Advertisement
Guest User

Untitled

a guest
Aug 30th, 2016
76
0
Never
Not a member of Pastebin yet? Sign Up, it unlocks many cool features!
text 2.40 KB | None | 0 0
  1. Characters:
  2. Socrates:
  3. Has been charged with impiety by Meletus.
  4. Euthyphro
  5. Has just deposed murder charges against his
  6.  
  7. own father for murdering a servant.
  8. Setting:
  9. Agora (central marketplace) of Athens, in front of
  10.  
  11. the the offices of the magistrate.
  12.  
  13.  
  14. Summary of dialogue:
  15. S: impiety and piety are opposite right?
  16. E: Yes
  17. S: What is pious, and what is impious?
  18. E: Piety is to prosecute the wrongdoer, as I am
  19.  
  20. doing now.
  21. S: Do the gods fight?
  22. E: Yes
  23. S: You have told me an example of a pious action.
  24.  
  25. What is the form that makes all pious actions
  26.  
  27. pious?
  28. E: What is dear to the gods is pious, what is not
  29.  
  30. is impious.
  31. S: The gods disagree on many matters, and so they
  32.  
  33. will disagree on what is pious and what is not
  34.  
  35. pious.
  36. E: All gods will agree on some things.
  37. S: Is this true: What is pious is what all gods
  38.  
  39. love, and what is impious is what all gods hate.
  40. E: YEs
  41. S: Is an action pious because it is loved by the
  42.  
  43. gods, or is it loved by the gods because it is
  44.  
  45. pious?
  46. E: It is loved because it is pious. It is not pious
  47.  
  48. because it is loved.
  49. S: There is a contradiction. "An action is pious
  50.  
  51. because it is loved by all gods." and "It is not
  52.  
  53. pious because it is loved by all gods." contradict
  54.  
  55. each other.
  56.  
  57. S: Does piety imply justice?
  58. E: Yes
  59. S: Does justice imply piety?
  60. E: No
  61. S: So piety is a part of justice. What part of
  62.  
  63. justice is piety?
  64. E: piety is the part of the just that is concerned
  65.  
  66. with the care of the gods.
  67. S: What do you mean by care
  68. E: benefit of the object
  69. S: So is piety meant to make the gods better.
  70. E: No
  71. S: Then what do you mean by care?
  72. E: care in the way a slave takes of his master.
  73. S: to what aim does service to the gods tend?
  74. E: Many fine things
  75. S: What is their main concern?
  76. E: Pious actions preserve both private houses and
  77.  
  78. public affairs of state.
  79. S: Is piety knowledge of how to sacrifice and pray?
  80. E: Yes
  81. S: To sacrifice is to make a gift to the gods, and
  82.  
  83. to pray is to beg from the gods?
  84. E: Yes
  85. S: So piety is the knowledge of how to give to and
  86.  
  87. beg from the gods?
  88. E: Yes
  89. S: So piety is a sort of trading skill between gods
  90.  
  91. and men?
  92. E: Yes
  93. S: What do gods benefit from our gifts?
  94. E: We give the gifts of honor, reverence to please
  95.  
  96. them.
  97. S: So what is pious is what is dear to the gods?
  98. E: Yes
  99. S: We have already shown the problems with this
  100.  
  101. statement.
  102. E: It is time for me to go
Advertisement
Add Comment
Please, Sign In to add comment
Advertisement