Explanation trial

[00:12:50] Dream Traveler: ...Blad
[00:12:52] Dream Traveler: e*
[00:12:59] Dream Traveler: ...if Robin made it into a sword.
[00:13:07] Dream Traveler: Could she give it to Klonoa?
[00:13:18] Mercenary Roy: Well....
[00:13:23] Mercenary Roy: I didn't say once the form changed
[00:13:29] Mercenary Roy: It would stay like that forever
[00:13:42] Mercenary Roy: Say she uses it, then gives it to Morgan.
[00:13:46] Dream Traveler: Okay,
[00:13:48] Dream Traveler: I get it.
[00:13:50] Mercenary Roy: It would change into a powerful tome.
[00:13:51] Mercenary Roy: But
[00:14:04] Mercenary Roy: If she were to give it in sword forme to Klonoa
[00:14:17] Mercenary Roy: The power of it would vanish entirely
[00:14:28] Mercenary Roy: Just making it a plain old sword for attacking
[00:15:23] Mercenary Roy: Think of it like this:
[00:15:32] Dream Traveler: Yes, he could wield it.
[00:15:35] Mercenary Roy: Malumbra feeds off the dragon's blood for its power
[00:15:39] Dream Traveler: But
[00:15:44] Dream Traveler: It wouldn't be anything special
[00:15:49] Mercenary Roy: Exactly
[00:15:51] Dream Traveler: And his Killing Edge would be better than that shit
[00:16:13] Mercenary Roy: Yup
[00:16:17] Dream Traveler: You don't have to explain it in too much detail, I don't know Fire Emblem for crap but I can comprehend a thing or two.
[00:16:23] Mercenary Roy: XD
[00:16:23] Dream Traveler: Here's the question
[00:16:31] Dream Traveler: Is there a sword
[00:16:35] Dream Traveler: Only the fellblood can use?
[00:16:39] Dream Traveler: NO
[00:16:43] Dream Traveler: NOT A BOOK SWORD THING
[00:16:46] Dream Traveler: A plain old
[00:16:49] Dream Traveler: regular
[00:16:56] Mercenary Roy: ....No.
[00:17:02] Dream Traveler: Okay.
[00:18:18] Dream Traveler: One sec, let me ask something.
[00:18:29] Mercenary Roy: Hm?
[00:18:34] Dream Traveler: =_=
[00:18:44] Dream Traveler: I'm asking someone else something, sorry.
[00:18:49] Mercenary Roy: Oh okay
[00:29:45] Dream Traveler: Blade
[00:29:55] Mercenary Roy: ?
[00:30:27] Dream Traveler: ...for Klonoa to wield the Falchion and have the skill level of Lucina and Chrom...would Klonoa need the ability to wield every sword
[00:30:36] Dream Traveler: Or wield every sword to it's full potential?
[00:30:38] Dream Traveler: :|
[00:30:54] Dream Traveler: This will be the key to seeing if he is able to use the Mu...gah
[00:30:57] Dream Traveler: Fellblood Book Sword
[00:31:18] Mercenary Roy: Hmm
[00:31:21] Mercenary Roy: I think former
[00:31:31] Dream Traveler: Monado?
[00:32:05] Mercenary Roy: He can use the Monado to some extent. It takes training to unlock all the symbols
[00:32:11] Mercenary Roy: And use it to the point Shulk has.
[00:32:57] Dream Traveler: Blade, don't fucking set in stone something that none of us remember. I'm trying to figure out the rules Klonoa abides to because none of us remember what I fucking said X<
[00:33:26] Dream Traveler: Not even me. I'm not wanting to be greedy. I'm trying to remember something so I don't cause some sort of problem in the future.
[00:33:27] Mercenary Roy: @~@ true
[00:33:54] Dream Traveler: There's a difference between wielding
[00:33:58] Dream Traveler: and wielding to full potential
[00:34:09] Dream Traveler: Klonoa does have to learn, but he has the ability to
[00:34:22] Dream Traveler: He isn't locked into just being able to pick up the sword.
[00:34:33] Dream Traveler: He has the ability to master it, not just be able to hold it.
[00:35:23] Dream Traveler: That's how I see the difference between being able to wield and being able to wield to max potential.
[00:36:11] Dream Traveler: Does that make sense?
[00:36:15] Mercenary Roy: Yeag
[00:36:20] Mercenary Roy: *Yea
[00:36:42] Dream Traveler: The thing I need to figure out is...does the Book Sword count as a sword?
[00:37:04] Dream Traveler: Or does it count as a book?
[00:37:28] Mercenary Roy: It is by default just a regular spellbook.
[00:37:45] Dream Traveler: Is it considered a sword when it becomes a sword?
[00:37:55] Dream Traveler: Or is it still considered the book?
[00:38:13] Mercenary Roy: ...It's just considered Malumbra.
[00:38:19] Mercenary Roy: The shape it takes
[00:38:22] Mercenary Roy: Is what it is
[00:38:27] Mercenary Roy: But the real Malumbra
[00:38:33] Dream Traveler: Blade, this isn't helping.
[00:38:33] Mercenary Roy: is a swirl of dark energy
[00:39:32] Dream Traveler: Blade.
[00:40:11] Dream Traveler: I realize you don't want me to have the ability to use it. Hell, I don't either.
[00:40:15] Mercenary Roy: I don't exactly know how to explain it... but the shape it's in isn't defined by it's physical appearance.
[00:40:17] Dream Traveler: I'm just wanting to work out a loop hole.
[00:40:34] Dream Traveler: As in make sure this underlying rule
[00:40:37] Dream Traveler: is defined.
[00:40:44] Dream Traveler: And doesn't bite me in the ass later.
