balanced out very carefully (which is why Searge may have blocked me, not sure).
  100.  
  101.  
  102.  
  103. Lastly, I'll just take the time to say that I really liked reading your post and that it's definitely interesting content, despite my criticisms of it. Before taking off, I think it'd be nice to refer you to a last link, "Minecraft Servers: Why They're So Great" by Treestompz (http://youtu.be/HuiyrRlzFis). As you can tell from the title, it's a very subjective piece, but most of the video consists of a (relatively) objective history of Minecraft servers, both on the level of software development and community development. It should be an interesting thing to watch for both sides, I hope.
  104.  
  105. I'm kind of out of words after 3-4 hours of solid reading, researching and writing, yet, I feel like I need more to have a complete ending to this post, so let me just be a bit more normal and tell you to "choke on genitals and die". XD Sorry, I hope you don't take that offensively, but after all of this I deserve a good joke. :P Thanks for reading, and I'd love to see whatever you have to say about this.
  106.  
  107.  
  108.  
  109. References:
  110.  
  111. The post I'm responding to:
  112. http://polygonal-moogle.com/uncategorized/on-the-eula/
  113.  
  114. Jul 15th 2009 (from the copyright page, Minecraft website):
  115. http://wayback.archive.org/web/20090715110900/http://minecraft.net/copyright.jsp
  116.  
  117. Sep 2nd 2011 (from the copyright page, Minecraft website):
  118. http://wayback.archive.org/web/20110902010826/http://www.minecraft.net/copyright.jsp
  119.  
  120. Dec 23th 2013 (from the EULA page, Mojang website):
  121. http://web.archive.org/web/20131210231416/http://account.mojang.com/documents/minecraft_eula
  122.  
  123. Dec 23th 2013 (from the EULA page, Mojang website):
  124. http://web.archive.org/web/20140817214809/https://account.mojang.com/documents/minecraft_eula
  125.  
  126. Sterling's letter:
  127. http://sterlingplays.com/
  128.  
  129. Galaxy's post:
  130. http://galaxy2alex.blogspot.co.at/2014/08/the-eula-1-day-after-enforcement.html
  131.  
  132. Treestompz's video:
  133. http://youtu.be/HuiyrRlzFis
Advertisement
Add Comment
Please, Sign In to add comment