Guest User

Ivan's colonization

a guest
Jan 4th, 2017
94
0
Never
Not a member of Pastebin yet? Sign Up, it unlocks many cool features!
text 11.78 KB | None | 0 0
  1. Commentary on The Charter, granted by Tsar Ivan Vasil’yevich to Grigorey Stroganov on financial, juridical and trade privileges in the empty lands along the river Kama.
  2.  
  3.  
  4. During the middle of the 16th century Russia – or Muscovy, depending on perspective – made its first serious steps into becoming a powerful regional hegemon and an empire. One of those steps was Ivan the Fourth’s policy of the colonization of Siberia, which until that time used to be primarily settled and controlled by local tribes and some khanates further in the East. The documents which is going to be commented on in this work are a selection of letters from Ivan the Fourth to a very rich and influential Muscovite family of Stroganovs, who were actively involved in the colonization process and had a duty of administrating and protecting the newly colonized realm within their domain.
  5. There are two documents overall, first one written in 1558 and the second one in 1582. Those documents are defined as charters, an official grant of authority from a higher up to subordinate, in this case – from Ivan the Fourth to Stroganovs, his de jure servants. There is a major difference between those two charters, and while both have the same purpose of revealing the authorities’ will, the message in each of them is fundamentally different. First charter represents more of a legislative document rather than anything, and it is more concerned with the description of rights and responsibilities, than with something else. The second one, that of 1582, is effectively a direct order from Ivan to Stroganovs, alongside a reminder of what will happen to them if they disobey, and it suggests an immediate action, as opposed to a strategic direction shown in the charter of 1558.
  6. When we look at the context of the first charter, it is important to look upon it in a historical context. Written and received in 1558, it shares the same date of Ivan’s beginning of the unfortunate for Russia conquest of the Livonian Order, mere four months after the declaration of war. It also marks the first serious and successful attempts of Russian colonization, which had begun to the north-east of Perm, one of the largest regions of the contemporary Russia. At that period, Russia had not yet been impoverished by the failures of the Livonian war and Oprichnina’s chaos, and while it had suffered some economic damage after the conquest of Kazan, its economy was rather stable and capable of supporting the expansion into the Siberia, and as shown in both charters, protection of its borders against most threats coming from Siberian Khanate and other local powers. Nonetheless, the first major efforts of the colonization have been carried out by the family of Stroganovs: Grigorey and Yakov Stroganovs, older and younger brothers accordingly. Stroganovs had been a relatively new clan of merchants, with the father of Grigorey and Yakov Stroganovs – Anikey Stroganov – being the man who had brought the fame and wealth to the family’s name. Like many exploration campaigns in the Western countries at that time, such as England or Spain, the state in Russia had not been willing to fully supply the colonization process and the prime responsibility, as well as the most of wealth in case of success, had been given to people like Stroganovs, who had offered their services to the crown at the right time. Grigorey Stroganov was the first man in the family to receive a charter from Ivan the Fourth to be responsible for the colonization and fortification of newly acquired lands on the bank of the river Kama, on the borders between Perm and the rest of the modern Ural region. Grigorey had received a substantial amount of an unsettled land – 88 versts, or approximately 100 km2, even though initially Grigorey had requested 146 versts of land. This land was rich with resources such as wood and fish, and as it was speculated, with various ores and salt pans. The main issue with that was that, as seen in the charter, Stroganovs had to fortify this area with a stronghold with stationed ‘gunners, musketeers and artillery men’, in order to protect it from the ‘Nagay people and other hordes’. On the other hand, Stroganovs had been granted a variety of unique rights and benefits, such as:
  7. The right to be exempt from all kinds of taxation (besides the trade tax) for 20 years;
  8. The right to be independent from any local authority besides that of Ivan himself;
  9. The right to work the forests, salt pans, precious ores (with a permission from the crown) as well as fish and hunt;
  10. The right to accept any untaxed and unregistered people to settle in the colony;
  11. The right to be free from obligations to supply any other expeditions into the Siberia.
  12. This list of rights is a product of a rather intelligent and balanced strategy of Ivan and his court towards colonization – the state is not losing anything by permitting Stroganovs to work on those lands, since no taxes had been payed from them in the past anyway, and taxing newly established colonies would only damage their growth and reduce any possible profits in the future. At the same time, by establishing that Ivan’s authority is the only one to command the Stroganovs would ensure an absolute control over their intentions, albeit not so much over their actions, as will be seen in the analysis of the second charter. Finally, the reason why only those who are untaxed and unregistered could move to Stroganovs’ lands lies within the issue of tax evasion, and the state’s natural fear that people from around Russia would flock to those territories hoping to escape the taxation, thus causing state to lose money.
