<CorveX> I thought so i was just checking to make sure

<forums> This is less of a rules question but more a confirmation that it works how I think it does.
<Turner-> that's what I thought
<Phasing2> i thought that was the case
<Sliver16> that's what I thought, a friend said they went onto here and was told you could exile tokens from the graveyard
<Discard16> yea, okay thank i was right woooah, he said i had to assign rest of defense
<Ghitu6> kk, ty, that is what I thought
<Alpha14> Alright, that's exactly what I thought, thanks
<Boar5> Thank you, that is what I thought.
<Jackal9> thank you, thats what I thought
<MiddenFac> thanks for confirming
<Yp> Ok, thought so. Thanks!
<mikebrum> That was how I felt. There's no deterministic outcome pending the random order post-shuffle.
<Adept10> Okay, I thought so, but my friend was giving me some serious junk about it. Thanks a bunch.
<Eldrazi17> okay, just wanted to make sure, ya'll are awesome :)
<Human0> Damn, that's what I guessed. Thanks guys.
<FatStack> Alright, I figured as much. Thank you!
<Stasis> ok, thanks everyone, thats what I was thinking
<Instant0> ok that's what i thought just double checking thank you amullins
<Tempest2> that's what i was thinking
<Equip3> thats what i thought thanks guys
<Ape13> cool, that's what i thought... thanks
<Drone4> thought so
<Cleric8> Thank you.  Just wanted to verifty
<Archer2> that's what I figured, thanks
<Seal3> That's what I thought, thanks
<Turner-> that's what I thought
<Phasing2> i thought that was the case
<Sliver16> that's what I thought, a friend said they went onto here and was told you could exile tokens from the graveyard
<Discard16> yea, okay thank i was right woooah, he said i had to assign rest of defense
<Ghitu6> kk, ty, that is what I thought
<Alpha14> Alright, that's exactly what I thought, thanks
<Boar5> Thank you, that is what I thought.
<Jackal9> thank you, thats what I thought
<MiddenFac> thanks for confirming
<Yp> Ok, thought so. Thanks!
<Flash6> K thats how I thought it worked. Ty
<Bolt10> thats what i thought. thanks.
<TriggerRu> okay, that's what I thought, but I wanted to make sure. thank you!
<Merfolk11> that's what I thought thanks
<Anonemous> thats what i thought, thank you very much
<Scryus> Sanity check here (this is the prequel to That's What I Thought, the musical)
<Arlhached> Thought so, thanks for the help
<todd64> ok thats what i thought
<Ceejsteak> That's what I thought
<seaes> that's what I was about to say
<NickB> Ok that's what I thought
<Scryus> Put that in your pastebin and smoke it
<Portal12> okay, thats what i thought, thanks
<DavidCo> Ok, that's what I thought, just wanted to make sure.
<Magus6> k thats what i thought
<Duder> i thought so
<Duder> thats what i said
<WhoisStup> ok, that's what I thought
<gfauxpas> thought so
<Tarpan1> ok that's what i thought
<Krektogar> thats what i thought, just wanted to make sure
<Unglued18> I figured that was why. I thought that it would exile everything attached to it as well.
<Wurm13> as i expected, ty ty
<Gazurb> thats what i figured, thanks
<Shandalar> thought so
<m0rning4e> ok, i didnt think so but wasnt sure. thanks.
<Jace16> that's what i thought
<RorakKuro> ok, that's what I thought
<Sphinx7> beautiful, that's what I thought, but I wanted to make sure
<Lam> Okay I thought so. Thanks. :)
<sharpshie>  thats what i figured, thanks
<mjj29> that's what I thought, but wanted to check, thanks
<overload1> ok, very thanks.
<HurplePaz> ok thought so
<Homarid10> That's what I thought. So a second question is as soon as a creatures toughness equals 0 is it immediately put in the graveyard?
<Stack3> Thank you. I figured that was the case.
<Jhoira> got it, that's what i thought might happen
<Bringer9> Thought so. Thanks. In your opinion, what would be my best bet to get rid of master? I'm running G/R.
<patfan> Thought so, thanks
<Stack1> awesome, just making sure thanks
<Soldier6> i figured
<Sphinx5> thats what i thought, but there was some hem and haw
<Rob973> Thank you, this is exactly what I thought, I knew I was correct about the ruling.
<Xit> rock on figured as much just needed to be reinsured
<Reyz> alright that's what I thought, thank you.
<phoenix4> Thought so, thx man :)
<Kobold15> makes sense, it's what I thought, but I wanted to see if there was a loophole
<Kroog18> thought so, thanks
<Snnn> That's what I thought. Thanks
<Jackal0> Crap that's what I thought.
