Lot of unused CS/Judgments, resulting in a total of 58 less HP generated than Zealtor (more than 25% less.) Not sure what ability CD is at level of haste and can't account for AvSh resets, so not sure what total possible amount is.

Results in fewer SotR casts/uptime (44 vs 51 casts.)

Has Seraphim talented, but hasn't cast it once. This accounts somewhat for the fewer amount of attacks (missing 1000 haste rating, 50% of the time.) But as is, HP generators are still being hit less often than they would if haste were even 0%.

Hasn't cast level 90 talent once. Possibly taking Holy Prism, but should be either Light's Hammer or Execution Sentence in all situations(?).

16 fewer casts of Holy Wrath than Zealtor (5% of his uptime.) 18 fewer casts of Consecration (30% of his uptime.)

Neither of you guys hit Hammer of Wrath as often as you can. :U Shame.

Using Warlord's Unseeing Eye instead of Anzu's Cursed Plume. More mastery = more AP = bigger damage with ring and Holy Avenger up. If Eye mandatory for proper haste but you'd rather have mastery for damage, this can be solved with either EmpSeals or (better yet) proper Seraphim use.

Not using Holy Avenger with every ring CD (didn't use it on pull, then misaligned with the second/third ring uses.)

Anzus + Seraphim uptime + Holy Avenger lineups + ring ilvl ALL account for overall damage. And in particular, the complaint that Zealtor's SotRs are critting 50% harder.

Zealtor's biggest crit of 217k comes with Anzu's + Seraphim + ring up.
Ed's biggest crit of 142k happens within the same 5s, but with only one of those buffs (ring) up.

Decent Sacred Shield uptime at 89% (try for 98%+). Zealtor's is lazy at 54%. :U