Defiant is NOT ruled OOT. Wizard gets to keep that character.

Reading through these, I think I am going to go with GuyOfEvil.

While we don't want you to outright lie, opening with: "Grue is an utterly unremarkable physical combatant, who will likely die the moment any serious opponent gets within arms reach of him" automatically reads like a concession in some aspect and is something your opponent can quickly capitalize on. I was also more convinced about Guy's path to victory then I was with Wizard's. Guy sets up the notion that Mirror Master acting on his default behavior will be enough to claim the win, while indicating his opponent's characters would need to act in a hyperoptimal and almost meta-gamey nature to snag their win. This is a point Guy emphasizes, and emphasizes well.

Guy's team will likely act and work more effectively as argued. Guy wins.