Spin The Bottle at Natsuki's Birthday Party!

>its Natsuki's birthday party!
>Natsuki doesn't have a lot of friends, so the party is only the literature club
>you feel awkward being the only boy in a party full of girls!
>Natsuki's house is very messy since her dad is "kinda a hoarder" so you are at Yuri's house
>conveniently enough, Yuri's parents are on a business trip so you five have the house yourself!
>you met Yuri's parents before they left and it was pretty awkward but you are pretty sure you left a good impression
>they seem to trust you and the bunch so that is good
>Yuri gets Natsuki a teddy bear, Monika gets her a jellybean sampler and a pink hardback notebook, Sayori gets her a ukulele, and you give her Yoshi's Island
>despite Natsuki's personality, she really seems to genuinely appreciate the presents and even gets a bit teared up
>Yuri comforts her by rubbing her back and she calms down and gives a final thank you to everyone
>the party resumes!
>you all four gather around a laptop to order a pizza and 2 liter pepsi
>while you wait you four show each other YouTube videos, varying in types of humor and length
>you spend the next few hours amassing a playlist of your combined music tastes, which you listen to while talking to all sorts of topics
>theres no cutting each other off or any one person talking more than the other which makes everyone happy, especially Natsuki who often feels like she fades into the background in social circles
>Monika suggests the idea of spin the bottle and everyone seems just as excited for the idea as they are nervous
>in retrospect it kind of feels you're trying to assume the roles of fun-loving highschoolers, because you're all pretty awkward kids and don't really know what you're doing
>but that doesnt matter because you all are having fun
>Yuri grabs a slab of wood and an empty glass pepsi bottle and sets it up
>Natsuki and Yuri's responses die down because of their exponentially increasing nervousness
>Monika seems slightly nervous but mostly pretty confident, and Sayori seems ignorantly blissful but also a bit nervous
>you spin the bottle and it lands on Monika
>Monika spins it and watches as it slowly points towards Yuri
>Yuri has a dark passive look but once she realizes its pointing towards her she has a delayed reaction
>her face goes pale and her eyes go about as wide as plates it seems
>you cant help but giggle but at the same time you feel bad because you know how incredibly nervous she is
>Yuri tries and fails to fake confidence by saying "alright, l-lets get this over with"
>she leans over the slab and bottle and kisses Monika on the lips
>theres a moment when their lips are touching and her eyes dart around like a wild animal
>everyone is blushing just watching, but Yuri's whole face has turned into a tomato
>the kiss finishes off and they seperate
>Monika has a mischievous smile and you realize she takes some sadistic enjoyment in Yuri's light-hearted embarrassment
>you can tell Monika has done this quite a few times which strikes you as funny and fitting
>"good job, Yuri" Monika says
>everyone nods and smiles, as if they were a bunch of judges for a spinthebottle contest
>Yuri smiles and even looks a bit prideful
>"I'm pretty experienced as you can see" Yuri says and everyone laughs, including her
>you spin the bottle again and it lands on you
>you were already nervous but now the show is on
>all the girls are staring at you with slightly wide eyes
>monika has that mischievous smile still and Natsuki has no expression to hide her half-fear half-excitement
>the bottle does its dramatic slow-down and eventually lands on Natsuki
>she blushes and says "aw shit"
>everyone laughs (including Natsuki a tiny bit) as none of you have heard Natsuki cuss before
>this one is somehow even more awkward then the one with Monika and Yuri
>leaning across the slab is awkward and pressing your lips together is awkward
>at first you and Natsuki's eyes dart around to avoid eye contact but eventually you submit to the intimacy of the act and your eyes meet
>the kiss lasts longer than probably you or Natsuki meant, and eventually the world fades away around you for a second because the moment is a bit wonky and intense
>you eventually separate and sit back, your eyes still locked, and everyone's blushing madly
>theres a moment of pure silence before everyone bursts into laughter, and youre relieved to find the tension has vanished
>once the laughter settles down Natsuki blushes a vibrant red and looks at you with a half smile
>she asks with a genuine tone "c-can we do it again?"