I think I already wrote such a thread ...

Let's just do pro and con.

Millersmash pros :
- Make everyone play
- Allow new SL/PL/FC to get experience
- Open to the community, yeah !

cons :
- More complexe to organize
- Might not have enough volunteer / competent PL / FC (I think that's the real issue)
- Not sure a lot of midfits have the remaining players for this
- We alread bring almost everyone for a competitive match. For the Cobalt match we used almost every outfit. Only ORBS was not taken while they signed up with 12. Having 2 / 3 outfits in reserve is pretty sane and happened to be useful. So yeah, regarding fairness inside the team I'm pretty happy.