Advertisement
Not a member of Pastebin yet?
Sign Up,
it unlocks many cool features!
- **Public Matters** (working title)
- by Andrew Clement
- What Snowden has revealed is a complex, institutionalized system of mass
- surveillance that is deeply embedded within and operating through our
- state and corporate apparatus. Only through a major collective
- investigative effort drawing on multiple perspectives can we adequately
- come to grips with its scope, consequences and remedial possibilities.
- An archive such as the one we developed would be an essential resource
- in this effort. See https://snowdenarchive.cjfe.org <https://snowdenarchive.cjfe.org/>
- Looking at ground breaking leaks, especially with regard to how society
- managed (or not) to archive them, we can learn from history. For me the
- most relevant prior leak that had great social significance was
- whistleblower Daniel Ellsberg's leak of the Pentagon Papers. Making
- public authoritative internal documents about the Vietnam War that
- showed that officials were routinely lying about the motivations and
- state of the war played an important role in public opposition to the
- war and the eventual US withdrawal.
- The Snowden documents have a similar potential power because they too
- show in detail shocking government activities and bald lying by public
- officials. Conditions are of course different than in 1971 when the
- Pentagon Papers became public. There was already a strong social
- movement opposing the Vietnam war to which the Pentagon Parers added
- fuel. At present, there is only a nascent, still quite weak social
- movement opposing state surveillance.
- The potential value of the Snowden leak is to help coalescing and
- broadening opposition Furthermore there appears to be have been more
- dissent in 1971 among the upper political strata than is the case now,
- making the challenge of changing direction even more formidable.
- **Public education about mass surveillance**
- I had several motivations in initiating the Snowden Surveillance Archive
- project, mainly having to do with helping to promote and inform the
- public debate around mass state surveillance. Now that we know our
- state security agencies are conducting fine grained surveillance of
- everyone's electronic activities, we as a society have very serious
- choices to make about the appropriate role for secretive security
- agencies in a democracy.
- If we do nothing, then we will have accepted de facto that our everyday
- lives are open to scrutiny by unaccountable government agencies. This I
- believe is inimical to the foundations of democracy and we run a high
- risk of becoming police states. Reining in these agencies and
- eliminating those aspects that are not justifiable is a very difficult,
- but necessary task. It can only be accomplished when substantial numbers
- are well enough informed about the existing surveillance practices and
- the threats they pose, to take effective remedial action.
- Given the secrecy and complexity of the practices involved, a
- pre-condition is public education about mass surveillance is vital. This
- is something that I have been pursuing in my research for several years,
- especially around the IXmaps.ca project that seeks to show people the
- paths their data takes across the internet and where it may be
- intercepted by the NSA.
- Firstly, I wanted a searchable archive of the Snowden documents for this
- research, so I could better locate and identify surveillance sites of
- the NSA and its Five Eyes partners that I could include in the on-going
- IXmaps work. It seemed like a pretty obvious idea, so was surprised I
- couldn't find such an archive already available. I had some research
- funds, and looked for someone in my Faculty's Archive and Records
- Management specialization who was interested in the subject matters that
- I could hire. I was fortunate to find George Raine, a trained archivist
- who had recently graduated from our masters program. George was keen to
- be involved in the project, had many of the necessary skills and was up
- for learning what else was needed.
- More generally it struck me that many other opportunities were opened up
- by the Snowden documents that could lead to academic and journalistic
- research and reporting that weren't addressed by the media coverage to
- date. Apart from Glenn Greenwald's No Place to Hide book, reporting has
- consisted almost entirely of sensational stories based on a relatively
- small handful of documents newly released with the article. The
- ability to see an individual document in a wider context and to pursue
- threads across the whole range of documents makes possible a more
- penetrating inquiry into the driving forces and overall nature of mass
- surveillance.
- **The archive's architecture**
- Given my primary goal of promoting an open, informed public debate, I
- intended from the beginning to create a widely accessible on-line
- archive under free/open licences.
- The Snowden archive is built using Greenstone, a suite of software for
- building and distributing digital library collections. It is produced by
- the New Zealand Digital Library Project at the University of Waikato,
- and developed in cooperation with UNESCO and the Human Info NGO. Being
- open source, it is widely used around the world for digital library
- initiatives, especially in developing countries. We recognize that
- Greenstone does not have many features of more recently developed
- digital archive platforms. Once we get a better sense of the needs of
- Archive users we may consider porting to another platform.
- The Snowden Archive that is available on the Canadian Journalists for
- Free Expression (CFJE) website has been highly customized. Documents
- are described according to a custom metadata schema that is sensitive to
- contextual elements of the Snowden documents that are not present in
- most other document collections, such as security classification codes
- and distribution markings. The look and feel of the collection,
- including the format of the document descriptions have also been very
- heavily modified from the standard Greenstone template.
