Not a member of Pastebin yet?
Sign Up,
it unlocks many cool features!
- Labels not required to reveal all
- The Kansas City Star - Monday, March 7, 1994
- Readability: 11-12 grade level (Lexile: 1220L)
- Author: MIKE HENDRICKS, Agriculture Writer
- ROCKVILLE, Md. - Cheerios are not only chock full of whole oat goodness, but trisodium phosphate.
- Black olives swim in ferrous gluconate, and dyes imbue fruit cocktail with artificial color.
- We know this because the U.S. Food and Drug Administration requires that food processors list their ingredients on the label.
- Yet Americans may not have a clue when genetic material from bacteria or insects are mixed into their fruits, vegetables and packaged dinners.
- The FDA says no scientific reason exists to test or require special labeling for most of the biotech foods under development.
- Few government policies have provoked as much outrage.
- "Are you completely out of your mind? " one Californian asked FDA chief David Kessler in one of the nearly 5,000 public comments that fill more than 60 volumes at FDA headquarters in Rockville.
- Now as the first gene-altered food nears the supermarket this year, the FDA is beginning to rethink that policy. The outcome could determine if these new foods find a place on America's dinner tables or are abandoned by the agribusiness companies developing them.
- "Labeling is the key issue," said Norman Braksick , president of the Asgrow Seed Co. "If you put a label on a genetically engineered food you might as well put a skull and crossbones on it. " It would be a tragedy to drive people away from designer foods that might actually be cheaper or healthier than normal food, contends the biotech industry, which has sunk billions into research.
- But many Americans, not satisfied with FDA's assurances that biotech foods are safe, want to make their own choices on what to eat. And they want labels.
- Safety isn't the only issue.
- Jews worry that they won't be able to keep kosher if scientists mix and match genes without telling them.
- Animal rights activists and vegetarians are concerned that animal genes will wind up in their fruits and vegetables.
- Others simply object to the entire notion of scientists tinkering with nature at the molecular level. Their philosophical arguments can be complex.
- Duane A. Peterson of Kodiak, Alaska, however, summed it up simply in a comment to the FDA: "The apples and bananas God creates are perfectly fine for me. " The need for labels The FDA relied on science to set its no-labeling policy in 1992.
- Genes are simply bits of a chemical molecule called DNA. One organism's DNA is pretty much like another's. What distinguishes a frog from a lima bean is how the genes are arranged.
- The agency concluded that mixing and matching these DNA bits posed no special food safety threat. And just as no FDA review is conducted for every new crop produced through traditional breeding methods, no need existed to review each and every biotech food.
- The FDA said some kinds of biotech foods, however, did warrant special review and labeling.
- Genes from known allergens need to be listed on food labels, according to the FDA. Some people, for instance, are allergic to peanuts. If a peanut gene was inserted into another food, FDA would review that closely and likely require a special notation on the label.
- The FDA said it also would require a label notice for foods that were modified so they contained substances not normally found in food or were altered so much that the very nature of the food was in question.
- "In other words, if you change a tomato so that it really can't be called a tomato anymore, that it now has a major new sweetener in it, for example, and it's much different from what consumers perceive a tomato to be," explained James Maryanski, the FDA's lead strategist on biotech issues.
- Most of the genetic modifications under study don't fit either category and involve only minute bits of DNA.
- "In many of these cases," Maryanski said, "there are very trivial levels of these substances; as long as they don't pose allergenic problems they really aren't going to affect the taste and flavor of the food. " Likewise, the FDA argues, the addition of a single pig gene into a carrot does not make the carrot some weird animal-plant crossbreed that should offend vegetarians.
- Why? Strictly speaking gene splicers don't transfer one organism's DNA into another. What microbiologists do is clone a gene and then transfer the copies.
- Unknown toxins Margaret Mellon isn't satisfied with FDA assurances and explanations.
- The agency is too blase about the hazards and concerns, given the unknowns about genetically engineered food, says the longtime biotech critic, now with the Union of Concerned Scientists.
- "Consumers need to be able to vote with their forks," Mellon said.
- She and other critics worry that biotech food could increase levels of naturally occurring toxins and allergens, or result in some unforeseen change in a food's makeup that might prove harmful.
- "Much of the concern over food safety risks," the General Accounting Office concluded last year, "centers on science's current inability to predict unexpected effects that may occur from manipulating genes. " The unknowns are called pleiotropic effects - the notion that a single gene can sometimes control more than one trait.
- Scientists could, for example, set out to produce juicier fruit by altering a single gene, but cause the release of some naturally occurring toxin without knowing it.
- "Plants are known to contain hundreds of toxic compounds, and it is likely that they contain many more that have not been identified," according to the congressional Office of Technology Assessment. "At least 148 naturally occurring food compounds have been demonstrated to have acutely toxic effects in experimental animals, livestock or humans when consumed. " Complicating matters is the fact that genetic engineering is far from precise. Even when they use tiny needles to micro-inject genes into cells, microbiologists still cannot pinpoint where a new gene will land on the DNA of the plant or animal cell that's being genetically engineered.
