Flutterrape Halloween Special: Too Spooky For You

>Dark and stormy night
>You and the Mane Six are headed towards a supposedly haunted mansion
>You're all going to spend a night in there
>Rainbow Dash dared everyone to go including you
>She's been building it up to be the scariest thing ever
>Everyone is a little nervous
>Everyone except you
I don't see the big deal. It's some abandoned place of course it's going to to look desolate and banged up. There's nothing to see here, let's just turn back...
>Rainbow Dash scoffs and flies circles around you
>"What's the matter Anon? Are you chickening out on us?"
No, I just don't see the point in this. This all feels like that start of a bad Halloween-erm Nightmare Night Special.
>Pinkie makes some chicken noises at you
>Applejack chuckles
>"Ya sure Anon? You're talking down the whole thing, ponies talk down things when they're nervous.."
No seriously-
>Rarity is eyeing everything nervously
>"Don't worry, Anon I too can let my nerves get the best of me."
>Twilight nods, laughing nervously
>"It's okay to be afraid."
>Fluttershy is shaking like crazy
>She moves closer to you and nuzzles your side
>"D-don't *squeak* worry A-anon ...I'll protect you..."
>Roll your eyes
>Fluttershy is probably more spooky and dangerous to you than the house itself
>She rubs your backside gently
>You jump away
>The others think you got startled by your nerves
>They laugh
>God damn it!
You know what!? I'll prove I'm not scared! I'll go in first!
>Before anyone else can saying you strut on ahead to the front door
>Door opens by itself
>Too pissed to notice
>Walk right in
See? Nothing here..well actually this mansion has a lot of furniture I'd like to take home with me...
>"Careful Anon, you don't want to steal from the ghosts and monsters living in here!"
>Rainbow Dash wraps her hooves around your eyes
Let go
>"You're no fun Anon..."
>The others enter
>For a while everyone stands around awkwardly
>Twilight takes this moment to speak up
>"So we're spending the night in here? Where do we all sleep?
>"That lovely couch is where I'll be sleeping."
>"Ooh! The attic I want to see the monsters!"
>"Anywhere really."
>"An actual bedroom, Sugarcube."
>"Uh *shiver* wherever I c-can keep Anon w-warm and s-safe."
Wherever she's not sleeping
>Before this conversation can continue any further, you all hear a loud banging noise from an unknown location
>Everyone jumps and huddles close together
>Fluttershy has wrapped her forehooves around your neck
>And her hindhooves are on your midsection
Let go
>"Eeeeep!"
It's probably just a rat
>Rarity shudders
>"Why did I agree to come to such a filthy place?"
>Pry Fluttershy off
>The noise repeats itself
>Everyone jumps once more
>Fluttershy is back on you again
>Fucking noise
>Lightning strikes outside
>The lantern that Twilight was levitating goes out
>The six mares scream their lungs out
>Then silence
>After about a few seconds another lantern comes on from across the main room
>Everyone but you, and Yellow Pone clinging to you are gone
Okay....this has to be a bad prank.
...Fluttershy get off!
>"No!"
>"I h-have to k-keep you safe, mister!"
>She's shaking so badly it's causing you to shake
Great of all the ponies I have to be stuck with, it's you.
>She doesn't pick up on the sarcasm
>"I'm gl-glad you th-think so Anon. I like being alone w-with you too. Although this time is so...scary..."
>She nuzzles you
We can't find our friends if you're stuck onto me like this....
>Takes about 10 minutes for her to finally get off of you
>You've got to get to the bottom of this
>Still think this is an elaborate prank
>Scared now, anyway
>Begin walking down a narrow dark hallway
>Disregard Fluttershy
>"Wait don't leave me here!"
>She follows after to you
Honestly Fluttershy you're always trying to force yourself on me, and I don't feel safe around you.
>She whimpers
>"I'm sorry Anon, I like you a lot and I just want you and I to feel very good. I know the day I succeed um ...you'll like it..."
>Shake your head and walk faster
>"B-but! Tonight I won't umm rut...you...unless you... want me to of course..."
Ugh, whatever, fine, okay! Just help me find our friends
>She nods frantically
Alright so, let's look for a bathroom first
>"Um why a bathroom?"
>She gets wingboners, and blushes
>Weirdo...
Because one of our friends is most likely in there. Or a key or something. I don't know, why not.
>Keep walking with Banana Hush close behind
>Her tail keeps spanking your backside
>Not sure if on purpose or not
>Door at the end of the hallway
>Suddenly hear a voice
>"0o0o0o0o0o0o0o0o~"
>Laugh
>Seriously?
>Fluttershy hides behind her mane and shivers
>"Uh, oh Anon!"
>Fluttershy jumps into your arms
Cmon, It can't be a ghost....
>She doesn't respond
Let's go in now
>"N-no..."
Yes
>Shakes her head
>Holds onto you tightly
>Sigh
Okay, what will it get you to go in there with me?
>"*mumble mumble*"
Huh?
>"Fl*mumble*"
>Lean in very closer
>"A F-fluttersnack..."
What the hell is a flu-umph!
>She forces a wet sloppy kiss on you
>"mmmmm~"
>Her tongue violates every inch of your mouth
>Drop her
>She holds the kiss by hovering
>Tail tickles your crotch
>Break the kiss
What the hell was that?!
>"A Fluttersnack."
You wanted a kiss for courage? You're supposed to ask for those first... Not that I would have given one to you though...
>Blush
>Stupid Fluttershy
Okay let's go
>She whimpers
You had your fucking "Fluttersnack", let's go!
>Kick door open
>It's a bathroom
>Of course
>"Oo0o0o0oO0o0o!"
Pinkie?
>"Oh hiya Anon, I've been using the echoes in here to disguise as a ghost!"
I'm not even going to ask why you're not concerned. Do you know how you ended up here? Is this some prank?
>"Well when the lights went out, I felt something move me around."
>"Then I ended up here!"
>Fluttershy gasps
>"Pinkie, was it a m-monster?"
>Pinkie shrugs her withers
>"All I know is that it carried somepony out into the backyard."
>Still think this is one big prank
Well then let's go to the backyard already.
By, the way...is there a key in here?
>She giggles
>"Why would there be a key in here silly?"
>"M-maybe his fetish is to be locked in the bathroom with us...."
It's not, trust me.
....Lead the way Pinkie
>Pinkie runs off and you and Yellow pony have to sprint to keep up with her
>When you arrive in the backyard Pinkie is nowhere to be found
>Great, stuck with a potential rapist again
>"Ummm Anon?"
>Backyard is a graveyard
>....Really?
>.......REALLY?!
WHAT NEXT? THRILLER?!
>"Anon, the m-monster might hear you!"
>Suddenly, as if the universe had heard your plight and laughed it's ass off, glowing corpses of ponies started rising out of the grave
Okay listen Fluttershy, if you don't want to get eaten you have to know the Thriller dance
