Not a member of Pastebin yet?
Sign Up,
it unlocks many cool features!
- Dear, http://www.objectivegamereviews.com
- I would like to make a complaint about the contents of the reviews on your site. Most of the reviews are vague with regards to the way the games operate, lacking a very very wide breadth of information. They make more observations about the game than the typical game review, which typically glazes over all sorts of details. That's commendable in its own right, but the reviews lack in tons and tons of information. I am going to go into detail on how some reviews lack. Tf you are uninterested in these details, as you probably are, given they didn't make them into the reviews in the first place, then please skip past them. To highlight the hotline miami review http://www.objectivegamereviews.com/hotline-miami-review/ in particular:
- "The game has 21 levels. The player can equip a number of weapons that they take from dead enemies, including firearms like shotguns and melee weapons like crowbars and knives. Firearms make a lot of noise and attract enemies. Enemy types include normal human beings, dogs, and large human beings who must be shot to be killed."
- First, this lacks a description of the melee weapons individually, or as a generalized group, contrasting their various properties, such as some weapons being longer or shorter than others, or the unique characteristics of some melee weapons, like the drill which cannot be used to kill except by execution, which it has a unique and long animation for.
- This does not specify the different types of firearms (come on, there are only 4, you could stand to list all of them) or how they differ in function, between burst fire, automatic fire, amount of ammunition, number of bullets fired, the refire rate, and lethality of the weapon. Additionally there is no mention of how walls and doors dampen noise.
- Furthermore it doesn't mention how weapon drops from enemies are partially randomized with enemies dropping from a set of possible weapons depending on the weapon type they were carrying.
- There are more enemy types than that, and each generalized type can carry different weapons, further varying the set of behaviors that an enemy can exhibit. The review makes no mention of the different AI patterns of the different enemy types (like how dogs pounce where ranged enemies fire on spotting) or properties thereof, such as how some enemies can be knocked down and executed where others cannot (like waiters, the large men, and the dogs). It's mentioned that the large men need to be shot to be killed, but not that they have more health than other enemies and only melee attacks.
- "All weapons can be thrown to knock down enemies, and enemies can be knocked down if they are standing behind a door the player runs through. Enemies who are knocked down can be executed by the player. The player earns additional points for killing enemies in certain ways and for accumulating a combo by killing many enemies in a short period. The player chooses from a variety of animal masks when the level begins, and each mask grants a different special power, like the ability to kill enemies with doors."
- The first two sentences are actually fairly accurate, but neglect to mention that enemies can be knocked down using the player's fists as well, and will drop their weapon when knocked down, they can also end up crawling on the ground, or propped up against a wall. Executions require the repeated beating of the enemy in the knocked down state, each beating requiring its own input, and cannot be exited until the enemy is executed, leaving the player vulnerable to other attacks if they are not in a secure location. Also it fails to mention how most melee weapons and all ranged weapons outright kill the enemy, avoiding this knocked down state.
- There are other facets of the scoring system which are not covered here, and it doesn't specify what those certain ways are either.
- It's omitted how the animal masks are unlocked (by scoring), and seriously, you could stand to list all the powers if you want to be truly objective. It's also worth mentioning the order in which they're unlocked relative to the power they convey and how this affects the range of options first time players or repeat players have access to.
- There's no mention in the review of how levels are composed of floors, each composed of an entry area leading into the areas where the enemies are. Nor does it mention how the player's death results in restarting from the beginning of their current floor and there are no additional penalties for death, even repeated death, except for a score penalty.
- Perhaps most importantly, and most obviously, it fails to note how the controls even work. It barely manages to squeeze in that it's a top down action game, but somehow misses that it controls similarly to a twin stick shooter, with the player moving and aiming independently. Aiming is controlled by the mouse in the case of the PC, and stick in the case of other platforms, where it is literally a twin stick shooter. Players also have the option to look further ahead of them, which is not mentioned.
- Additionally it fails to bring up the design of even one level. It's not mentioned how any level is constructed, what orders the player is capable of facing enemies in, how the level is set up to force encounters with multiple enemies, how weapons are distributed through the level, or how levels introduce new concepts in them or have various gimmicks. The boss fight with helmet is not mentioned, nor the ending sequence for jacket.
- "The music in Hotline Miami is electronic music inspired by music from the 1980s. The game itself is set in the 1980s in Miami. The player receives calls from a hotline which tells them who to kill."
- The first two sentences are accurate, but the third is outright false. They receive a call that alleges to be from a variety of sources other than the hotline, and it does not directly inform them who to kill, it only provides an address while the rest of the message is completely innocuous. This also ignores the visits to various stores that occur, and the way in which the manager of those stores is replaced in subsequent visits, or the scenes in which the player encounters the various personified animal masks questioning them.
- Your review is insufficient, and I have done a better job of reviewing it in my process of critiquing your review than you have writing it. You can't get basic details straight, and omit tons of information.
- Apart from the site's reviews lacking in substance and glazing over many many many basic details of a game that a review should be making, this lack of detail could of course be construed as a bias, because there is only a partial representation of a game. The details featured about a game are seemingly chosen at random.
- An example of a more thorough analysis would be Daniel Johnson's critical analysis of Warioland 4, which exists to demonstrate precisely how game reviewers in general should be capable of observing a video game in order to make informed conclusions on it. And given that this site is supposedly objective, every review on it should be matching the format of this book precisely.
