swordsman v duelist

Duelist v Swordsman findings --Tissues

Assumptions -
	Clean room (no damage/movement/buffs)
	Heavy Armor target (2597) (coefficients use 2600)
	No traits

Naked | single steady pistol (258)
	Duelist ------
		916 power
		coefficient of 0.4 according to wiki
		96 per shot (red flag here)
		takes 7.5 seconds to complete all 8 shots (#1 source, worst case scenario)
		takes 5.4 seconds idle between attack channel (#1 source, worst case scenario)
		12.9 seconds to complete a rotation (idle + attack)
		258 x 916 x 0.4 / 2597 = 40.37 per hit
		tooltip supports the claim of 40 damage per shot, the actual numbers are around 86
		//calculating in-game coefficient (IGC)
			258 x 916 x IGC / 2597 = 96
			IGC = 249312 / 236328
			IGC = ~1.05
			Rounding to 1
		Now to check scaling on IGC
			258 x 1066 x 1 / 2597 = 105.90
			107 per shot
		Much more realistic
		//calculating DPS
		Now taking our 86, by 8 shots = 688
		688 / 12.9  = 53 DPS

	Swordsman ------
		916 power
		coefficiant of 2.0 according to wiki
		645 on average (red flag here)
		takes 4.5 seconds to attack and idle (Self Calculated, #1 source confirms)
		258 x 916 x 2.0 / 2597 = 182
		tooltip supports the claim of 182 damage per shot, the actual numbers are 645
		//calculating in-game coefficient (IGC)
			258 x 916 x IGC / 2597 = 645
			IGC = 1675065 / 236328
			IGC = ~7
		Now to check scaling on IGC
			258 x 1066 x 7 / 2597 = 741.31
			750 on average
		Much more realistic
		//calculating DPS
		741 / 4.5 = 165 DPS

What I learned and stuff untested

Coefficients are fucked
Phantasms do not adapt the caster's weapon. This is most notable with steady weapons. Only phantasms have a range of damage regardless of weapon range.
Until Phantasms are logged in the combat tab, this is all speculation and based on my inner clock
While swordsman has almost triple the dps, keep in mind Duelist has 8 shots which can result in more damage at 50%+ crit chance then the base 53 DPS shows. This is bare minimum.
Duelist has a Combo Finisher that is more appealing than Swordsman in my opinion.

Sources ----
Coefficients are from wiki
http://wiki.guildwars2.com/wiki/Phantasmal_Swordsman
http://wiki.guildwars2.com/wiki/Phantasmal_Duelist
#1 -- http://wiki.guildwars2.com/wiki/Phantasmal_Haste