BigBadBoy: http://puu.sh/o8KOu/5c62ea6dac.png
LaxBro69: http://puu.sh/o8MjX/4391208ca9.png
100% WR for Big

https://epicmafia.com/game/4982432/review - both town. lax is sheriff. big dies n1. mafia CCs cop poorly and lax shoots right in CCs. fiveway lylo lax immediately votes maymay without outing why. only possible explanation would be that he joked about shooting maymay the previous day. next day he also immediately hammers right. big doesn't talk in the GY, but his next game starts significantly later than the end of this one, meaning he would've been in GY. implies GY vision.

https://epicmafia.com/game/4985848/review - both town. both blue. honestly this game is an advertisement for drinking bleach. long story short town gets a really easy win and none of the blues have to out any correct reads.

https://epicmafia.com/game/4985924/review - big town lax maf. lax is hooker, big is sheriff. his first lines in the game are http://puu.sh/o8NDq/2478badb35.png . his partner gets mad at him in night chat, but he just says "it's a joke man". d2 he barely talks. big shoots correctly in cop CCs, but mislynches in blues. n3 lax incorrectly hooks (and goes against his partner's suggestion), so town gets autowin. suggests throwing for big.

https://epicmafia.com/game/4988507/review - big town lax maf.  lax n1s big. he is then shot shortly into d2.

https://epicmafia.com/game/4988532/review - big mafia lax town.  lax is cop and big is mafia. big quickly votes lax as the night kill. suggests possible rolesharing.

https://epicmafia.com/game/4994124/review - both town. big is sheriff. lax says two things on d2 before big shoots the hooker, one of which is while the hooker is talking. strangely, big never FOSes him. either way, the rest of the day lax just throws out random reads that he never explains. big hammers a second mafia on the same day and gets town autowin. suggests rolesharing.

https://epicmafia.com/game/4994199/review - big mafia lax town. lax is cop. lax claims PR d1 for no adequate reason, and again, big quickly votes him for the kill n1. town FOSes big pretty early into d2 and he gets shot. suggests rolesharing/throwing for big.

conclusion: all the games that big and lax have played together are sketchy at best. lax has a history of playing trollishly, but in big's games, he mostly ISPs, even when they're on the same team. big never misreads lax in spite of this, and even correctly PR reads him. there is no basis for these reads to be so on point in spite of ISP. this on top of the 100% WR together suggests cheating

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

BigBadBoy: http://puu.sh/o8KOu/5c62ea6dac.png
epicsean368: http://puu.sh/o8TIf/1fb2fc50b5.png
100% WR for BigBadBoy

https://epicmafia.com/game/4980188 big maf epic town. Nothing here suggests cheating. epic Cop claimed with inno on blue, and bigbad hooked and killed a blue. epic was later killed the next day

https://epicmafia.com/game/4987228 big ig maf epic town. Epic had hammer on lax to give bigbad the win, but forced nl instead. based on these games, i'm gonna stop here and say these two arent cheating together.

Conclusion: Not cheating
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------


BigBadBoy: http://puu.sh/o8KOu/5c62ea6dac.png
Ubernaga:  http://prntscr.com/ap3fkk
100% WR for BigBadBoy

https://epicmafia.com/game/4987365/review big town, uber maf. Nothing heng here suggests cheating. Ubernaga killed bigbaboy during n3. Ubernaga had no reads on the PRs after BigBadBoy was killed. If they were cheating, it would make more sense to keep BigBadBoy alive in that situation.

https://epicmafia.com/game/4987326/review big town, uber maf. n2 mafia decided to kill outside the uncc'd cop that cannot be vested. BigBadBoy has been pushing on Uber since the begining of day 1. d3 epicsean got lynched based on a FoS from Sheriff. After game Uber claims to have not been there and to be confused on why cop didn't die, but he lead the kill outside of cop even though he was active throughouly when cop claimed d1.  Based on this game I'd suggest that its a possibility that Uber and BigBadBoy are cheating together or at the least role sharing.

Conclusion: BBB and Ubernaga are not definitely cheating based on the second game, however it could of just been a WIFOM play by the mafia members during n2 when they didn't kill the uncc'd cop. There's no reason for it, but could of been a fuck up. I'd be willing to rule against the cheating in this scenario.

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

BigBadBoy: http://puu.sh/o8KOu/5c62ea6dac.png
Marshallrake: http://prntscr.com/ap3kta
100% WR for BigBadBoy

https://epicmafia.com/game/4998743/review big town, marshall town. Marshall died n1. During d1, BBB didn't really FoS properly and didn't out any reads. d3 BBB suddenly seemed to know who the mafia was without outing reads nor attempting to scumhunt. Hammered the right mafia without reasoning. d4, BBB also didn't really attempt to scumhunt or attempt to out reads. He seemed just to be entering filler to make it seem like he was trying but demonstrated no effort. Based on this game, I'd be willing to say that BBB and Marshall are cheating after Marshall dies, probably outing the mafia to BBB through a third party chat system.

https://epicmafia.com/game/4998701/review big town, marshall town. Nothing here suggests cheating. Big actually tries to get the win. They both survive until the end of the game but the majority of the vote is on Midochin and everyone seemed to FoS him before. However,
based on the fact that BBB basically ignored Marshall on the last day without TRing him or interacting with him, could suggest role sharing.

