Round 381: Body is currently 1st place in the round at the time of this pastebin. There had been some speculation that Body and Wine were the same person. After a check, it was detetermined their accounts were IP linked, and they have plated 7 games together this round. But, that's not all, there's more. At this point in the round, Body has played 31 total games. (19 wins, 6 loses, 6 incomplete) She has played 24 games out of these with atleast one of Wine/Sign/Bromance/Signature.(17 wins, 3 losses, 4 incomplete) She has played 7 games without either of them at the table. (2 wins, 3 losses, 2 incomplete)

89% of her wins this round so far come with one of Wine/Sign/Bromance/Signature at the table. It's key to note that it's never more than one of them at a table with her at the same time. It's only ever Body/Wine, Body/Sign/, Body/Bromance, Body/Signature. Through this bin, you will see that we believe Body is multiaccounting/rolesharing/cheating/threw with the accounts listed. It is also heavily believed after looking through the games that Signature/Bromance may have also multiaccounted/roleshared/threw/cheated in Round 373 when Body won her silver trophy. For now, we will only focus on this round.


Body: http://puu.sh/mlesr/de274155b2.png
Wine: http://puu.sh/mlkSe/8551c9edcf.png
http://puu.sh/mlkWt/e67c93b28c.png

At the time of this pastebin, Body/Wine have a total of 7 games together. They are also confirmed linked by IP address. Despite this they claim they do not know each other. (https://epicmafia.com/game/4735065/review) This game happened Janurary 5th. http://puu.sh/mleYZ/7c5fb07b66.png. When harodihg seems confused by the exchange he tries to get Wine to clarify. http://puu.sh/mlf6s/549e52e9bb.png. Here she denies knowing who Only is. Despite the two of them being linked. It's key to note that in the first game linked below (https://epicmafia.com/game/4728739/review) Happened Janurary 2nd. Body clearly says her main is Only in the game with Wine. http://puu.sh/mlfm3/d99d1e57a9.png http://puu.sh/mlfoz/65b119c29f.png. They clearly acknowledge each others, as they know who each other are. Wine is hesitant to say her main when asked by everyoneisalie

https://epicmafia.com/game/4728739/review - Body: Blue. Wine: Blue. (town/Both win)

Body and Wine never FOS each other this game. They also never talk at the same time. Body talks the most day one, as Wine doesn't talk much at all. In a 3 way with Impoetic, they never FOS each other, and wait for Impoetic to cross one of either Body or Wine. Crossing Wine. Body hammers quickly after. Body and town wins!

https://epicmafia.com/game/4730060 Body: Sleepwalker. Wine: Stalker (Town/Body wins)

Sweet Dreams. There is a loudmouth among the blues, no one knows who. It's a luck based setup. Body sees herself as Blue. She can be blue, sleepwalker, loudmouth. If stalker stalks loudmouth, they are confirmed mafia. Guess what? Wine is Stalker. She takes the risk of stalking to stalk her friend Body. Luckily (or unluckily) for them, Body is sleepwalker and not loudmouth. 2 minutes into the game, Body immediately foses Abhilaash, who is Wine's mafia partner. Again, the two of them do not talk at the same time. One is active when the other isn't. Reluctantly, Body is forced to switch to CogEme who is town the point where she says "This isn't mafia, I want to flip." The next day Body foses Abhilaash the whole time, until kicks. Since the cross is in Wine/Matthew she is forced to vote Wine, the stalker. Abhilaash kills Body at night. Next day, both town quickly vote the scummy Abhilaash. Town wins! Body wins!

https://epicmafia.com/game/4730161 Body: Nilla. Wine: Blue. (Game vegged. Incomplete)

Nothing too interesting happens this game. Blue is lynched day one and Body's mafia partner sadly vegs. Incomplete game.

https://epicmafia.com/game/4730292 Body: Sheriff. Wine: Blue (Game vegged. Incomplete)

Nothing interesting happens here. N1 journ vegs. Luckily, as Body was being n1'd as sheriff. Incomplete game.

https://epicmafia.com/game/4730309 Body: Blue. Wine: Sheriff (Town/Both win)