<gfauxpas> thought so
<kooljay2> Thats the same thing I was just thinking, but to say it happens during combat just doesnt pass the smell test for me. I don't like it, but if thats the way it works thats the way it works.
<Trygon> Didn't think so thanks for the help.
<Djinn11> thats what i though
<Djinn11> tought
<Djinn11> thought*
<Lazav> That's exactly what I thought. Thank you.
<Ceejsteak> That's what I was thinking. Thanks!
<Dapogo> Ok, that's what I thought, thanks!
<gfauxpas> thought as much
<CrypticMe> Thats what I was thinking, coppro.
<Guild10> thanks. thought so. just wanted to double check
<Guild10> i figured that. just like any counter still need to pay the cost of the spell.
<RedPoet> That's what I thought. Thanks
<DLI> That's what I thought.
<RabidWomb> Sudden doubt : if I move an Equipment from creature A, to creature B, and creature B gets killed in response, is the Equipment still attached to A, or unattached ?
<Managor> WAs just checking, thanks. That's what I thought, but I didn't want to look stupid tomorrow at FNM. :P
<Mirodir> thanks, as I thought.
<unusual> sweet thanks. thats what i thought.
<Eldrazi6> Ok, that's what I thought. Thank you
<grphugFTW> ah. that's what i wondered about. thank you, good to know.
<Ascension> ahh okay, targets both creatures, just making sure
<Forest0> okay, I had suspected that, but I wasn't sure
<Revised15> thought so, also its effect triggers on the casters upkeep not the defender's right?
<Cars10wrk> Nlin: Thanks, I knew that, but I decided not to be that specific since it doesn't have anything to do with the question.
<Ashnod> thanks, thought so. 702.2c
<telos> very true i thought so just needed clarification :)
<Omni> That's what I always think. But, sometimes, people tell me I'm wrong. Whatever. It's cool. :D
<sparhawk8> that's what I thought.  I just wanted to double check before FNM
<Elvish5> thats what I thought thank you
<Ceejsteak> Ha yeah that's what I...never mind
<Unicorn8> thought so
<Comando> That's what I thought, thanks.
<gfauxpas> thats what I thought, thanks
<Griffin15> That's what I though; thanks.
<Relic4> Thanks thats what I thought
<Dragon12> Thought so. Thanks!
<Spirit5> Ya that was my ruling Dcollins just making sure
<Homarid1> -_- thanks i knew i was right
<Flash12> ok thanks that's what I thought
<Soundgard> thought so
<Badger5> no first strike. that is what I thought. thank you
<jmk> that's what i thought(tm)
<n00b426> I knew it!
<grphugFTW> huh. they did away with it there. But okay thanks.
<Praetor9> thanks guys, that's what we thought!
<Tundra0> This is what I suspected. Too bad - flitterstep eidolon looked fun in Animar EDH.
<DivisionB> that's what my gut told me; just wanted to make sure - not that delay was ever that good, but casting delay on a flashed back spell is extra bad
<Scryus> sanity check: If I Sudden Spoiling an Invisible Stalker, I can block it, right?
<Scryus> Thanks Ceejsteak, that is what I thought.
<Block7> Thats what we thought thank you for the conformation
<Portal7> I actually knew the answer, but my friend doesn't believe me unless I ask you guys lol.
<Alienhead> That is what I said, but I am obviously a noob.
<Ceejsteak> Thanks, that's what I thought
<Turner-> <Ceejsteak> Thanks, that's what I thought
<Ceejsteak> <Turner-> <Ceejsteak> Thanks, that's what I thought
<Turner-> <Ceejsteak> <Turner-> <Ceejsteak> Thanks, that's what I thought
<Ceejsteak> <Turner-> <Ceejsteak> <Turner-> <Ceejsteak> Thanks, that's what I thought
<Turner-> <Ceejsteak> <Turner-> <Ceejsteak> <Turner-> <Ceejsteak> Thanks, that's what I thought
<Ceejsteak> <Turner-> <Ceejsteak> <Turner-> <Ceejsteak> <Turner-> <Ceejsteak> Thanks, that's what I thought
<Cleric2> that's what I thought too, then the program I'm using (forge) is using the card wrong. Thanks
<Omni> Yeah. I thought as much. Still. Like checking.
<Flying1> That's what I thought.
<ProphetOf> thanks guys. that's what I thought
<Omni> That's what I thought.
<Omni> Makes sense. That's what I always thought it does, but, as usual, I always like double checking.
<Omni> Didn't think so.
<otashi> k thats what i figured, friend told me otherwise lol
<Clash18> ok good thank you thats what i thought
<Unicorn1> Gotcha, that's what I thought. Thanks,
<Archer10> IYes I thought so, opponent tried telling me its an activated ability soit doesn't count as a mana ability
<Hydra15> Expected as much, thx a bunch.