>Show her the dance
>Zombie ponies copy you
>Sigh
>You begin thriller dancing your way back towards the mansion
>Fluttershy follows, but trips on you
Oh no...
>Zombies encircle the two of you
>Fluttershy hugs your midsection
>"No! Take me first!"
>"I just want to let you know that I love you, Anon!"
>Think you might die too
Ummm you've been a friend, a creepy one, but a friend, a rapey one, but a friend.
And maybe if I live through this...I might consider-
>Zombieponies suddenly all drop to the ground
>What?
>Twilight appears from behind a large grave
>"Oh my gosh! I'm sorry! I was levitating those corpses to scare off monsters!"
>"I panicked and didn't know it was you and Anon!"
>Nice use of corpses Twilight...
>She helps Fluttershy up first
>Then you
How did you know about Thriller?
>"I didn't I saw you dance like that and thought it was a mutual thing among monsters..."
>Oh....
So, do you know where Pinkie or anyone else went off to?
>"I heard noises from the kitchen."
May as well. I still think you're all playing me here...
>As you turn to leave feel patting on your ass
>Turn around
>Fluttershy
>"You said if you lived through that ordeal that you would consider something?"
No! Nothing, forget it!
>Arrive at the kitchen
>Twilight is nowhere to be found
Oh for the love of!?
Next time this happens I'm entering the destined location first! And if I get grabbed or something I'll call out for help!
>The kitchen has all tons of pots and pans
>It's super cold
>Like ten fucking kelvin cold
>Fluttershy is shaking and crying
>She's truly terrified over this whole ordeal
>May as well comfort her
>Pull her into a hug
>"Eep!"
Stop being such a baby, there's no monster, no ghosts, our friends are just having fun at our expense. I'm sure of it.
>She's super warm and soft
>And this kitchen is freezing
>Don't let go
>"Oh Anon, you really like it don't you?"
>Notice you have your cheek buried into her mane
>Your hands are under her wings
>Pull away flustered
It's not what it looks like, I admit you're soft and warm and it's cold in here! That's it though!
>"You can experience that anytime you want mister."
>"Thanks for trying to comfort me...how about I comfort you..."
>She get's bedroom eyes
>"With a Fluttersnack...."
>Oh no..nonononononono
>She surges forward
>Luckily you're saved by a frying pan flying out
by itself and hitting your face
>Oh boy you're not falling for this again
>Pots and pans are now circling around the two of you
>Hear loud clanging of pots from somewhere as well
We're not monsters or something like that! Come out whoever you are....
>"Oh Dear...."
>"Heheh oops."
>Rarity and Applejack pop out from behind the counter
Yeah I knew this was a prank.
>Rarity shakes her head
>"No Darling, we really saw it! The thing that grabbed us, it went upstairs!"
>"I was hoping that the noise my Granny makes to scare off the timber wolves would also scare it."
>"And I was using the items in the kitchen to defend ourselves, we're very sorry."
Okay great, let's go upstairs
>"Anon are you crazy? We're not going after that monster!"
>"I agree with Rarity, I'll be in the living room if ya need me."
>"I'm with you, Applejack."
Okay fine, go ahead....ugh
>Realize something
Oh! Take Fluttershy with you!
>Thank god
>"No, I said I would protect you mister."
>Damn
>"I'm staying with you, if that's okay with you."
Ugh suit yourself Flutterbutt, second story here we come!
>Dash is up there
>You're sure
>The second story wasn't very large it had only a few rooms
>Walking down the hallway was unnerving this time, mostly because you knew that the final prank was about to commence
>"*meow*?"
Aaaaugh!
>Fluttershy gasps
>"Now look here Ms.Kitty, that's very mean to scare Anon like that!"
>The cat hisses
>Fluttershy gives it the stare
>It backs away
>"Now what do you say?"
>"*meow*..."
>"Good, she won't bother you anymore Anon."
>Fluttershy rubs your ass and gives it a gentle smack
>"Is being defended your fetish anon?"
No!
>Hear laughing
>Rainbow Dash....
>You were pissed
>This night has been nothing but stupid situations and you're sure this has all been some dumb prank
>See Dash
>Walk over to her
Look here Dash! You all have not been fooling me, maybe Fluttershy but not me!
>"What do you mean Anon? I just thought it was funny how you were all high and mighty about not being scared, and a stray cat scared you."
>She chuckles
I haven't been scared! At least not by this fake monster or ghost or whatever this thing is supposed to be!
>She doesn't respond
This is just some dumpy ass place, and nothing more!
>Still not responding
>Fluttershy nudges your side
>"Um Anon..."
WHAT?! Are you going to ask me if stupid hoaxes are my fetish?
>Rainbow Dash flutters up to your eye level
>Turns your head
>See a tall dark headless pony
Oh....
>Turn to look at Rainbow Dash but she's flown off in fear
>Fluttershy looks at you
>You look at her
Zoinks!
>"AAAAAAAAAA!"
AAAAAAAAAAA!
>You both run out of there with the headless horse trailing close behind
>It chases you into a dining hall
>It's gaining on you
>Jump on Fluttershy's back
>"Oh Anon~ I had no idea-"
Now is not the time! Fly! You shy little banana horse!
>Fluttershy flies off
>In next room, it's a library
>Lose balance
>Both of you fall down into the maze of bookshelves
>You two begin sneaking toward the next room
>"Hehehe~ Anon that tickles. Can you got a little lower, sweetie?"
>What.
I'm not touching you
>Turn around to see headless horse tickling Fluttershy's flank
>It then makes a mocking gesture at the two of you
>You both run even faster
>You're almost to the living room now!
>The headless horse is right at your heels
>You all step into the living room at once
>Net trap is set off
>You're all caught in the net
>Twi, Dash, AJ, Pinkie, and Rarity pop out
>"You two made excellent decoys!"
Fuck...you....
>Fluttershy seems to love the close contact the net gives
>Because she's dry humping you with all her might
>The headless horse tries to back away from the two of you, clearly disgusted
>Twilight uses her magic to undo the net
>The headless horse falls dazed
>Pinkie rushes up to it
>"Now to find out who the headless horse really is!"
>Is this going where you think it is?
>You're having difficultly containing your rage at this point
>Pinkie tears off the costume
>It's
>It's!?
>Everyone including you shout out
Mr.Waddle?!
>"That's right!"
>The royal guards rush into the mansion and take him into custody
B-b-b-but what?
Why?!
How?!
>"And I would have gotten away for it too if it weren't for you meddling mares and your human!"
>Wait you thought you were sha-
Okay!? Why would he even be here?!
This makes no sense!
What crime did he even commit or attempt to commit?!

