Not a member of Pastebin yet?
Sign Up,
it unlocks many cool features!
- This setup is mafsided through and through, you think you have mastered civilians, but you really aren't even close. From what I've gathered this setup is NOT suitable for competitive at all, the civilians do ruin it.
- In this setup, town is blessed with a gun shot, in addition to an ML. That is next to a mafia night kill, and the lynch after. The layering in this setup is maximum level. There's so many possible things to happen and they all WILL happen frequently. One can praise a setup for that, but getting a certain scenario is all down to luck. However, some of them are interesting, I definitely think the setup has succeeding elements, but is inherently broken.
- Let's see all the possible scenarios:
- Deputy outs, he shoots his gun, the odds are: 1/4 to hit mafia. But, he has the same chance of killing mafia as to kill civilian or villager, so the shot is pretty fatal and it pretty much decides the following parts. What happens if he shoots a civilian? Bad things...
- Soluciones advices the other civilian to claim when their fellow has been shot. I disagree with this on all levels. Never out the death of you if it's not necessary. If we play by his books, then it's already game over if you lynch bodyguard. Ask for claims before lynching you say? That doesn't make a single difference. Even if you don't lynch a bodyguard, but STILL not lynch a mafia, you AUTOMATICALLY lose. Mafia kills bodyguard if they know him, even if they don't, they have a goddamn good shot anyway. Based on the lynch, if it was a villager, then there are 5 unclears left, 3 considered towns and 2 mafias. The villager, the bodyguard, the turncoat, and the two mafmen. It is 1/3 chance to kill any of the 3 unclear roles and 2 of the kills are great situations for mafia. If they kill the bodyguard, game over. There are 2 mafia left and only 1 lynch, mafia has to kill once more to win. GG.
- If they kill the turncoat, he flips to traitor. You'll know when they hit turncoat because there'll be no deaths. Now there are 7 people, 3 mafias(1 traitor), and 4 towns, LYLO. All they have to do, is make the traitor CC bodyguard. Lynch wrong? GG. Lynch right? Night kill bodyguard and on the next day, it's the same thing: 2 mafias alive, bodyguard dead, one civilian alive. GG.
- If they kill the villager itself, well, besides being unlucky they don't have much work to do in this scenario. It is MYLO, after all. So a mislynch means death. One mafia CC's turncoat, the other CC's bodyguard, a mislynch and you're gone.
- In the first place, you can even try to hit civilian. After all, the chances are 50-50 whether you're gonna die or bodyguard dies. And if he dies, GG.
- Now you see, civilian claiming is wrong on all levels and should never be done. But what if, people actually do good for themselves, and not claim civilian if their fellow civilian dies? Guess what, it doesn't get much better...
- So, you are in D1 and as deputy you are about to lynch someone, ask for their claim, they are initially mafia, but what in the world could they claim to save themselves?! Oh right, the civilian. Just claim civilian and save yourself, make the real one out and it'll be a similar scenario with all its woes for town to deal with. If you wanna go ham, how about claiming bodyguard? Bodyguard is important after all. This guarantees a dead bodyguard anyway, and keeps the civilian shut for the rest of the game. The optimal way is to make it if actress is about to get lynched, they'd be the one to claim civilian, but if it's the disguiser - or as I like to call them in this setup, the nilla - that's about to get lynched, they claim bodyguard instead. Very good options for the mafia here, and not a single one to satisfy deputy. If he lynches civilian it's already game over, so he has to change his lynch.
- Moving on, what if deputy doesn't lynch a mafia, civilian, or bodyguard? What if he lynches turncoat? Hmm. Well, turncoat here is a town after all. Why'd he ruin it for his side by claiming a PR, he probably should avoid doing that. So, as a town he'd not claim civilian or bodyguard, because let's think about it. If he does claim bodyguard and gets him lynched, mafia can just kill civilian, all is not good because turncoat is still turncoat and turncoat is a town role. Right, he'd just claim turncoat then. Oh wait, that'll get him lynched. Since it's better for town without turncoat who sometimes in some cases sides with mafia giving town no hope, it's better off killing him. All in all, a smart turncoat would just give in his reads and allow himself to be lynched, wishing the best for his deputy and rest of the town.
