Not a member of Pastebin yet?
Sign Up,
it unlocks many cool features!
- I am here to prove parents should be able to vote on behalf of their children.
- The model that we are proposing today is modelled off the Demeny voting system, similar to that which is in force in Hungary. This would extend to every democratic country. In this system the guardians of a child would each receive an additional half vote for every child that they have. A child being any person under the age of 18 at the time of the referendum or election. A guardian according to law is the primary care giver ie. The mother plus the father provided they are willing and fit according to court. In the case there is one parent he/she would receive one vote per child. In the instance that they are in the care of the state the foster parents would exercise this right for them. This half-vote would be used by the parents to vote for the party they feel represents a child’s best interests. This vote is subject to being influenced by the child’s beliefs at the discretion of the parent. All laws restricting campaigning to minors would still be inforce.
- To begin I would like to quote the United Nations declaration of human rights. An agreement over 200 countries including Ireland signed. Article 21 section 1 “EVERYONE has the right to take part in the government of his country as well as in free periodic genuine elections either directly or through freely chosen representatives.” Allow me to stress this. This bill of rights makes absolutely no justification for restricting the voting rights of youths. It clearly uses the word “everyone” in which children are inevitably a part. It then says this can by expressed through a representative. This is essentially the model of demeny voting as children are either taking part through their parents or being represented by them. Our current voting system goes against this policy as by not including children we cannot say that EVERYONE is included. Essentially what the restricted voting is doing now is repressing rights given to children by the U.N. and moreover that the Irish state explicitly agreed to give them. When someone is given a right it is the unwavering duty of the state to uphold this right. Hence our current system is in contempt of agreements that we have agreed to and is therefore illegitimate. In turn our model works on these principles making it the viable solution to the problems brought about by the current system.
- Across the world the struggle for democracy has been something that most countries have undergone. And even when this battle was won there was consistent disenfranchisement. Until the early 20th century women could not vote in any country because apparently they would simply just vote for whatever the head of the house ie. The husband would. Less than 25 years ago you couldn’t vote in South Africa if you were black, because it was claimed you didn’t know enough. Fast forward to now and we haven’t changed our arguments, just who they’re directed at. Children are well capable of forming their own opinions. For example during the marriage equality referendum a staggering 90% of 18-21 year olds intended to vote in favour compared to 52% of the 45-55 age group which typically would be their parents. These people typically would have grown up with these opinions so the assumption that being under 18 automatically means you have no concept of politics worthy of notoriety is a gross generalisation which clearly does not always hold true. Hence these arguments are comparable at least in principle to restricted voting policies based on skin colour and gender. And hence should be treated and subsequently rejected as such. Essentially what I am saying is that all these concepts of democracy are being made a blatant mockery of. “No taxation without representation??” children are forced to pay taxes like everybody else such as V.A.T still have no representation. Lyndon B. Johnson “a man without a vote is a man without protection”. And the people who arguably need protection the most are the ones without that vote. The demeny voting system would change all of this because they would have that crucial say.
- It is clear that from an ideological perspective by not implementing this model we are in direct conflict with the values that constitutes a democratic society.
- On a final note a final note. Our country has a fifth of our population of 5 million under the age of 18. Essentially the whim of one man of voting age trumps that of 1 million citizens. And that I’m sure we can agree is something that requires serious reform.
Advertisement
Add Comment
Please, Sign In to add comment