Wine immediately does a reactionary "Body inno" (Possibly as a reason to townread her.) Wine shoots janitor and lynches Blue. It's important to note again, Wine/Body never talk at the same time. Knowing that Cops were cc'd meaning blue was likely janned, and blue is lynched. Body is confirmed last Blue to him. Day 2 he quickly hammers one of Body's cc, since Body is the inno report. Day 3, Wine doesn't talk much. Just talks when Body is done going back and forth with Lincoln2. Wine points out that Body was scummy day 1, but never thought about lynching her. He said his mafia read was DrDiabetes day one and he hammered LaserVP. He could be saying this Day 3 to make it less obvious. After crossing, Wine correctly hammers Lincoln2. Town wins! Body wins!

https://epicmafia.com/game/4730378 Body: Lawyer. Wine: Journalist (Maf/Body win)

Wine gets n1'd as Journalist when Body is mafia. When Trump says "Wine?" Body quickly agrees she should be N1'd. Body is guiltied by cop and she immediately claims Journalist, knowing that journ is dead. She gets cop shot because of it, and after she is confirmed mafia she keeps saying "Who is real journ? I don't have a journ cc" to act like she doesn't know. A normal mafia would automatically assume Journ was janned at that point since she was uncc'd, but the fact that she had to keep saying it, looked as though she was trying to convince she didn't know journ was janned. Fake cop is lynched day 2 to set up a three way no clear. Body's mafia partner carries her to a win in a 3 way. Mafia wins! Body wins!

https://epicmafia.com/game/4734530 Body: Sleepwalker. Wine: Sleepwalker (Town/Both win)

Wine, the sleepwalker gets n1'd. Town lynches GonFreeccss the nilla is lynched. Stalker kills the loudmouth and is confirmed mafia. Body votes first, and even though Stalker could be Sleepwalker, she refuses to believe she could be sleepwalker and pushes hard on mafia. Nothing too suspicious this game.

Conclusion: The fact that the two accounts are IP linked, they never talk at the same time: Proves this is multiaccounting. Body is always quiet when Wine is active. Wine is always active when Body is quiet. To prove it's not in Wine's nature to ISP a lot. This is a game with only Wine in it (https://epicmafia.com/game/4735065) She replies quickly and with a lost more pace than in games with Body. The fact that she also has suspicious games with Sign/Signature/Bromance is also something that will be looked into.

_______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________

body: http://puu.sh/mlesr/de274155b2.png
sign: http://puu.sh/mlerm/c46667b963.png
http://puu.sh/mlesM/10d1258420.png

https://epicmafia.com/game/4733828/review - win, body maf sign town. sign doesn't talk much and instantly townreads mafia for no good reason. no reaction when he shoots and lynches wrong.

https://epicmafia.com/game/4733884/review - unranked, both town. sign gets guilty on mafia d1, and instantly outs it and spams to lynch it. noteworthy because he ends up trying more in this game as cop with jan'd sheriff than he does as sheriff in the previous game. the following day, body tunnels on harley when sign gets a confirmation in GY that one of harley/mega is mafia and mega was the inno from n2. then, when sign gets a confirmation that zerro is the partner, body shortly outs a scumread on zerro with no reasoning. she also proceeds to out a bad townread on PRC shortly after the GY confirms that he's town. heavily suggests GY vision.

https://epicmafia.com/game/4733936/review - win, body maf sign town. body CCs cop d1, then gets a bandwagon on her. sign votes it, then changes his vote less than a minute later once body says it was too quick. only other thing sign does d1 is ask why tangent (town) says body is confirmed, then proceed to scumread tangent for it. d2 body is confirmed and refuses to hammer it. d3 sign goes 1/2 and tunnels the mafia. however, most of his arguments are weak and he explains his defense of body poorly. he gets lynched in lylo for a maf win.

https://epicmafia.com/game/4734003/review  - win, body maf sign town. d1 sign doesn't say a lot of content, mostly filler and talking when addressed. all his reads are incorrect. n2 body urges her partner to guilty sign "because he sucks so hard". d2 sign repeatedly claims cop is jan'd when guiltied, and never considers PRC (real cop) as town. when kicks go up, sign goes afk then kicks when votes pile up on PRC.

https://epicmafia.com/game/4736496/review - lose, both town. nothing exciting happens in this game. both are town, with sign being sheriff. he shoots right, but his only outs one (correct) scumread on body's townread. he mishammers twice in a row to a town loss.

