Guest User

Untitled

a guest
Feb 14th, 2026
196
0
Never
Not a member of Pastebin yet? Sign Up, it unlocks many cool features!
text 5.05 KB | None | 0 0
  1. This is my opinion as to why I think Craig Murry is incorrect. I will use references to the judgement as Murray has.
  2.  
  3. Firstly, what the court decided yesterday.
  4.  
  5. Huda succeeded on two ground.
  6.  
  7. Ground 6 the HS misappplied her own published policy by treating the police powers as a major reason to proscribe.
  8.  
  9. That can't be a relevant factor because it would apply to any proscribed group, and the policy must limit the number of groups proscribed (paras 90-94).
  10.  
  11. They said it was such a significant error that the government couldn't rely on s31 the mistake being irrelevant because the outcome would be the same anyway (paras 146-149).
  12.  
  13. Ground 2 ECHR the proscription caused significant interference to Article 10 and 11 rights (paras 103-106). It was disproportionate because only a small number of PAs actions met the definition for terrorism and there were existing laws covering that (paras 135-140).
  14.  
  15. Because of ground 6, the interference was not prescribed by law anyway.
  16.  
  17. The result is that the court will make a quashing order subject to representations from both sides.
  18.  
  19. Onto Murrays points
  20.  
  21. Keeping the ban in place pending an appeal is utterly illogical
  22. This is the opposite to what the court has said - they said they will quash it unless there are representations otherwise. They may well stay the proscription, but that's speculation. Even if it does occur, it's routine for courts to pause the effect of a judgement until an appeal is held to avoid "whiplash" rules.
  23.  
  24. The judges chose an extremely narrow path and produced an extremely weak judgement so the govt can win on appeal
  25.  
  26. There is no evidence of this. Multi-factorial judicial reviews often have mixed findings. It is not a "weak judgement", the policy analysis (paras 72-95) is very thorough in exploring the finding that a rule that applies to all cases isn't a rule. Likewise the proportionality analysis (paras 138-140) uses strong language.
  27.  
  28. There is no bumper rails at the appeal. If the government appeals Huda can cross appeal the rejected grounds too. It makes it easier for the government in that they will know what arguments they have to defeat but that's the nature of appeals, not a stitch up.
  29.  
  30. They state PA is a terrorist group
  31.  
  32. Huda didn't challenge that PA committed serious property damage in order to influence the government so there was no debate that PA could potentially be covered (because the definition is too wide).
  33.  
  34. They reject the UN and say international concensus has no impact on statute
  35.  
  36. This is accurate.
  37.  
  38. All those arrested for showing support including placards were rightly arresed
  39.  
  40. The judgement does not say the arrests were right, it says the placards were "carefully worded" as part of a "calculated action" to get arrested.
  41.  
  42. No need for Cooper to consult
  43.  
  44. They found it was not "obvious" that a suspected terrorist organisation should be consulted. We all know the consultation was ticking boxes the Israeli embassy and Elbit were demanding but it would be difficult for terrorist groups to be universally consulted. The process is not designed for a UK protest group and it shows.
  45.  
  46. Repeatedly references Filton case with no reference to jury findings (paras 34, 139)
  47.  
  48. This is entirely incorrect. Paragraph 34 is a quote from the JTAC report which mentions Filton as a reason for proscription (which we already knew). Paragraph 139 lists the many different criminal offences people can and have been tried on to show there is no need for proscription because there are other non-terrorist offences available. This weakens the governments case.
  49.  
  50. A valid criticism was that they didn't discuss Filton acquittals but that would have involved further submissions and a delayed result.
  51.  
  52. Didn't allow comparisons with JSO/XR
  53.  
  54. The court said that Palestine Action had to be considered on it's own merits and they weren't there to judge whether JSO and XR were terrorist groups as they had no evidence and it wasn't their job to. (para 144)
  55.  
  56. The motive for stopping genocide is irrelevant (paragraph 70)
  57.  
  58. Here he misunderstands the judgement. It is discussing the HS decision to proscribe. It says the point is irrelevant because it is "obvious" the HS knew PA's motives (para 71) and that the question of whether that motive was relevant was better considered as part of the ECHR ground 2 argument.
  59.  
  60. National security justify interference (paras 128-130)
  61.  
  62. Again Murray is being disingenuous here. He is quoting the part of the judgement which says that national security or protection of others CAN justify interference with Article 10/11. We all agree on that, people don't have a right to be tell Muslims to go home, to hold napalm making workshops etc.
  63.  
  64. He misses out paras 138-140 where it says the interference is disproportionate.
  65.  
  66. Overall, the court finding is that PA did some activities that would be covered by the Terrorism Act but that proscription is still unlawful and disproportionate. Murray has picked out various paragraphs which were designed to be read together. The reason for doing that seems to be to fit his ad hominem framing of "hand picked, known right wing judges".
Advertisement
Add Comment
Please, Sign In to add comment