Unconventional magic - 3: A Chance Opportunity

><You could do it Anon>
><Right here, right now>
><It would be hilariously easy to pull off and get away with>
<Fuck you brain! What if I grew wings afterward or something, how would I explain that shit?>
>That's a good point
>Something new could happen for every single time
>Even with the ability to erase short-term memory, how could you hide something like that?
>'Oh hey Twilight, yeah nothing happened last night, look at how my dick glows purple now!'
>Yeah that would definitely go over well
>Then again, you had no proof it would be like that
>You'll just have to wait and see
>Either way, remember the boundary you set
>Even with the recent turn of events, you were still falling for Rainbow Dash
>She had to come naturally, and you were mostly okay with this
>Honestly it was probably the only thing that would keep your sanity in check
--
>You sat next to this tree with Rainbow passed out beside you for ages
>You didn't care, time could go as fast or as slow as it wanted right now
>...Wait, why was the sun so low over the horizon?
>Well, you must have zonked out too
>You move a hand over Rainbow, gently petting her back
>Soon you move down to an exposed wing and begin massaging at the base
>Within moments one of her back legs begins twitching and kicking
>Ha! Just like a dog!
>You can't help but giggle at the sight, and keep going
>Soon Rainbow shuffles around a bit, must be waking up finally

>Her leg calms down but otherwise she does nothing
>You slow down your massaging almost to a stop
>"Mmm, don't stop Anon.." she mumbles as she forms a smile
"I'd love to keep going Dash, but.. well, open your eyes."
>Rainbow reluctantly obliges, turning to you first and smiling, before looking up toward the sun
>"Whoa how is it that late already?"
"I must have passed out too, we've been here a while. I'd say it's time to go back."
>Rainbow nods and slowly stands up, yawning and stretching out her legs
>You stand and practically mimic her; you have been sitting there for hours now after all
>As you're both walking back toward P0nyville, you remember something
"So hey, where do ya wanna go for dinner?"
>"Dinner? Ooh, right. Umm, I'm still really out of it, mind if we just chill at your place for a while or something?"
"Hmm, sure why not?"
>You and Rainbow had been taking your time walking the couple miles back to P0nyville
>The sun was beginning to set, giving the two of you a fantastic view
>As you enjoy the sunset, Rainbow nuzzles her head alongside you
>"This beats any ol' dinner date." she mumbles
"Agreed." you respond, laying a hand on her head and rustling her mane
>Before the sun completely leaves the sky, you make it home to Sweet Apple Acres
>And damn there's a divine scent coming from inside the house!
>Of course it mostly consisted of apple, but you didn't care

>You'd loved almost everything apple-related since before even coming to Equestria
>And living here only made it better
>Upon entering the house, you spy Applejack in the kitchen finishing up dinner
>Awesome, not only did you not have to pay for another meal for you and Dash, but you didn't have to make one either!
>AJ gives a glance back at the door and spots you
>"Just in time, ya can never resist mah cookin' can ya Anon?" she says with a chuckle
"You kiddin' me? The food you make here dwarfs anything I ever bad back on Earth."
>"Ah shucks, yer just sayin' that." she responds, turning back to the cooking
"I'm serious AJ!"
>You stroll into the kitchen and get a look at just what she was fixing up
"Did ya make enough for a guest?"
>AJ:"A guest?"
>Rainbow finally makers her way in
>RD:"There better be enough, that looks too good to pass up!"
>AJ:"Heya Rainbow! Of course there's enough, don't you worry."
>AJ turned her gaze from Rainbow to you, gave you a sly grin, then shifted back to the task at hand
>You and Rainbow take seats at the table when the feast was prepared
>Big Mac, Applebloom and Granny Smith eventually joined you three
>The family was always happy to see Rainbow Dash
>Likewise Rainbow never passed up an opportunity to have some of their food or cider
>And damn was that food good, just like every other meal the Apple family made
>Your taste buds could never repel flavor of that magnitude