<Techie624> Ok, thats what I thought... just was wondering about the defined differences. Thank you
<jeepcj> I thought that was the case but we wanted to be sure.
<Vamprie0> thats what i thought
<Archer17> fk i knew it
<Archer17> I KNEW IT
<Drone14> okay that's what i thought. thank you very much!
<mithost> That's what I thought ther
<Devorer> i thought so but i was confused because in the ruling it says the effects go one after another so i was not sure. so the effect works only for itself in its resolvig and i win the next turn if the cards stay on the board
<jmk> That's what I thought.
<gfauxpas> thats what I thought, thanks seal
<Advisor10> I figured as much...just checking!
<Plains15> I'm pretty sure I'm right, but just want to confirm, when Magic 2015 rolls in, only 2014 is rotating out, correct? The Return to Ravnica block (and all the shocklands) will still be Standard legal until the next expansion after 2015 rotates in?
<Portal6> That is what I thought! Thank you
<goodisont> Thought so, thank you
<Beta6> fuckin knew it.
<Phasing12> Thought so thanks
<grphugFTW> i was noticing that, just woke up. I meant Elvish5's answer was right.
<Gotcha7> ok, that would be my guess
<syl> yeah, that's what i figured
<Block14> Thought so. Thanks.
<Ally8> I didn't think so, wanted to make sure
<Turner-> that's what I thought
<Untap4> Yeah, I figured that worked.
<Mishra14> thats what i thought but it constantly resolves without me being able to pick three cards
<grphugFTW> k thanks, thought so there.
<Flash5> I think I know how this works, but I just want to make sure. So if my opponent has an Aegis of the Gods, I can't use Arc Trail to kill the Aegis and hit my opponent, correct? Due to there not being enough legal targets?
<jmk> That's what I thought(TM): passed the checks, they depend on each other, so we apply "remove all" first, and now we won't be applying the mill ability since it's not there.
<jmk> THAT'S WHAT I THOUGHT.
<densetsus> I thought so, thanks!
<Scryus> that's what I thought it would be
<Falkalore> Figured as much, thanks guys.
<dragonsli> thought so
<Revised12> yeah that's what I thought
<Revised9> ok like i was thinking ;-)
<opus5> thought so. Thanks.
<Kintanon> Double checking something: Sharuum is in my graveyard, I cast Body Double, it comes into play as a copy of Sharuum, targeting the Sharuum that is in my graveyard, the new Sharuum dies due to legend rules, and I use its own ETB affect to bring it back into play again, infinitely. This works, yes?
<Spider5> that's what we tought, just wanted to double check with someone else
<Block13> I didn't think so, can't explain why.  Is it because it has to be clear which game object is which? BTW, thx everyone for all your help...this is an awesome resource for mtg players.
<Zodiac12> ok that is what i thought thank you
<VeeArr> That's what I figured; just wanted to verify.
<Skitter> thats what i thought, thank you, got a second situation
<Urza17> thats what i thought, just wanted to double check
<Mint11> sounds good! I've been playing my deck correctly then, thanks a bunch!
<Harpyon> Thought so. Thanks
<gfauxpas> thats what I thought, thanks
<Mora> Ok, I thought so but wasn't 100% sure.
<Mora> Exactly what I was thinking
<Backaback> What I assumed, thank you.
<Shifter13> thought so
<Forest5> Ok cool that's what I thought, thank you
<bprill> Thanks, that's what I thought
<spoothead> Thanks. That's what I assumed but I wanted to make sure.
<Taiga6> Didn't think so. Thanks
<Human1> That's what I thought! My stepdad will not agree with me. He's old. So with prodigal pyromancer, can I block and then tap him to do 1 damage to the creature he is blocking?
<metatron> that's what I thought. Thank you
<Kreiger> Thanks, I thought so.
<RaT|Gone> I thought so.
<Ofonix> that what i was thinking, but my friend wanted to be sure i could do that
<Gar91> Ok great. I thought that was the case. Thanks.
<goofball> yeah, I thought not, but was rather hoping it would.   Thanks  :)
<Pirate7> thats what i thought thanks
<khursed> that's what I thought, thanks
<Bringer16> thanks, that's what I thought.
<Oppressiv> interesting. thank you. I wasn't fully confident about the rules on commas
<Zedruuthe> That's what I thought. I just wanted to make sure it was just that it had an old owner to return to, as opposed to the fact that they 'took' it and the 'took' effect ended.
<Flying15> didn't think so. thanks.
<chiralane> thought so =]
<Snake321> That's what I thought, but then MTGO has it wrong.