- Depending on where that new gene falls in plant cells, the result could be decreased levels of nutrients or an increase in naturally occurring toxins.
- Critics also worry that biotech foods could ruin the antibiotics we use to treat infections. That's because some genetic modifications introduce antibiotic-resistant genes into food.
- The Food and Drug Administration doesn't think that will pose a problem, but critics say one bad biotech food out of 100 is too many.
- "I've always said these are low probability, high-risk introductions," said biotech critic Jeremy Rifkin. "I think a lot of them will be safe. Some of them are not going to be. " No need to know The Purdue University auditorium, filled with biotechnology experts, went dark as Thomas Hoban switched on the overhead projector.
- The co-author of the most thorough survey of consumer attitudes toward biotechnology presented mostly favorable news to the crowd of industry and university officials, most of whom play some role in developing genetically engineered crops.
- Americans support biotechnology, the North Carolina State University professor said. One chart showed that 70 percent of consumers think biotech foods will be good for them. Men were more supportive than women. Persons with college educations were more optimistic than high school graduates.
- It was all very upbeat for the industry, until this finding appeared on the screen: More than 85 percent of those questioned want information about genetic engineering listed on food labels.
- "People want an involvement in things that affect their lives," Hoban said.
- But the food industry doesn't want to label biotech foods because of public relations concerns.
- Labels noting health warnings are one thing, but simply declaring that a crop has been altered to produce its own toxin or resist viruses would serve no purpose, other than to scare people away, according to the biotech industry and its supporters.
- "Labeling ought to be based on science," said Rep. Calvin Dooley of California, co-chairman of the Congressional Biotechnology Caucus. "The challenge is how do we educate people that there is really no danger. " While critics argue that education should start on the label, Dooley and others say explaining the benefits of an added gene would be difficult, if not impossible, to explain on most packages.
- Sugarcoating it with positive advertising would be a stretch for many biotech foods. Imagine a food processor boasting that his canned corn is "new and improved with soil bacteria genes. " Food makers also say labeling would be a logistical nightmare.
- How does a maker of tomato sauce keep the biotech tomatoes separate from the non-engineered tomatoes during a manufacturing process that never stops?
- It either sets up separate manufacturing lines at a considerable cost that would be passed on in the form of higher prices. Or it labels the entire batch as possibly containing tomatoes that were genetically engineered.
- Enforcement would be difficult as well. New genes can't be detected in food, unless you already know what to look for.
- "The fact is there is no law that says the consumer has a right to know about his food," said Edward L. Korweck, a Washington, D.C., attorney and expert on food labeling.
- Negative labeling The industry arguments may play well at the FDA, but across the country there's a growing call for some form of inspection and labeling of biotech foods.
- Missouri, Wisconsin and other states are considering their own labeling laws. Chicago actually passed one last year but withdrew it in January after grocers complained.
- Congress also is taking up the matter. Sen. Russ Feingold of Wisconsin wants labels on milk from cows treated with genetically engineered growth hormone BST. The FDA already has declared that this milk is safe and identical to milk from cows that don't receive BST hormone.
- Feingold said labels allow consumers to decide for themselves.
- "If someone prefers chocolate over vanilla ice cream, does that have to have a scientific basis to it? It's a preference," he said.
- "For many people, that's exactly what this is all about. They want to know what they're eating, and in some cases they might want to know how it's produced. And I think that's their right. " The FDA plans to hold hearings on the issue this year.
- Don't expect the agency to completely reverse its position and require a full, pre-market review of each new biotech food, top FDA officials say.
- But they probably will set up a system in which the agency is notified before new biotech products come to market, says Jerold R. Mande, FDA's acting associate commissioner for legislative affairs.
- "We're looking at something that's less formal than a pre-market review," he said.
- The agency also might give some on the labeling issue. It probably won't switch position and require broad labeling, but it is open to an alternative called negative labeling.
- That means food companies could proclaim that they used no genetically engineered ingredients - as long as they could prove it.
- "You're free to make statements like that as long as they're truthful and not misleading," said Mike Taylor, the agency's deputy commissioner for policy.
- The biotech industry isn't thrilled with the notion. In fact, Monsanto Co. has already sued dairies that say their milk is from cows that haven't been injected with genetically engineered BST.
- But the FDA, not the courts, will probably be the authority that clarifies what type of negative labeling will be allowed.
- For biotech critics, it seems silly that the burden of proof would be on them rather than on the biotech companies. Still, it's probably the best compromise they can get.
- Caption: graphic photos (color) photo (color)
- CAPTION: To label or not to label
- Memo: Second of two parts
- Edition: METROPOLITAN
- Section: NATIONAL/WORLD
- Page: A1
- Index Terms: Farming the Genetic Frontier; Farm ; series ; agriculture
- Record Number: 218725
- Copyright 1994, 1996 The Kansas City Star Co.
Advertisement
Add Comment
Please, Sign In to add comment