>Granny Smith and Applebloom turn in early, leaving you, Rainbow, AJ, and Big Mac to hang out for the evening
>Eventually Rainbow's exhaustion from the day's events comes back and she decides to head home
>She has early weather duty in the morning anyway so you don't keep her
>Seems like tonight's going to be fairly uneventful, but you still made progress with Dash
>It won't be long now...
>Luckily you don't have to work tomorrow, so you get to sleep in
>By late morning you finally get up, have some leftover dinner for breakfast, and head out into P0nyville
>You didn't have any plans, but hopefully you could find something to do
>Your first objective was to check out the market by the town square
>If you remember correctly, Applebloom was running the Apple family market stand today
>As you stroll into the market, you spot Fluttershy walking away with a somewhat dejected look on her
>Well you can't just ignore that, so you go and see what's up
"Hey Fluttershy!"
>This cathces her off guard, as she stops walking, perks her head up and looks toward you
>"Oh, hi Anon."
"Everything okay?
>"Um, yes. Why do you ask?"
"You just look like you're really down about something is all."
>"Oh, well.. You see, I came here to get some herbs, but.. nop0ny has any left to sell right now."
>Her head and ears lower in defeat
"Oh, well, is there anywhere else around here you could get some?"
>"Just the Everfree Forrest, which is where I'm going now."

"Wait, you're going into Everfree? That forrest is dangerous you know!?"
>"Oh no it's okay, these herbs I need can be found around the edge of the forrest where there's no danger at all. I'll be fine Anon." she says, perking her head up a bit
"If you say so, but do you mind if I tag along? I don't really have anything better to do."
>"Sure, I guess so." she responds with a smile, as you both move on your way out of town
>Out of all the p0nies you'd made friends with, you've spent the least amount of time with Fluttershy
>She was just really shy, and was constantly tending to her animals
>Fluttershy also seemed to be a little extra nervous around you, but you weren't sure why
>Either it was because of you being an 'alien,' or that you were probably her only real male friend
>Maybe both
>The two of you could use some time together, so really this was already a great start to the day
>On your way to the forrest, Fluttershy describes to you what you'd be looking for
>Soon the two of you venture forth into the Everfree and begin your search
>You forced what small-talk you could, but this was Fluttershy so it never went far
>You two had searched the outskirts of the forrest for a couple hours and had little luck
>Fluttershy was getting worried
"Fluttershy, didn't you say these herbs were more common deeper in the forrest?"
>"Yes, but.. it's too dangerous."
"Tell ya what; I'll go further in and get some for you-"

>"Anon, no! You can't go that far into the Everfree by yourself!"
"I'm not afraid Fluttershy, besides I can easily take care of anything this forrest throws at me."
>"I.. you can't!"
"I'll be fine. You go on home with what you have, I'll head back as soon as I find a few more."
>Fluttershy continues trying to convince you otherwise, but finally you manage to send her on her way
>You continue moving deeper into the forrest, and what seems like a couple hours pass by
>You happen to spot some of the herbs you're looking for as you go along, and eventually get ready to turn back
>It's still mid-day, but the thickness of this forrest made it rather dark and gloomy in the area you were at
>So far though, no danger at all
>Shortly after you turn back, you hear some noises in the distance; bushes rustling, followed by a high-pitched 'eep!'
>Whelp, spoke too soon
>Wait, that was... Fluttershy!
>You take off in a mad sprint in the direction of the sound
>You come to a small clearing and spot two timberwolves
>They look as though they're about to pounce on their prey, until they notice you
>As soon as they do, they both dash in your direction
>You quickly grab them with your dick-magic, lift them into the air, and bash their heads together as hard as you can
>Afterward you toss them hard into a couple of nearby trees, and they fall to the ground motionless

