288 jwlk Thu May 24 2012 10:28:38 AM
hi go check thread kk thx

289 Eidolonic Thu May 24 2012 11:34:38 AM
By the way. I absolutely want an Acolyte claim. I like having townfirms, and there's zero reason to remain hidden at this point.

290 KaiDASH Thu May 24 2012 11:45:17 AM
.. isn't that you?

:mspa:

291 Eidolonic Thu May 24 2012 11:50:47 AM
Post 278, Kai. That should tell you what I am.

292 KaiDASH Thu May 24 2012 11:53:11 AM
well yeah.

but i thought you were the acolyte like all of day 1 because reasons

293 Eidolonic Thu May 24 2012 12:04:40 PM
Heh, yeah. I can totally see that in retrospect. Throw me a check on your way out the door, and then doc us to victory, I guess.

Mind looking at the stuff I mentioned in 287?

294 Sesc Thu May 24 2012 12:13:47 PM
Witch!Stojil makes me feel better than ever before. He was the one that claimed bob's lynch wagon was just spiffing. Also reverse reasoning on Castiel says he's Town, then >_>

What about Kalas? (#165, #192)


Also, is it an idea to use the B.O.D. and get her to give Kai +1 life? We'd trade her for one more check, effectively.

295 Menace Thu May 24 2012 12:15:32 PM
Ehhhhh. Unless Kai has a solid target in mind, I don't think it would be worth it.

296 Eidolonic Thu May 24 2012 12:17:03 PM
I don't think it's worth it at this point? That can be extremely powerful in mid-late game. Taking our 2 town for 1 elder trade is... reasonable, I guess. BOD would be 3 town for 1 elder and a very slim shot at a second.

297 castiel Thu May 24 2012 12:17:39 PM
Stojil, post 161

The wagon on bob99 looks clean to me at the moment. With the possible exception of Castiel (and his check-targets), all the other votes feel like bandwagoning town more than scum and at first, town trying to gauge reactions. What I don't like much is Kalas' interaction with bob99 and his non-vote.

Stojil, post 165

I'm... not sure I understand your post, but here's my answer anyway. If you were lynched and turned out to be town, I would look mostly into Castiel. After that, Striker (for other reasons as well) and maybe Geabe. Kalas would be scummy no matter what you are.

If we were scum and on the same team I doubt he would have done this, or I would have let him do this. I was already enough of a target that 2 people suggested I should be lynched instead.

Also,
#vote Uncle Stojil

298 KaiDASH Thu May 24 2012 12:24:55 PM
I actually like the BoD idea.

Assuming that today and tomorrow witch kills are successful, then we're down me and some other role

Almost every other role is more mechanically useful than the BoD.

But if we lynch the BoD today, then tonight's kill is me again, and tomorrow's kill is me... again.

Court can kill stojil (unless something crazy like the dhulli slot was king lolo) and we can talk about nice people like geabe and aekiel tomorrow.

Incidentally, this totally screws witch target prioritization since they can't exactly leave me alive.

Also a BoD that claims is super town so having another townfirm will be good for vote/action analysis (me, strikerlee, acolyte, BoD)

thoughts?

299 KaiDASH Thu May 24 2012 12:26:20 PM
The biggest bonus imo is screwing with the ability for witches to kill who they want to.

300 Eidolonic Thu May 24 2012 12:30:12 PM
Hm.

Hnnng.

Yeah, okay.

I'm officially on board with a BOD reveal, and lynching them, giving the life to Kai. The court will kill Stojil tonight.

I stillll want an Acolyte claim as well, though. But am proceeding as if Kai's legit. (he is, I just want another townfirm, dammit).

301 Sesc Thu May 24 2012 12:30:38 PM
Something along those lines was what I thought, yeah.

302 Eidolonic Thu May 24 2012 12:37:22 PM
So, we're looking for BOD claim and Acolyte claim, with the BOD needing to happen pretty soon.

The only exception to BOD being lynched today is if it's a court member, I think. Well, or if they're scum and refuse to claim. That too.

303 KaiDASH Thu May 24 2012 12:39:59 PM
i'm still in utter amazement that you aren't the acolyte btw

304 Menace Thu May 24 2012 12:40:38 PM
But guys! What if the Acolyte is scum!?!?

305 Eidolonic Thu May 24 2012 12:40:39 PM
I was trying shenanigans assuming a potential paranoid/derp priest. But it fits pretty well in retrospect.