https://epicmafia.com/game/4736520/review - lose, body maf, sign town. sign gets lynched d1 and says almost nothing in his defense besides "sorry i am new". in his defense, it's a relatively quick day (<2 minutes) so there isn't much to say on his part. body votes sign early and says "please just kill this", likely because sign would be a very easy lynch to get. even with basically no ML for the game, body gets owned and loses.

https://epicmafia.com/game/4736581/review - win, body town, sign mafia. town gets an effortless autowin. sign stalks body, gets outed because body is loudmouth, then sign's dumbass partner kills body.

https://epicmafia.com/game/4736596/review - win, both town. again, town gets an effortless autowin. this setup is dogshit

https://epicmafia.com/game/4736617/review - win, both town. finally a non-autowin game. body is n1'd as sleepwalker. sign spends most of the day scumhunting and trying, as opposed to when he's town with body as maf. he jumps around on a few reads, but settles on mafia by the end of the day.

conclusion: multiaccounting, sign never tries nearly as hard when body is mafia. however, when body is town, sign scumhunts talks noticeably more. there is a lack of body town sign mafia games to gauge how those would play out in a pattern, though if i had to guess it would likely be that body talks a lot, sign does little to nothing, and body magically will scumread correctly once sign is lynched. most importantly, neither of them talk during the same time at all. they talk in short bursts or sections of the games, but they never have intermingling lines. even if body is outing a lot of lines and reads, the second sign talks, body quiets down until sign stops talking. the accounts aren't linked but it's multiaccounting and i'll bet lotsa money on it.

_______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________

Body: http://puu.sh/mlesr/de274155b2.png
Bromance: http://prntscr.com/9mngb8

http://prntscr.com/9mnfss (5 games with Body)

https://epicmafia.com/game/4728470/review - town lose. bromance is cop and body is mafia. during n1 mafia meeting, body led a kill on bromance who happens to be a cop. body says "let's kill bromance. he went 3/3 last game". bromance got killed n1. body kills sheriff n2 (bromance finally spoke and only said one line in the GY during that night) After d1, prs were clear so body pretty much did his job as mafia and killed whoever he wanted.


https://epicmafia.com/game/4728435 - win, both town. body got killed by mafia n1. bromance's role is sheriff. Bromance didn't talk much/scumhunt and waited for 4 minutes to shoot a gun and mafia dies. town self'd for sheriff and bromance hammered nilla who did not talk at all after mafia got shot d1. in d2, cop dies and bromance followed journ's vote on mafia and the game ends.

https://epicmafia.com/game/4728365 - lose, both town. body is journ and bromance is blue.  body gets fake guilited by mafia and inno'd by real cop. body tunnels on fake cop and sheriff shot fake cop. body questions bromance's fos but townreads him/her anyway. no response from bromance on that and bromance omgus'd the person who voted them. body made a comment and said the town should vote that person who voted bromance. sheriff hammers bromance d1. then body got killed by mafia. in the GY, he c/p or wrote a fake report "A is guilty" and A is actually mafia, thinking he was still alive. it took him 23 seconds to realize he was in the GY. meanwhile town was just talking around and mishammered blue. the game ends.


https://epicmafia.com/game/4728355/review - unranked, bromance town, body mafia. nothing really happened..body's partner suicided n1.

https://epicmafia.com/game/4725171/review - win, both town with same role as blue. let's start with d1. body talks more than bromance. body has two fosses - 1 mafia/1 town. body outted his read that bromance is not in teams with his fos who is mafia. body also said he agrees with bromance's lynch and it was on blue. d2: body and bromance are still alive. there was a confirmed mafia because they killed lm so everyone was voting them. bromance gave a read and said he/she is clear and trs body and other person who is mafia. bromance got killed n3. when d3 began, bromance kept asking if Lucky7 (EM player) was mafia and body's start suggested that body thought lucky was mafia as well. bromance changed his mind and asked if it was body but cecila (who killed lm n2) told Bromance who real mafia was. meanwhile in game, body questioned his fos (his fos was on town) and then changed his mind (without really giving out the reads or actually took time to reread) and hammered mafia.

Interestingly, in d1, body was pretty solid on Lucky7 being mafia. Body said if Lucky7 flipped mafia, he would mark twitter (EM player who is mafia in 3 way with Body and Lucky7) D1 clearly suggests that Body did not read twitter's lines carefully. he had strong reads on blue who got ML'd (his name is Wunderkind) d1 and other mafia (caels, EM username). for example, he gave a read which made him seem confident - "Wunderkind and Lucky7 was not a team"

Keep in mind - D3: Body still fos'd Lucky7 and Lucky7 instavoted him. Body somehow doesn't fos him anymore and only asked mafia 1-2 questions.