- The vast majority of documents released by the media are PDF files. In
- their original form, there were a lot of powerpoint files and other
- proprietary formats. The newspapers did work for us by releasing them in
- PDF and PDF/A, which are both very widely used, open-source formats. We
- determined that there was little likelihood that PDF files would become
- obsolete in the foreseeable future (it is an extremely widely used,
- open-source standard). If they do, it is easy to retrieve the documents
- from the collection and re-upload them in a different, more widely used
- format.
- **Linking to offline archives**
- There is also an initiative to develop an offline "Snowden Archive in a
- Box" developed by Evan Light at Concordia University's Mobile Media Lab
- where he works on privacy, surveillance and telecom issues.
- The Portable Snowden Surveillance Archive is an autonomous version of
- the fully text-searchable Internet-based archive Snowden Digital
- Surveillance Archive created by Canadian Journalists for Free Expression
- and researchers at the University of Toronto. It is a stand-alone wifi
- network and web server that permits you to research all files leaked by
- Edward Snowden and subsequently published by the press. The purpose of
- the portable archive is to provide end-users with a secure off-line
- method for individuals to use this database without the threat of mass
- surveillance.
- The Portable Snowden Surveillance Archive began as part of an evolving
- and touring European project called Performigrations
- (http://www.performigrations.eu <http://www.performigrations.eu/>) which focuses on migration/immigration
- and was launched in Montreal at the Blue Metropolis literary festival in
- April 2015. An evolving project in its own right, a current version of
- the Portable Archive also includes a surveillance demonstration
- apparatus that monitors wifi traffic around it and plays it back to the
- public. In June, it will be showcased at the Biografilm festival in
- Bologna, Italy – in partnership with Performigrations - and at the
- Citizenship and Surveillance Conference in Cardiff, Wales. The Portable
- Archive may appear in future Performigrations iterations in Europe and
- Canada.
- **The role of public libraries**
- I would like to see the Snowden Archive become more than a passive
- resource, but also a site for collaborative research and deliberation.
- Libraries certainly have an important role to play, especially public
- libraries as they go beyond their more conventional role of making
- materials accessible to devote more attention to facilitating discussion
- and deliberation within the communities they serve based on these materials.
- My own university library contacted me about archiving materials related
- to the Snowden Archive (specifically the media articles that published
- the documents). We're now working to have the library host a mirror of
- the entire Archive. Establishing mirroring sites is desirable in several
- ways. Besides improving accessibility and technical stability through
- redundancy, it also provides local users (say students) access to the
- collection without exposing their search traffic to internet
- interception and expresses solidarity with the ideals of open access to
- controversial materials.
- We've approached other universities as potential mirror sites, but so
- far this has been bogged down by the fact that the documents represent
- 'stolen goods' and so possessing them would be a criminal violation (at
- least in Canada). While the chance of prosecution is very small, legal
- departments in a couple of universities are balking. Going directly
- through the libraries themselves looks to be a better prospect as they
- both have the necessary technical capabilities and appear more oriented
- than university administrations to preserving academic freedoms around
- contentious holdings.
- While our current focus is on ensuring that the Archive is accessible to
- all, reliable, easy to use, accurate and updated as new documents are
- published, to fulfill its potential as a 'knowledge commons' around the
- issue of state surveillance, it also needs a community of engaged users
- who will conduct research based on the Archive and give wider public
- meaning to its contents. Ideally this would include people who can
- provide insightful annotations, contribute additional relevant
- documents, host mirrors, stimulate conversations, initiate collective
- research ventures, … While extending the software to support such
- distributed collaboration and animating the wider conversation is beyond
- our abilities at the moment, hopefully there are others who are willing
- and able to take this on.
- * Andrew Clement is a Professor in the Faculty of Information at the University
- of Toronto. He is a co-founder of the Identity, Privacy and Security Institute.
- His research and teaching interests are in the social implications of
- information/communications technology and human-centred systems
- development. Recent work focusses on public information policy for
- guiding the development of Canada’s information infrastructure,
- digitally mediated surveillance, privacy; digital identity
- constructions, public participation in information/communication
- infrastructures development, and community networking. He has also
- written papers and co-edited books in such areas as: internet use in
- everyday life, computer supported cooperative work; participatory
- design; workplace surveillance; women, work and computerization; end
- user computing; and the 'information society' more generally. See:
- http://iprp.ischool.utoronto.ca/
Advertisement
Add Comment
Please, Sign In to add comment
Advertisement