<MStarr> that's what I thought
<Yeti9> Thank you very much, i thought the same of you
<Discard10> thats what i thought
<Thomas25> ok thanks, thats what i thought.
<Kroog4> thought so
<Lincro> That's what I thought.  thanks.
<Bayou2> fair, thats what i thought
<Sliver13> that's what I thought
<Stranjer> Thats kind of what I figured
<Hound1> that what I thought just was checking thank you
<Ally8> I figured, thanks
<Popetoper> well done, I knew the answer already, just thought I would ask you guys to get your thinking juices working
<res0nat0r> thought so, thanks "\
<res0nat0r> yup, thought so
<Orgg5> ok thought so thanks
<Bolt7> that is what i thought thats
<Sorcery1> fucking knew it
<GodRax> Ok just as I thought
<Flying14> thank you, thats what I was saying...
<Mirrodin3> that's what I thought, I just wanted to make sure
<Lazav> That's what I thought. Such bollocks. :T
<mjj29> that's what I thought, but I've been told categorically that's not the case
<Arrest1> thought so
<Quest14> Thought so, thanks
<Knight9> I thought so. thanks
<jeff1234> That's what I thought, he said it wasn't because we already agreed to split, but it still felt super fishy to me, I declined so that I wouldn't get in trouble and we just split evenly
<Eric Shukan, Judgecast #95> That's what I thought.
<Aganos> Cool that ends up as what I thought. But I still feel the Disenchant player would have never tried to cast his disenchant if the Map would have been where it should have been, in the graveyard.
<Aganos> That's what it thought too.
<Elvish12> that's what I thought Guild11, but seems that others are telling me otherwise
<JoeH> That's what I thought.
<Sengir11> thanks i knew it
<Plains5> Thats what I thought. I just wanted to make sure before I have somebody try to tell me otherwise
<Rowdy> thats what i thought, ty
<Skitter> I figured as much but wanted to be sure.
<Archon8> didnt think so and thanks
<M4v> I thought so, but thought maybe I'd get lucky anyways.
<Garruk15> Awesome. Just wanted to make sure. Thanks!
<izzetchar> thought so
<felanor> Thats what I thought.
<atlyx> thank you.  that's what I thought.  but he won't take my word over it =\
<Eldrazi4> thought so, thanks
<Elvish17> ok i thought so thank you
<MadMageQc> That's what I thought.
<StrnjrPhn> Just got asked by someone if they can count judging as community service for something like extra credit for school. I'm thinking no but I thought I'd double check
<Cain590> That's what I thought.
<Geth17> thought so, but it never hurts to ask.
<Slyblade> If I activate Xathrid slyblade's ability during declare blockers, will my opponent be able to Hero's downfall it? My line of thought is that it has hexproof until ability resolves. Will priority pass after ability comes off the stack?
<Reveal6> Thanks.  That is what I thought and played.
<Keranos> Okay. That's what I thought, just wanted to make sure. Thanks
<titsos> k, thought so
<dgentry> That's what I thought.  In this case, the judge issued a game loss to the player, causing the player to lose the match.  Is there a resource I could give to the player to write a review?
<Lotus6> I know, just making sure I'm not crazy. Thanks.
<Stranjer> Thats what I'm leaning towards too.
<Equip13> okay that's what i thought.
<Sengir4> thank you just checking
<Bolt15> Okay thanks, that's what I tought
<AnS> guys, I need layering reconfirmation rulings...
<Swaffle> That is what I thought, I just wanted to confirm.  Is there like a specific rule I can quote?
<CorveX> I thought so i was just checking to make sure
<Legends13> thank you I knew I was right and I had a rules advisor and the other playing tell me otherwise.. I was watching the gqme but my frien
<Shifter9> ok, that's what I thought..thanks
<Portal11> Ok. That's what I thought. Thanks.
<Teysa> That's what i figured, thank you.
<Ceejsteak> That's what I would have said as well, and where we landed on JC
<Katzby> That's what I thought.
<Grincho> Woot, I knew it! Thanks!
<Mana6> that's the ruling I gave. Thanks  for the confirmation
<Noggle6> Alright, that is what I thought and what I ruled yesterday, but it was an unusual question for me.
<CaseyB> That's what I thought
<gfauxpas> thats what I figured thanks for the confirmation
<Magus8> Didn't think so. Thanks!
<Michael Puccio> Yeah that's what I was figuring
<Lotus123> that is what I said thanks for setting this argument
<Ghitu10> (Thank you. I knew that.
<Kor1> OK. That's what I figured, just wanted to make sure. Thank you!
<Mana13> thats what i figured, thanks a lot :)
<clubbprez> Cool 'nuff. I thought so, I just wanted to make sure I knew I was right in my thinking.
<Homarid10> thanks. I knew I was in the right. Oh well