Rad_Edw

-> 1. I like the black neck silouette contrast with the background. Ducks are funny.
-> 2. Yep, seems black people makes better B&W photos. The left one reminds me of coffee advertisings with that big smile.

--first set-

-> 1. Interesting old man. It's hard to find punk grandpas, at least out of big cities.
-> 2. I like how shows both, the silouetes of the persons and the ducks. Maybe a bit too dark
3. Can't find anything interesting
4. Nice, but since I tend to dislike portraits, it's a no for me. Ask portraiters or however they are called.
5. Nice family photo, but that's it.
6. I only see a park, nothing more.
-> 7. I like that happy look they have.
8. Could be my house, nothing to see here.
9. I guess she and her friends will like the photo. Doesn't catch my interest.

--second set--
1. see 9. above.
2. Reminds me the "generic alone man seated at the lake looking at the infinity". Too much abused on photos/films that it's harder to make one that has something special.
3. I don't like the face of the mother.
4. Closing eyes? Either that or fully stonned, can't tell. Also dog looking away. Also, car distracting.
5. Not enough contrast. Rocks have the same tomes as ducks making it distracting. Took various views to find there is a pidgeon.
6. Nice photo for her mother I guess.
7.See 2.
8. Sorry, but can't find interesting. Also too much things. I dislike specially the sign.
9. See 6.