The Grand Game of Give and Take 1 (CYOA)

>Day trying not to be attractive to Fluttershy
>You're sick of Fluttershy stalking you, trying to rape you, trying to guess your fetish, and trying to buy you stuff
>It's really annoying
>So you're going to find something she finds unattractive
>Hmmmmm
>Male horses don't have nipples
>But you do
>Maybe she'll see your nipples and find them unattractive
>You decide to go shirtless today
>Walking around Ponyville
>Ponies staring at your bare chest
>Don't care
>Suddenly Yellow Quiet meekly approaches
>"A-anon you're looking wonderful today....you should wear less clothes more often, if that's okay with you..."
>Her wings are erect
Look at my nipples
>She blushes
>"Oh my..."
>You grin smugly
>Hah she probably wasn't expecting them to be there
Turns you off right? Yeah I bet y- Aaaa!
>She is now hovering in the air and suckling on your nipples
>Occasionally she kisses them while moving from one nipple to the other
>Her tongue swirls around them and she nibbles softly
Aaaaa! Stop!
>She squeaks and flutters back
>"S-so you don't like nippleplay?"
Shouldn't they be weird to you?
>"I think they're a b-bonus....and um primates have nipples...it's normal...."
>Damn
One of these days I'll find something that turns you off...
>"I love you Anon, I'll do anything for you mister."
>Oh right the fetish thing....
>So nipples are a bonus for her...
>Damn it!
>Well female horses have nipples….
>Maybe something weirder is needed
>You look at your hands
>Nah, might even be appealing to her
>You look at your feet
>That might work
>Ponies rarely see them since you wear shoes almost all of the time, and if you don’t you have socks
>You grin
>It’s time to stop Fluttershy once and for all!
>Go bare foot for today
>Walking to the library to check out Daring Do books
>You arrive only to find that Rainbow Dash has checked out all the copies
>Damn it
>Fluttershy is there
>She’s smiling at you
>Ugh
What do you want?
>”Uh! Um I was just reading this book…”
>She conceals the book with a wing
I don’t care what you’re reading, Fluttershy…
>She slowly moves her wing back in place
>The title of the book is: “Humans and Pegasi: Natural Partners”
>Notice the book looks custom made
>Authors are Lavender Magic and Butterfly Bold
Nice pen names you two have….
>”Eep! It’s a work in progress!”
>You sigh
Okay well have fun writing a bunch of stuff I won’t read. See you later…
>You’re not even going to bother with the feet thing right now
>You need a cold shower, just the thought of Twilight and Fluttershy writing about humans and pegasi…..
>Ugh!
>Ponies belong to ponies!
>Humans to humans!
>How hard is that?
>You’re spending so much time raging about this that you don’t notice quiet hoofsteps accompany you home
>You slam the door behind you
>”*squeak*!”
>Huh?
>What was that?
>Somehow that sound pissed you off
>You’re not sure why
>Go to the bathroom
>Damn your feet are dirty
>And really sore
>Undress
>Get in the tub
>Run the water
>Pull out bubble bath soap
>No one must know your love for bubble baths
>You pour a whole bunch of that shit in and get in
>Lay down and rest your head at the edge of the tub
Aaaaaaaaah this is nice…
>”Oh I agree mister.”
>Eyes widen
>Fluttershy is in the tub with you
>Her head rests on your chest while the rest of her body is pressed closely against you
>Wings shooting out from her back
>Her eyes are closed and she has a little content smile
>”Oh my.”
JESUS CHRIST! ARE YOU IN THE TUB?! WHY ARE YOU IN THE TUB?!
>She squeals and jumps back from you
>Fluttershy is now at the opposite end of the tub
>The shy pony is fumbling with her hooves as she stammers out an explanation
>”Well I love observing your naked and pure body….and um I wanted to get…”
>”*mumble mumble*”
>Sigh
>Lean in your head to hear her
>”I wanted to be ….c-closer”
>She kisses your cheek
>You glare and move your head away
That’s creepy Fluttershy, and furthermore-
>Realize this is a good opportunity to try to turn her-off
>You lay back down
>Raise a foot from under the water
>You display it proudly in front Fluttershy’s face
>Still a bit dirty
>She gasps
>Yes!
>She hates it
What’s wrong? Does it turn you off?
>”Oh no, Anon it’s just that your feet are structured very strange…”
>Fluttershy holds the foot in between her hooves
>”I thought it was mutilated, because it’s different from other primates.”
>She smiles
>”But I can see it’s perfectly healthy”
>She kisses it
>then giggles
>”It’s very cute.”