Conclusion: Last game vs the rest of games - Bromance was more talkative in GY with Body being alive in last game (https://epicmafia.com/game/4725171/review). Bromance wasn't really talkative in other games with body - due to body/bromance getting n1'd or being clear. However, when body and bromance are both town, they always tr each other. in one of these games where body was a clear and he just tr'd bromance recklessly. as for the last game, body and bromance were unclear blues and they actually scumhunted (body mostly) and gave out the reads. There was almost never any interaction between them other than TR'ing each other. Also, it is worth mentioning that Bromance and Body never talk at the same time. Body and Bromance are possibly rolesharing - even though in https://epicmafia.com/game/4728365,  where Body "thought" he was still alive as journ in gy - suggesting that Bromance didn't tell him that mafia was killing him but he somehow guilited real mafia with his fake report. The best evidence to say they roleshared is probably this -  https://epicmafia.com/game/4728470 <-- Body killed Bromance and Bromance is a cop.


_______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________


Examination of Body’s games with signature

3 games - 2 mutual wins - 1 win over signature

https://epicmafia.com/game/4727970/review:

Sigature fake-claims with a guilty on colombe as sheriff. Colombe pretends to be sheriff to reaction test. Glock claims cop with an innocent report on Body. Body claims journalist after journalist is janned. Signature eventually shoots sonrio for troll-claiming various roles throughout the game. Signature asks glock18c and body for fos’es before hammering. Signature ends up hammering uberhorse753 as janitor. On day 2 signature townreads Body as the journ claim because Body could have random guiltied as mafia. Signature eventually gives Body hammer, and body promptly hammers Colombe into a win.

It is noteworthy that if Body and signature were multi-accounting, signature would have deliberately prolonged the game when he could have ended it quickly. Signature’s motivation behind prolonging the game would be to make it seem as if body and signature were two different users and to avoid suspicion. However, Body did seem to have an emotional reaction to signature’s hammer that indicates she was not expecting the hammer on the janitor. Additionally, for someone careful to avoid suspicion, signature did hand over the hammer to body on day 2. Granted, the idea of Body getting hammer was expressed by herself at night 2.

https://epicmafia.com/game/4728080/review

Revexx starts the day by sharing seemingly random role-reads of various players in the table. Revexx’s daystart eventually becomes the main topic of conversation throughout day 1 and leads to his own lynching. On day 2, dreamer confirms Robotbatman as mafia. On day 3, body’s reads seem to be a lot more confident and consolidated. It is easier to find mafia between two people. Body’s participation level on day 3 suggests that she did not have the assistance of breezybaby or simbark to win the game. Body argued that they were town because there was a momentum in her vote on revexx, where breezybaby and simbark had to wait for her to vote. Also because colombe died because she townread them. Body claimed they scumread simbark because of their awkward fence sitting in regards to the day 1 vote and because of their reaction to being suspected.

https://epicmafia.com/game/4728212/review

The crier initially cried to lynch signature on day 1, but later changed their mind to TheDeletedUser. Signature shared a townread on body on day 1, but all of body’s lines were dealt with game mechanics (specifically creating the crier line). Edwin was the lynch on day 2, but the governor ot’d the lynch to soul. On day 3, signature argues that edwin had to be mafia because if body were mafia, the logical assumption would be that edwin was governor that ot’d a vote off of herself (which does make sense). Body initially did not follow signature’s train of thought and they seemed to have mindsets that were in completely different places which suggests that they aren’t the same person. However, their lines/thoughts never intermingled, all of their speech patterns do not overlap with each other’s.

_______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________


In conclusion: It is obvious there is at the very least throwing in all of these cases. Body and Wine's IP addresses are linked. It's obvious that they are rolesharing. Sign has similar tendancies as Wine, though the IP is not linked. It is heavily implied that there is rolesharing or multiaccounting going on. In terms of Bromance/Signature: Both of those account are linked to each other. Though it's harder to tell if there is multiaccounting going on, there is enough evidence to show there is rolesharing or at the very least throwing in Body's favor.