>Scanning the area they were looking at before spottiing you, you find Fluttershy behind a tree, curled up and trembling
"Fluttershy, are you okay!?"
>She had a set of claw marks across her face; not deep enough to cause any long-term scars or damage, thankfuly
>There was another set of claw marks across her back and cutting into one of her wings
>That wasn't good, now you know she would need some medical attention
>"A.. Anon?"
>You crouch next to Fluttershy and scoop her up into your arms
"You'll be okay Fluttershy, I'll get you out of here!"
>She doesn't respond with words, but a weak attempt at a smile
>She was still really shaken up and seemingly in a good deal of pain, so you ran your happy ass out of the forrest with Fluttershy in your arms
>At least now you know why she never ventured that far into the forrest
>You could deal with threats like timberwolves no problem, but Fluttershy on the other hand...
>She didn't really seem capable of defending herself at all
>So why did she even go looking for you anyway?
>You'll be sure to give her shit about that later
>Eventually you make it out of the forrest
>You sprint around P0nyville toward the hospital
>Finally you make it inside and hand Fluttershy over to the medical staff
>After a quick look, they tell you both it doesn't look so bad and nothing major seems to have been hit
>You're forced to sit in a waiting room while they take her in and patch her up

>Less than an hour passes by and Fluttershy is brought out in a wheelchair by Nurse Redheart
>A wheelchair, really?
>Whatever, at least she seemed okay
>Her cuts had been cleaned and bandaged up, and her wings were wrapped up too, preventing her from flying
>Fluttershy only manages to smile at you again as she comes through the door
"How is she Redheart?"
>"She'll be just fine Anonymous, she just won't be able to fly for a while. She seems to have twisted one of her ankles too, hence the wheelchair."
>Makes sense now of course
>"We'll have a nurse come to Fluttershy's home each day to help her around and check up on her. It should only be required for two or three days though."
"I'm glad to hear it, guess she really dodged a bullet there."
>You soon wheel Fluttershy out of the hospital and back to her home
>Once there, you fix up some dinner for her
>The two of you sat down to eat before you break the silence
"Fluttershy, why didn't you go back home? Why did you follow me deeper into the forrest?"
>She lowers her head and looks away from you
>"I, was.. worried, Anon, I didn't want you to go alone, I-"
"That was foolish Fluttershy! I told you I could take care of myself, you should have just gone home! But, I commend your courage."
>"But, I.. also wanted to make sure you got the herbs, and-"
"Well, I got them. So don't worry, about anything. Just eat and rest for now so you can heal up."

>Fluttershy responds by raising her head back up and smiling
>To think that somep0ny like her was worried enough about you to put herself in danger
>She really was completely selfless, and the embodiment of kindness
>After dinner you take the dishes from the table and go to clean them up in the kitchen
>When you're done, you turn around to see Fluttershy standing behind you, her front-right hoof raised up
>You drop down to your knees in front of her and carefuly grab the wrapped-up hoof
"You shouldn't be walking Fluttershy, thi-"
>You're cut off as she stands up on her hind legs and embraces you in a tight hug
>Well, didn't see this one coming
>"Thank you Anon, for everything.. I.. I...."
>Sounds like she tried to mumble something, but instead she's sobbing
"Fluttershy, you're the most caring and selfless p0ny I know, always caring more about others than yourself. Returning the favor is the least I can do." you say as you return the hug
>You two enjoy each-others embrace for a couple minutes until she finally calms down and breaks the hug
>"Come join me for a while before you leave. If that's okay.."
"Uh.. yeah, sure."
>Fluttershy hobbles over to her living room and takes a seat on her couch
>You follow and take a seat next to her, curious as to what she's up to
"Was there.. something you wanted?"
>"You used some kind of magic back in the forrest, right? How did you do it?"

"Oh, that. Well, you see... Something happened a couple nights ago that gave me this ability. I don't really know much else, but I gotta say it's pretty awesome."
>"Oh? What happened?"
"Lyra cast some kind of ridiculous spell on me, and gave me some of her power or something, I don't really know. Just some part of her testing I guess. I'm not complaining."
>"That's really interesing, I've never heard of spells like that before... Do you.. mind showing me?"
>Weeeellllll shit
>You do have a certain spell at your disposal, so what harm could it do?
"I, uh.. well, sure, but it's kind of.. awkward."
>"Awkward? How so?"
*sigh* "Let me just show you. Try not to freak out."
>With that, you levitate a couple books off the coffee table in front of the couch you two were sitting on
>Fluttershy looks on in awe as you dance the books around in the air mindlessly
>"Well, I don't see what's so awkward abo- eep!"
>Yeah, the 'eep' was her turning to look at you and noticing a glowing buldge in your pants
"Now do you understand?"
>Her eyes had widened and face turned a deep pink
"I guess the magic needed some part of me to take up the role of a unicorn horn, and.. well, I guess my dick was the most appropriate. I didn't make the call, but again, not complaining."
>"Oh my, that's.. very, interesting, Anon."
>Her eyes weren't so wide anymore, but they were still fixed on a certain something
"Fluttershy, you're staring."

