Fairy

Faith discovers her fairy ancestry and powers when she sees a cat fall off a roof, and sprouts butterfly wings and flies to the rescue.

When telling her friend Cathy, a cosplayer and photographer, she says only that she jumped as if she were flying. But now Cathy wants to see Faith with wings, and asks her to come over and cosplay. Encouraged, Faith does so, and instead of wearing costume wings she lets out her own.

Cathy is delighted to have a fairy friend, and encourages Faith to explore her powers further. She puts on cat ear and tail accessories and suggests trying to bring them to life. But when Faith directs her magical energy at Cathy, the accessories fall off and Cathy changes temporarily into a real catgirl instead.

Cathy loves this and gets her other friends to try Faith's fairy magic too. Lupita the athlete becomes a wolfgirl, unsure at first but warming to it eventually. Serena the swimmer is granted a mermaid tail and never wants to leave her pool. And Mary the cook enjoys having more stomach space as a centaur. Vicky the model politely declines, liking her body the way it is, but promises to keep a secret.

One weekend they all go hiking/camping to have fun in their creature forms with no one else around. Along the way Cathy in her excitement climbs a little too high, then slips and falls. Faith flies up with her fairy wings and grabs Cathy, but a girl is somewhat heavier than a cat, so Faith can't hold her for long.

Lupita, Serena and Mary tell Faith to transform them. When she does, Mary rushes over at full gallop, carrying Lupita who bounds up the rocks, then leaps to grab Cathy as she slips out of Faith's hands. They fall into the nearby river where Serena guides them back to dry land. While they all share a triumphant moment, Vicky is at least curious about being an animalgirl and which one she would be.

At the campsite Vicky says she wants to try it. Faith's spell gives her fox ears and tail, and she falls in love with the look and feel of them. So goes the first of their many animalgirl adventures together.