This entire thread is a trainwreck of people posting irrelevant replays (versus a Cosmog and Mono Electric, seriously?), making irrelevant comparisons (like Refrigerate Explosion and Prankster Destiny Bond to Innards Out) and saying that things aren't broken because... Other things in the tier are more broken? Honestly, I'm so lost at this point that I don't understand what you all are saying.

Posting 35 replays (and Arceus knows how many there actually are, I'm not going through that many replays and counting each individual one) doesn't help the situation. Explain it to us. Don't show us a bunch of replays and say that "Innards Out works like this", take some time and explain it to us in a manner which contains valid evidence, comparisons and coherence. I can name a plethora of individuals who have stopped posting in and paying attention to this thread due to the gargantuan decline in quality posts.

My opinion on the stance is identical to @motherlove 's - The assumption that Innards Out only punishes offense isn't true at all.
[quote="motherlove, post: 7193939, member: 231750"]Another thing I'd like to point out regarding the idea that Tony is pointless against stall is that Tony has the potential to massively damage any team that relies on a regenVest user (which seems to be most teams nowadays).[/quote]
A lot of people seem to entertain the illusion that Innards Out is useless against stall and for those individuals, I highly advise you to read this segment. Seriously. It'll take 10 seconds of your time and you'll be left with a greater understanding of how stall is damaged.

Also, whittling down the HP with relatively low-powered attacks won't work either.

4 Atk Solgaleo U-turn vs. 252 HP / 0- Def Chansey: 380-448 (53.9 - 63.6%) -- guaranteed 2HKO

In this scenario, you pivot... and the Chansey Metal Bursts, dealing 570 HP of damage to anything on the lowest roll possible. Friendly reminder that a minimum roll that you Metal Burst off of KOs anything that isn't Chansey or ZygC (and Blissey and Guzzlord, I know I left them out but both have no relevance in BH whatsoever.)

This calc may seem meaningless, but I'll try to explain why I included it. In a scenario where you're facing an Innards Out Chansey, you simply can't whittle it down using attacks that don't KO because Chansey won't just sit there and take punishment. Innards Out Chansey carries Metal Burst to punish things that think they can get away with using weak attacks to whittle its health down. What doesn't it KO? Two relevant things in the tier. If you think that's balanced, then... I really don't know what to tell you.

Calc some more if you guys are curious about how much things other than RegenVest Solgaleo do, grab your spears and pitchforks because I included 4 Atk EVs, doesn't really matter to me. But for Arceus' sake, please start making sense. I'm not the only one who thinks that most people on this thread are speaking gibberish.