[00:41:39] Dream Traveler: I'm sorry
[00:41:40] Dream Traveler: :|
[00:41:45] Dream Traveler: I should have written it down
[00:41:57] Mercenary Roy: It's okay, sorry for not being so clear.
[00:42:40] Dream Traveler: You can just say "I don't want Klonoa to be able to use this." if that's what you want to say. I realize this, I don't want to either, I just don't want Klonoa to be like
[00:42:54] Dream Traveler: "Fear my blade." *tries to attack but it does nothing*
[00:42:55] Dream Traveler: :|
[00:43:32] Mercenary Roy: I dunno, if he wanted to practice with it, under the assumption he could use it,
[00:43:40] Mercenary Roy: Then question why it won't respond
[00:45:00] Dream Traveler: Klonoa can wield any sword, that's for certain, but I don't know if it's possible to wield a sword and not be able to use it to its fullest.
[00:45:09] Dream Traveler: And that goes for every sword.
[00:45:16] Dream Traveler: Not just this stupid thing.
[00:46:00] Dream Traveler: And then you got to explain if...say, in game, does it become a sword and get considered a sword by the game itself?
[00:46:26] Mercenary Roy: Malumbra is not an in game item.
[00:48:31] Dream Traveler: -m-;
[00:48:33] Dream Traveler: Ugh...
[00:48:43] Dream Traveler: Okay, answer this
[00:48:54] Dream Traveler: Can I pick up the Monado but not use it (period)
[00:49:06] Dream Traveler: Can I pick up the Falchion but not use it (period)
[00:49:09] Dream Traveler: =_=
[00:49:18] Mercenary Roy: You can use both o-o;
[00:49:56] Dream Traveler: I'm asking not me in specific
[00:49:58] Dream Traveler: ANYONE
[00:50:22] Dream Traveler: Can a person pick up either sword and not be able to use any of its abilities?
[00:51:37] Dream Traveler: Look, if I say Klonoa won't use the book no matter what you say, will that make you actually give a straight answer?
[00:51:38] Dream Traveler: :|
[00:51:45] Dream Traveler: =m=
[00:51:46] Mercenary Roy: No, the Monado is solely meant for those who can have the capability
[00:51:59] Mercenary Roy: While Falchion is tied only to the exalted bloodline
[00:52:11] Mercenary Roy: Anyone can swing Falchion around, and cut apples with it
[00:52:21] Mercenary Roy: It would just act like an overgrown knife
[00:52:28] Dream Traveler: THEN Klonoa can use every sword and use it to it's full potential.
[00:52:38] Mercenary Roy: Yes.
[00:53:22] Dream Traveler: Now. ...if Robin gives Klonoa the sword, or Robin falls in battle, would Klonoa be able to wield that sword to its full potential? Or would it not be considered a sword by the underlying rule Ricken made?
[00:54:28] Mercenary Roy: Malumbra will have to taste for the blood of the dragon. If it doesn't receive that taste, its power will go away.
[00:54:58] Dream Traveler: Are you giving straight answers or just avoiding so Robin has something special to her?
[00:55:14] Mercenary Roy: In a sense, the blessing doesn't come FROM the weapon, it's just used to channel and amplifies it's power.
[00:55:39] Mercenary Roy: By itself, it's useless to anyone but Robin, Morgan, Grima, Marc, and Megan is unknown.
[00:55:50] Mercenary Roy: Even Klonoa.
[00:55:58] Dream Traveler: I realize that.
[00:56:03] Dream Traveler: As everything but a sword, Klonoa can't use it.
[00:56:13] Mercenary Roy: Exactly.
[00:56:14] Dream Traveler: As a sword, maybe. Again, his DNA is irregular.
[00:56:27] Dream Traveler: So perhaps
[00:56:29] Dream Traveler: And this
[00:56:40] Dream Traveler: is a really really big stretch, and I don't even know how the fuck it would work
[00:57:04] Dream Traveler: And before you try to dodge the bullet, Klonoa wouldn't ask to use Robin's book as a sword, he'd only do it if he had to.
[00:57:44] Mercenary Roy: Right
[00:57:48] Dream Traveler: SO NO KLONOA WOULD NOT ABUSE IT
[00:58:06] Dream Traveler: But here's my idea.
[00:58:12] Dream Traveler: ---
[00:58:38] Dream Traveler: Klonoa's body adjusts itself to be able to use every sword, and reverts when he is done.
[00:58:52] Dream Traveler: use every sword to its full potential.
[00:59:06] Dream Traveler: So, and only as a sword, he wouldn't be able to use the book.
[00:59:08] Dream Traveler: Or the tome
[00:59:14] Dream Traveler: Or the scythe.
[00:59:42] Dream Traveler: But if it's a sword, and Robin gives him said sword, his body would adjust itself to be able to use the sword to its full potential
[00:59:46] Dream Traveler: And revert back to normal
[00:59:51] Dream Traveler: Once the sword is taken away from him.
[01:00:14] Dream Traveler: @m@ His DNA is irregular, so I guess that is why?
[01:00:25] Dream Traveler: ... did that make any sense. No Klonoa won't abuse it
[01:00:35] Dream Traveler: No I don't want to use the sword.
[01:00:40] Mercenary Roy: If his DNA contained any sense of dragon in it, then it would react.
[01:00:44] Dream Traveler: No Klonoa isn't greedy.
[01:00:48] Dream Traveler: Neither am I.
[01:01:08] Dream Traveler: In case you don't realize that. I do like giving Robin things only she could use.
[01:01:19] Dream Traveler: But I don't like plotholes.
[01:01:26] Dream Traveler: =_=