>"Oh, I'm sorry! I didn't mean, to, umm.."
>Her eyes aren't moving...
>Wait, what are you worried about?
>This is as good a chance as you're gonna get, might as well take it
"Fluttershy, if you want to see it, you just have to ask."
>Her eyes widen once more as she looks directly at yours
>"I- wha, what? Oh, I- I, didn't- I mean, I.. but.." she stutters
"I'm not hearing a noooo." you say, giving her a sly grin
>"W- well, I.. guess, so.."
>Damn she was cute like this
>It feels like you would retain the erection if you stop the magic, but you decide to keep it going just in case
>Leaning back into the couch and casualy placing both hands behind your head, you use the magic to unzip your pants, revealing your erect glowing schlong
>After a few more moments of staring, she stands up and looks to you
>You can see her tail begin to rise, and the blush on her face getting even deeper
>"Anon, can.. can I.. have you, inside me, if.. if that's okay?"
>Mother of god, she actually did want you
>She stuttered the hell out of what she just said, but you were surprised that she even attempted it
>Again, you admired her newfound courage
"I'd like nothing more." you say with a smile "But can you promise to keep this a secret? Just between you and me?"
>"Well, I suppose so.. I think one time is enough, as a token of my appreciation for what you did for me."
>She seemed sincere, but could you trust her?

>Could you trust any mare's promise for that matter?
>If anything ever slipped out down the road, things could go south real quick
>The thought of wiping this moment from her memory actually hurt, but you needed insurrance, and that was the only real way you were going to get it
>Your train of thought stops there, as you make your way back to reality
"Okay Fluttershy, come here."
>You proceed to unbutton your pants and take them off along with your boxers
>Fluttershy steps over you and places her two front hooves on the back of the couch, on either side of you
>Luckily her sprained ankle didn't seem to bother her much
>Her lower half was slightly trembling from nervousness as she positioned it over yours
"Don't be afraid. Just let go, and enjoy yourself." you say as she turns her gaze to you
>Her face is just inches from yours, and you're staring into each other's eyes
>Before she has time to react, you lean forward and plant your lips on hers
>Her mouth opens, and your tongue begins it's assault on hers
>As you expected, she's very submissive here
>It was a good distraction for her though, as her lower half calms down
>Slowly, she lowers her wet marehood over your erect, still glowing member
>You weren't even levitating those books anymore, you were just trying to keep some magic flowing to see if it felt any different
>The anticipation was killing you, but eventually she lowered herself onto you

>Fluttershy breaks your kiss and eeps as her marehood begins to consume your member
>She continues to take you in, lowering more and more until you hilt
>You could feel her muscles tightening around you
>She was very wet, and very warm
>Come to think of it, she was a lot warmer than Lyra, but maybe that's because of the magic?
>"Oh, Anon, you're so.. warm!" she somehow manages to say
>Yeah, must be the magic
>Awesome, this magic dick of yours just keeps getting better!
>Slowly, Fluttershy raises back up until just your tip is inside her
>And she moves back down, continuing this motion, gradually picking up the pace
>She lets out constant moans of pleasure, quickly getting more intense as she continues to ride you
>You close your eyes and focus your magic around the action
>Hopefully you'll manage to make things a little more interesting
>Aaaand, whatever you did, it worked
>You've managed to make yourself twice as sensitive
>The pleasure has been doubled!
>Fluttershy has found a good rhythm now
>She's bouncing up and down over your member as she's leaning onto you with her upper half, her head resting next to yours
>This goes on for a few minutes, which is just fantastic for an equine, but a tad mediocre for you
>You can tell she's already almost at her peak, and thanks to your magic, you are too
>The pace of her thrusting quickens, as she pants and moans louder and louder practically right into your ear