- Now mafia has nothing to joint with! They don't really need to. They're not entitled to carry turncoat. A kill with a role report is enough to keep them well and healthy. In day 2, one will CC bodyguard and the other will CC villager, well, that if they didn't ALREADY kill bodyguard in the night which gives them AUTO WIN GG TOWN, GG.
- But, what if our deputy doesn't lynch the mafia, civilian, bodyguard, or turncoat? What if he lynches a villager? Then... That just happens, no reason to stop here. A kill and a role report for the year! What happens now is interesting... Based on the kill - again, if they kill bodyguard it's auto frickin' win - mafia will claim the roles they find ideal. Let's have a look at the roles alive that are unclear and not mafia: Bodyguard, turncoat, villager. 2 are in-check. So there'll be no roleswap playing here, it's all in-check for mafia. Best situation is to kill bodyguard of course, but they can also have the luxury of killing turncoat. So he'll just flip traitor, now he doesn't need to do anything. He can out himself it he wants to, as traitor, he'll never get lynched because it's MYLO and deputy needs to lynch a hardcore mafia. Now mafia should try something special and optimal, CC traitor:
- Make disguiser or actress CC the traitor, whoever really wants to just will, and the other CC bodyguard. Now why'd they ever do that? Since deputy will probably be scared of lynching in bodyguards, he can resort to lynching in other roles, to troll him, make the traitor and a mafia claim traitor right in front of him. He has to lynch in them, if he lynches the real traitor he loses because it's MYLO. The best part is the traitor can force the deputy to lynch him by acting scummier on purpose, ah that'd be fun. So this is a cheering part of the setup, you can just do that and be effective as ever.
- That was something different, unfortunately Soluciones didn't bother to look more in-depth. This is me complaining about people who don't know their own setups well enough. This one is definitely one cared for in detail by Soluciones when he made it, but he didn't look at the scenarios, and what should be done. Doing that makes you not only a better player but also prevents unnecessary losses because of following your obviously not so good strategies that you made without knowing your setup well enough. People are misguiding other players this way. You need to be sure on everything and do final touch ups. GG.
- A good chunk of text for only one scenario and that is shooting civilian with deputy gun D1. This is nice layering and I definitely think it's nice to have setups of this kind that can change by what you kill and lynch, adds some variety. Makes the game not a straight line to walk on.
- Time to find out what happens if you shoot bodyguard! Not a nice ride ahead of you. You shot bodyguard, congratulations. Oh did I mention about asking for claims before the shot? Oh man, you're not gonna finish a game of this in 20 minutes. So you decide who you lynch. Luckily, this time there are 2 civilians alive. But people's claims will never change. A mafia would still claim civilian straight away. Maybe even more chaos would occur because it's 3 CC's instead of 2. Now you don't wanna lynch in the civilians, you really don't. So lynch outside and hope for the best, whether civilians are outed or not, mafia has a good chance to kill one of them. If civilians outed then you need to do some heavy lifting to keep your team in the game, God what a horrible setup to run on.
- However, if your lucky ass lynched villager instead, in the night mafia are left with 1 villager, 2 civilians, and 1 turncoat. Oh, also a kill and a role report. 50% chance to kill a civilian and if they do, it's goddamn GG. If they don't, killing turncoat makes up for it as he's going to be the freeloader again and claim traitor and gets one mafia to CC and make the CC's in civilians a 1/3 chance to get it right. Killing a villager causes a huge heart attack for mafia as they -- No wait it's the same thing just do the above.
- Two scenarios above are total poop, but there are some good ones down here. What if you kill the turncoat? Hurray? Nay Nay. So once you shoot turncoat, you have 7 people to hammer out of, deputy. 2 villagers, 1 bodyguard, 2 mafias, 2 civilians, so it's 1/3.5 odds for all of civilians, mafias, and villagers. You can literally expect anyone to flip anything at this point! And because of my rule not to out anything, you don't! Don't out anything. Asking for claims would result in the same tragic scenario of last time, and it'll only get more intense from here.