- http://stolen-projects.myshopify.com/collections/frontpage/products/game-design-companion-a-critical-analysis-of-wario-land-4
- To make his methods of presenting observations about the game more clear, here are screenshots of selections from the book across a range of topics: http://imgur.com/a/gzh9M
- To pick another example, which I happen to be an expert on, the Mirror's Edge review http://www.objectivegamereviews.com/mirrors-edge-review/ is massively lacking. It doesn't summarize even the basic moves or their functionality. It doesn't mention that the player can vault over obstacles such as low bars and instantly run at full acceleration, it doesn't contrast the different climbing animations with regards to the facing angle of the player and height of elevation. It doesn't mention the effect of speed on other animations such as wall running or climbing. It doesn't mention the turnaround key or the various turn jumps possible. It doesn't mention the coil jump, allowing the player to raise their legs to pass low obstacles, additionally making environmental features incapable of being interacted with until the animation ends. It doesn't mention the ability to roll in order to break falls from high heights, or the ability to roll on shorter non harmful drops, which has applications in a number of sections, especially because rolls that end with the player not standing on solid ground generate an invisible platform beneath them briefly which resets the fall distance, so the player can survive heights from much higher drops. You somehow managed to omit reaction time, which slows the game down, and in time trials also affects the speed of the clock. And how reaction time regenerates after a certain amount of movement, regenerating faster with faster movement.
- There's no mention of different enemy types or armoring. There's no mention of the way some can cross rooftops after you. There is no mention of how enemies can be disarmed by using the grab button when they attempt to melee attack you using their weapon and their weapon turns red. Also no mention of how enemies can be disarmed from behind if they are not alerted to you.
- It misses all the environmental features and how they all function differently. It misses any of the wealth of advanced techniques for the game, failing to even mention the principles of how motion works in the game, as the movement system is rather complex.
- "punching a door to open it" This is a glaring factual error as none of the punch animations possible are actually capable of opening doors, and if you do manage to hit a door with a punch animation, the door will actually remain closed. The only animations that can open doors are kicking animations, either the jumping kick, or the stationary forward kick, the exception being a shoulder vault possible when running at higher speeds, which is still not a punch. You are objectively wrong on this point.
- "To help clear her name, Faith can murder dozens of police officers." This is another factual error, Faith doesn't take a single action with the intent or result of clearing her name or her sister's name in the entire story. It's even announced after the credits that Faith and her sister escaped and are still being pursued by police. Did you even beat this game? The entire focus of the plot is figuring out the reason Pope was murdered and rescuing Kate, not clearing Faith's name. You are objectively wrong on this point.
- "twenty three time trial maps drawn from the story missions" Again incorrect, some of the time trials are not drawn from story missions at all.
- Here I am going to refrain from using as much detail as in my hotline miami review criticism in the interest of time and space, but again it can be clearly demonstrated how this review is lacking on a basic formative level, in addition to being objectively wrong on a number of points.
- Yeah, I'm aware this is a satire site. I'm critiquing it like it's serious because your parody sucks and doesn't prove the point you set out to prove and you'd be creating something of more worth to everyone if you were actually thorough in describing how the whole game works. Fix your shit or shut up shop. If you wanted to you could do analysis like I just did or like daniel johnson does and actually contribute something useful to the field of games critique, actually be a valuable resource to all the people out there trying to learn about and understand games. If you want to continue making shitty satire intended to mock people who want better reviews then you can go fuck yourself.
- Leave reviewing to the literal experts or yourself become an expert instead of starting up a dumb site with the obvious agenda of mocking people who want more precise reviews based on objective observations about a game, something that is massively lacking in current games critcism, which is largely run by non-experts, such as Jim Sterling, who started the "objective" review joke in the first place. The agenda becomes increasingly obvious with reviews like this one: http://www.objectivegamereviews.com/stanley-parable-demo/ which gives the demo a 10 and is even more vague about the structure of it than the other reviews on the site.
- Many of the actual experts on games, which I will restate for the purpose of vindictiveness, most game reviewers are not, are capable of making qualitative judgments about a game on a basis of the game's contents and furthermore are capable of actually summarizing details about the function of the game in a perfectly objective manner, which is a necessary prerequisite to even attempting to make qualitative remarks in a critical fashion. Clear examples of this are in this video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=d2RckfYLVXI which not only makes qualitative judgments about the game but very precisely identifies what elements within the game lead to this judgment in a reasonable manner. Further objective analysis examples exist in this guide to "footsies" for street fighter http://sonichurricane.com/?page_id=1702 or this guide to the workings of Capcom versus SNK 2 http://www.gamefaqs.com/arcade/562704-capcom-vs-snk-2/faqs/15064 And these represent an important contrast because one is objectively summarizing the details of the engine and the other is objectively summarizing effective tactics in battle that have been proven both through tournament experience and citations of specific footage from tournaments.
- This site is plastering review scores on games without any qualitative remarks justifying their scoring, which I'm perfectly aware is the intent of the site. Because it's a good way of covering a lot of journalists' asses to say that you cannot come to a conclusion without a subjective analysis of the content, thereby justifying their failure to analyze the content on any basis of objective fact about the content, but rather vague subjective opinions without backing.
- Seriously, you're the worst type of games writer, intentionally trying to ruin things for everyone to cover a few unqualified people's asses instead of doing the job justice and providing a valuable critical resource for everyone. I'd love to personally join your site and rewrite all of your reviews to the utmost detail possible, but I have standing real life obligations, and I already write for http://www.gatheryourparty.com
- Sincerely,
- Chris Wagar
Advertisement
Add Comment
Please, Sign In to add comment