>Cute?!
>What the hell is her problem!
>No…. she’s hiding her hate for it
W-well if you like it so much, why don’t you wash them!
>You grin smugly and show her your other foot
>She smiles
>You maintain eye contact to see if she’s pretending to like it
>Futtershy lathers up your feet with her hooves
>They trail along the bottom of your foot
>It kind of tickles
>You squirm a little
>Trying not to laugh
>Maybe you should speed up her disgust
>You curl your toes around her hooves
>”Your feet really like me mister~.”
>She begins to rub them more lightly and quickly
>Causing it to tickle like crazy
>You laugh and squirm
>She giggles along with you and tickles them with her wings
>She holds your legs with her hooves
Hahahahahah stop! It tickles too much! Feet are sensitive!
>Fluttershy continues to brush her wings on your feet for another minute
>Then she stops and gives them a firm kiss
>She rinses your feet
>”All clean, and you looked so happy when I played with them.”
>She blushes
>”I love when you’re happy Anon.”
>”I-I wish you would smile more….”
>You frown at her to hide the smile you got from the tickling
Wasn’t it weird and gross for you?
>She shakes her head
>”Not at all Anon, it’s like um washing an animal….”
>Fluttershy hides behind her mane
>You sigh
>She likes taking care of animals
>And she associates you with them often
>”A very very attractive animal.”
>Fluttershy gets extremely close to you
>You were about to give her a bubble beard and carry her out of your house
>Until you noticed your feet were still sore
>Maybe she’ll notice how gross they are when dry
>And you can get relief out of it
Fluttershy, how would you like to give me a foot massage?
>She agree and after drying off and putting on clothes (much to her disappointment) you we lies down on the bed with her
>You display your feet to her
Okay, feet massages are really sucky….
>Wiggle your toes
>”Why?”
Because it’s feet…
>”But I think it’s wonderful to take care of your sensitive parts, sweetheart.”
Just start rubbing
>Her hooves trail along your two feet
>They’re firm yet gentle
>Warm and soft, yet dense and solid
>They knead into your soft soles
>You can’t help but let out a content sigh
>She goes a bit firmer and you feel sweet relief
>Then her hooves trail up your feet
>She then focus both her hooves on one foot
>Circular rubs gently massage the ball of your foot
>Your toes curl in delight
>Fluttershy coos happily
>”Your toes are the cutest thing ever!”
>She moves onto them and gives them individual attention
>It’s actually embarrassing
>Because she’s babytalking them and playing with them
>On the other hand she gets them to pop and you sigh in relief
>This is good….
>You’re laying down and relaxing
>Then you feel a wet and warm sensation run across a foot
Aaaa!
>Fluttershy is licking it!
>She runs it along slowly and then stops at your toes
>With a smile, she nibbles softly on them
>It tickles like crazy
Hahahaha!
>Then she engulfs them in her mouth
>Her tongue massages and playfully rubs across your toes
Stop!
>”Mmmmmm”
>You lightly kick at her, but she takes this as a signal to go more intensely
>She lets go, but then she kisses it before quickly engulfing a big portion of your foot
>Her tongue roughly and quickly runs across it
>You try pulling away but she’s able to get what she wants
>You hate to admit, it but it’s making you hot and bothered
>You wait for her to finish
>Fluttershy releases your foot with a “pop!” from her mouth
>She lunges for the other one but you curl your foot and move it away
No! Stop!
>”So footplay isn’t your fetish?”
I was hoping it would turn you off!
>”I like your feet though…”
Well someday I’m gonna find a way to turn you off from me!
>”N-no I’m going to find your fetish, if that’s okay with you.”
It’s not okay
>You pick her up and cradle her in your arms
>She squeaks but then nuzzles her head into your chest
Enjoy it while you can
>The window is open
>Throw her out of it
>One of these days
>You'll find her turn off!
>Fucking Fluttershy

>The next day
>You march over to the library
>Fluttershy is browsing the library too
What are you doing here?
>"Finding something that will make you love me."
>She pulls out the Big Book of Fetishes
Funny you should mention that. I'm finding something that will make you dislike me.
>You pull out the Big Book of Turn Offs
>You both check out the books dramatically
>"I'm going to find your fetish first,mister."
No, I'm going to find your turn off!
>"I love you"
I don't like you
>"And nothing is going to stop m-me..."
You're not stopping me
>"From loving you!"
From finding your turn-off!
>You two leave the library while dramatically staring each other off
>This means war