- If you hammer a civilian, the bodyguard shouldn't be on you, but then again, civilians didn't out how could he know which one to protect? He actually has a better chance protecting mafia than civilian, so... From another perspective, mafia have 50% chance to kill a villager, 25% to both bodyguard and civilian. A kill, and a role report. They have to know civilian at this point. If they killed a villager, one mafia CC bodyguard and the other CC the civilian. One mislynch is fatal, however this IS technically a 50-50 situation so, I'm not going to complain.
- If they kill bodyguard, and since they do have a role report, they might know civilian or it's down to 2 people to be civilian. You probably don't wanna claim anything at this point. The deputy has to lynch out of 4 people, but 2 are mafia, so that IS 50-50 as well.. Except, the part where mafia can automatically win if they have actressed civilian or the fact they also have a 50-50 shot to finish the game if it's not finished already.
- If they have killed a civilian, then............................................. GG.
- If you get a chance to hammer mafia, then they'd claim civilian and it's a battle once again. You should NOT and I repeat NOT lynch in civilians ever. If you lynch one wrong in the 3 CC's you're still not safe, bodyguard doesn't know who the real one is and if mafia is doing better than the actual civilians you're in trouble. Just hammer outside.
- If you succeed in hammering villager like a true champ would, you still have a rough road ahead of you, chances are, mafia WILL hit the civilians. How about that... And if they do you don't lose automatically which is a good thing unlike the other scenario. Once they do that, one mafia will claim civilian and the other will claim bodyguard and the game proceeds the same.
- If they kill bodyguard instead, hell they probably know the civilians by now, letting 1 mafia CC both civilians is always best, but if you want to, going 50-50 in CC's is never the wrong answer because, if deputy gets it wrong, he loses anyways.
- Remember, this is where you shot a turncoat, that is like, a supposedly very good situation, compared to the others.
- Now what happens if deputy shoots a villager? Basically same with the turncoat scenario only worse. Deputy has to hammer again, nobody claims again, and mafia proceeds to kill and get a role report, again. Hammering bodyguard is always fatal and will cause you to eventually lose the game, because mafia have only 1 villager alive but 2 civilians and the turncoat. If they hit turncoat, it's GG. If they hit civilan and actress someone that is not the turncoat, GG. If they do a backflip, GG.
- Now don't hammer bodyguard, silly deputy. Hammer the other villager, like the hero you are. Which causes you to have odds that are extremely bad for you like: 2 civilians, 1 bodyguard, 1 turncoat. Basically the death bed. Hammering turncoat is a little bit better because it doesn't give mafia auto win, but you're still in a shit pit. GG.
- So... Is that it? Am I finally done complaining about this setup? Look, people. This is definitely not suitable for competitive, or you know what, let's have it in competitive. I wanna see the userbase of epicmafia suffer from having to deal with all the bullshit overpowered mafia just to get a shot at a 80town-40mafia points score payout.
- Trust me, you are far from mastering civilians. But that's alright, because I never thought you could. They are very bullshit roles anyhow that don't add a concept of fun to the game. And, I don't think you're using turncoat to its fullest right here. Like, yes, it's jointing, but, it's doing nothing at all, nothing more than sitting there and knowing nothing the whole time. If he doesn't get converted by D2, it's over for him, back to the town side again. And him CC'ing the special roles or not doesn't make a difference, he's better off staying blue or just out'ing himself. He's not the traitor in lolnoobtraitormafialose.
- Overall, the setup has up points that are summed in the versatility of the scenarios based on your kill. But they are overshadowed by how bad those damn options are for town. The town has to try being epic to win here, absolutely destroying everything and finding mafia on D1. Yet, all mafia has to do is follow a script that guarantees them the win completely.
- I didn't think this at first, but, I think it's near the point of unplayable. And also, the way you explained your setup in the strategies, shows you didn't really intend this to be so layered, did you? I don't think you made the concept of turncoat helping mafia by claiming traitor or the inability for town to lynch in bodyguard because of civilian on purpose, maybe it just turned out like that.
- Tip for the future, being unique is awesome, but that has to have a purpose, a bigger purpose. Think about how enjoyable this'd be to play, if only, I didn't have to shed a tear when bodyguard dies.
- I think you should read this and get better.
Advertisement
Add Comment
Please, Sign In to add comment