(Stop the story! Stop the story!
>"What's wrong Anon?"
)


What's wrong is that this ghost story you've all been telling together makes no sense!
>Dash shrugs
>"I thought it was alright."
Yeah but why Mr.Waddle?
He wasn't established at any point previous, not in Pinkie's part of the story, not in Twilight's, not in Rarity's and Applejack's, and not even yours Dash! And Fluttershy I know you're gonna make me have sex with you when it's your turn to tell the story!
>Fluttershy blushes sheepishly
>"Well....I do want to do that."
And that's another thing, why did you all make this about me? And why with Fluttershy? You know she and I have our issues right?! With the whole rape thing?
>Rarity giggles
>"You two would make a cute couple."
>Nods from all around
Yeah try having a weird stallion try to rape you Rarity and then see how you feel when someone says you'd make a cute couple....
>Twilight sighs
>"Alright Anon, if it will make you happy it can be your turn to tell the story."
Gladly!
>You clear your throat


>Suddenly Mr.Waddle is let go because he did nothing illegal
>Everyone listened to Anon's reason that they should go home and stop being in a retarded abandoned mansion
>Also Fluttershy died of AIDS 3 Months later
>The End

(
>"You really suck at this Anon."
>"Hey! I thought the mansion concept was great!"
>"*Snf* I-is.... AIDS your fetish, Anon?"
>"Anon you brute, that was so rude to poor Fluttershy!"
Oh boo hoo! You guys made a million jokes at my expense in this story...
>"No need to get saddle-sore there partner"
>"So I guess we can check scary story's off the list now?"
>Fucking Nightmare Night
)