Conclusion: BBB and Marshall are probably cheating with eachother. The games are sketchy at best. The first game suggests the sharing of information on roles as BBB never really attempted to play and seemed to be able to hammer mafia out of nowhere. The second game could suggest that they're role sharing as well considering the lack of interaction between BBB and Marshallrake.

FiveMinuteDays: (alt of the above)
https://epicmafia.com/game/4977501/review
FMD - Orc, BBB - blue
FMD orcs BBB n1. BP is hit d1. FMD seems trollish but hammers stalker d2. BBB foses hardeffingworker (blue) d2. N3 FMD orcs mainaccount2 and dies. D3 mainaccount2 (nilla) is lynched. Game over.


https://epicmafia.com/game/4977437
FMD - nilla, BBB - BP
N1 - FMD shoots BBB. D1 BBB doesn't out any reads. D2 BBB dies and FMD trolls all of D2. His partner is hammered at the end of the day. D3 FMD continues to troll. D4 FMD appears to try and gets hammered.

Conclusion: second game seems a little sketchy but other than that ????


cranl33t: (alt of the above)
https://epicmafia.com/game/4985848/review
cranl33t - hooker, BBB - Blue
sheriff (note: sherriff is JaguarKaran who's alts have played a bunch with BBB) shoots hooker d1, BBB votes roadman (cop) and foses mindful (nilla). blue is lynched d1. d2 bs dies, BBB pushes for mindful all day. jag pushes on lawyer all day, lawyer gets lynched. mindful gets lynched d3

Conclusion: unless JaguarKaran is involved it's unlikely they were cheating at this time
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

BigBadBoy: http://puu.sh/o8KOu/5c62ea6dac.png
Washroom: http://prntscr.com/ap3s00
100% WR for BigBadBoy

https://epicmafia.com/game/4977154/review

https://epicmafia.com/game/4977112/review

Conclusion: Neither of those games suggest any cheating from either party with eachother. There's no reason to investgate these two for cheating together.

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

BigBadBoy
LeftParenthesis (80% winrate) (5 ranked games together)

The only moderately suspicious game was the last game in this list (the SnL one). Left's levels of participation and effort seems to be independent of BigBadBoy's alignment flips. I don't think they're role-sharing or communicating game-related information outside of the game. And the single game on the bottom isn't really enough to justify a throwing in favor case.

https://epicmafia.com/game/4977112/review - Sheriff - Village win
Vegas claims as sheriff d1 and shoots jimmmaster. Even though LeftParenthesis accidentally inno’d his cop CC (Rydia) on day 2, vegas still wanted to lynch Rydia - presumably because Rydia cc’d late and it could have looked like an inno’d hooker taking advantage of the situation. BigBadBoy claims as sheriff and hammers the hooker (brunomars) on day 2 for “not doing anything”. Both cop claims guilty the lawyer on day 3. With the hooker out of the picture, LeftParenthesis got swiftly lynched, along with his partner the following day.

https://epicmafia.com/game/4977154/review - Sheriff - Village win
Empath (who is linked to a few banned users - mostly for inappropriate names) claims as sheriff on day 1. They considered shooting vegas on day 1 but decided to NL instead. Empath split the day 1 shot between jimmaster and pingpongdads. Pingpongdads gets shot as hooker (probably for claiming blue first). Empath hammers leftparenthesis as nilla afterwards. Day 3 becomes autowin - vegas gets lynched as lawyer. (Empath seems like a suspicious user).

https://epicmafia.com/game/4981527/review - VDLI - Mafia win
BigBadBoy was killed night 1. On day 1 LeftParenthesis shared who he would have stalked as mafia to participate in an on-going discussion. They made a light fos claim but didn’t pursue it. Left’s day 2 was filled with lines talking about meteor mechanics (about how mafia hitting bp brings meteor on town). If BigBadBoy were communicating with LeftParenthesis outside of the game, I believe LeftParenthesis would have been much stronger in their pushes or defences. Left’s day 3 had 1 or 2 comments questioning the actions of other players; they also requested a justification for the xamurai lynch (which led to the town loss) but didn’t bother to push on it.

https://epicmafia.com/game/4984171/review - Sheriff - Veg
LeftParenthesis spent most of the day pushing on Awnyy in a half-joking manner (stating that having pink text is 50% mafia). BigBadBoy spent day 1 complaining about the high number of PR softs (he was mafia himself). FaithH vegged and the game became unranked.

https://epicmafia.com/game/4987365/review - Sheriff - Town win
LeftParenthesis and FireDragonPrince CC each other as cop on day 2. FireDragonPrince claimed second with a copy/paste mimicking a santa’s report (which probably got him townread). BigBadBoy pushes for FireDragonPrince to get shot, arguing that it was unlikely for fire to report a guilty and claim second as mafia (since the intention behind random guiltying is hoping you’d guilty your cc before they claim). Michael shoots Left as cop relatively quickly. Fire gets lynched and BigBadBoy dies the next day.

https://epicmafia.com/game/4987453/review - SnL - Town win
Nobody23 dies night 1. Kylo creates a mason list the following day. During day 2, Bigbadboy seems to waver between wanting to lynch Sierra and LeftParenthesis (Left is hooker and Sierra is town). Left’s visible lack of effort this game could mean throwing in favor of BigBadBoy. BigBad did give a few signs that he did not know mafia like setting up a reaction test on Left and immediately advocating a Sierra lynch after. LeftParenthesis even advocated his own lynch at one point, saying “it’s for the best”. I don’t think Left has ever offered to get himself lynched. Left is lynched and his partner is automatically confirmed the next day for giving the wrong code.