>You continue your focus on the magic, trying to get used to whatever the hell you're doing, until you feel her inner muscles begin to spasm, then tighten up even more
>With this you're being taken over the edge, and begin a little upward thrusting of your own
>"Oh, Anon, I'm.. I'm..!" she stutters between moans
"Me- too!"
>"In- inside!"
>You grab her with both hands as you give her your final thrusts, unloading your seed into her hot vice-grip of a marehood
>She really didn't want to spill anything it seemed
>But she had maregasmed at the same time
>As waves of pleasure flowed through the two of you, your combined fluids spilled all over your crotch, thighs, and the couch
>Fluttershy rested on you for a couple minutes, still leaning against you and resting her head next to yours
>When the two of you revert back to normal breathing, she whispers into your ear
>"That, was.. th- thank you, Anon."
>You reach out and grab her in a gentle hug, careful not to touch her wrapped-up wings
>Soon she finally stands up and allows you to pull out of her, spilling even more of her juices from her open marehood
"I'm impressed Fluttershy, never would have thought you'd have that in ya."
>She responds with a simple grin
"Heh, well, I think we should get ourselves cleaned up."
>Fluttershy nods, and you both head to her restroom
>Before long you've both cleaned yourselves up, and you re-acquire your boxers and pants

>You notice Fluttershy having a hard time moving around, keeping her sprained ankle from touching the ground
"I think it's time you got some rest, what do ya think?"
>"Yeah, I'm pretty tired after that." she says softly, as she smiles and looks away
>You walk up and scoop her up in your arms, carrying her into her bedroom and gently laying her down on her bed
>She stretches and gets comfortable before turning and looking to you
>"Will you.. stay with me, tonight?"
>Oh man, that look she's giving you
>That's hard to turn down
"Okay Fluttershy, if you insist."
>She gives you the biggest smile you've ever seen from her
>Not quite Pinkie Pie level, but pretty good nonetheless
"Just let me clean up the mess on the couch and I'll be back in a few."
>She rolls over and curls back up under her blankets
>You go back out into her kitchen and luckily find a good upholstry cleaner, which thankfuly cleans the couch right up
>Good, now hopefully she won't suspect anything
>You head back into her bedroom to find Fluttershy sleeping soundly
>Perfect
>A bulge forms in your pants, as you close your eyes and focus on performing a spell for the first time
>As you conjure up the spell, you begin to hurt... emotionally
>You never thought about it being like this, you were really starting to feel bad for Fluttershy now
>This could have been a very special thing for her, and you were about to completely erase it from her memory

>Just what the hell were you getting yourself into anyway?
>Why did you decide to go through with this?
>Why are you still considering it if your'e already having second thoughts so early in the game?
>It's basically all or nothing right now
>Either you go through with the spell, and your plans, or you leave this amazing night in Fluttershy's memory
>Who knows, maybe she will keep her promise, and you'll still be able to do this for a while
>Even still, it's risky
>If it ever slipped from her, or any other mare you might end up with, you and Dash would be over
>And the thought of that is apparently even more painful
>You finally notice you've began sweating, as you're standing next to Fluttershy's bed debating your next move
>Thinking for just a few more moments, you make your decision
>You already knew what you really wanted, and taking that path was surprisingly less risky
"I'm sorry, Fluttershy." you whisper, as a single tear escapes one of your eyes
>You focus your magic on the spell, doing your best to only erase the part of her memory after the dinner
>When you think you're ready, you cast the spell to the best of your ability
>You see a wave of light-green energy flow over Fluttershy's head for a few moments before dissipating
>Well, that should do it
>Time to take your leave
>And so you do
>You make sure Fluttershy is tucked in and comfortable and turn off all of her lights before heading out and locking up the house for her

>It wasn't terribly late yet, the sun just recently went down
>So you had a moon-lit walk home through P0nyville and back to Sweet Apple Acres
>The little magic you used was more taxing on you than you thought
>When you got home, you gave the family a simple greeting and went straight for bed, anxious and slightly nervous about what the next day would bring you