  13. Stroganovs’ main responsibilities, besides that of defending the lands from the enemies, had included the aforementioned prohibition of accepting any taxed and registered migrants, the possession of supplies in case of the Tsar’s men’s need, and most importantly Stroganovs’ obedience to Ivan’s orders and obligations, or else the charter would be proclaimed to be void.
  14. When we look at the overall picture of the colonization of Siberia, with regards to this charter, it fits the general narrative on how states perceived colonization at the time. Those who are willing to take the duty of expanding the realm are facing both the great risk and the great reward in case of success, and the kind of risks Stroganovs were taking is vividly pictured in the second charter of 1582, from Ivan the Fourth to Maksim and Nikita Stroganovs – descendants of Yakov and Grigorey.
  15. This charter, as mentioned earlier, carries a different message. Through this document, Ivan expresses his extreme dissatisfaction with Stroganovs’ control over their own Cossacks, hired by them earlier to act as the guardsmen of the realm. The year of 1582 is very relevant to the contents of the charter because of two key events: Russia was on the brink of defeat in the Livonian War, and therefore there was an influx of armed men for hire, searching for a better opportunity to sell their services all throughout Russia, such as Yermak. He, the head of a small group of Cossacks – mounted light cavalry, – was responsible for keeping Stroganovs’ towns and keeps on the frontline safe from the never-ending raids of Siberian clans. Later, he would be the one to greatly expand Russian territorial possessions in Siberia, however in 1582 he was the reason for the Tsar’s anger at Stroganovs, since he and his men made significant mistakes: Firstly, they have attacked the nearby loyal to Russia clans with or without the consent from Stroganovs, secondly, they have ignored their duties of protecting the frontlines, and therefore they were absent when the Voguls have ravaged Cherdyn, a city of Perm. While the Tsar was threating both the Stroganovs and the Cossacks with severe punishments, one could argue that there was little the state could do about groups such as Cossacks – especially on the frontier, where they could easily go rogue, and not during a devastating war. Considering that Stroganovs retained their authority two years later, as seen through the existence of the last charter to Stroganovs of 1584, it is safe to conclude that they have managed to settle the situation in the manner which had pleased Ivan.
  16. Those documents are all written in Russian language, and the style of each of those documents is a formal, juridical one, as expected from a charter granted by the authorities. They come from Ivan directly, and even though the actual writers were Ivan’s secretaries such as Petr Grigor’yev and other administrative staff members, there is little doubt that Ivan had at least dictated the idea of those charters himself. The reason why they were written is to manage and control Stroganovs’ actions in Siberia, as well as either limit or expand their rights and responsibilities when it best suits the interests of the state. Since those documents have been recovered from the Stroganovs’ archives, one can assume that they had a grand meaning for the contemporary Stroganov family, since they have confirmed and legitimized their rights to not only administrate the land given to them, but also to exert power against the surrounding enemies. Being a document of such high juridical authority it is unlikely that it can be biased on the administrative and legislative levels, and there is no reason to suggest that those are fake or have been amended. However, the charter of 1582 only shows Ivan’s reaction towards events regarding Stroganovs, and it is unknown for sure what happened in 1582, and whether the Cossacks have attacked the locals on behalf of Stroganovs, or if they went rogue and Stroganovs had no control over their actions, with the Tsar assuming the former. While the charters were important to Stroganovs, they are also very informative to the historians, since it allows to trace the developments of Siberian expansion, the growth of Stroganov family’s powers and authority, the relationship between the government and the new realm, and even the struggle between the colonists and the local tribes, and how those conflicts have been handled. One very interesting detail is that nowhere in any of those two charters there is a mentioning of the Church or the religion itself, for example it is not specified that only Christians were allowed to settle on Stroganovs lands, or that those who attacked the lands of Perm later on were heretics or infidels. The aspect of religious belonging was an important factor in both diplomatic, political and legal documents before, during and after those charters, and it usually showed the relationship between the state and the matter addressed. The reason for that could either be that it was decided to sacrifice religious issues for the productivity in colonization efforts, or that the Church did not regard this stage of colonization as worthy of interfering.
  17.  
  18. In the end, Ivan’s charters to Stroganovs paint a very interesting picture regarding the troubles of the Russian colonization of Siberia, and the reasons behind such colonization in the first place. It shows that the colonization itself was not done by the state, but rather by the individuals with bright personalities, such as Stroganovs or Yermak himself. As opposed to the West European countries’ colonization of the Americas, Africa and Asia, the Siberian expansion was both harder and easier for Russia in some aspects. Russia had no competitors for the land besides local tribes and khanates which stood no chance of an organized resistance against a clever mix of diplomatic efforts and well-equipped men with firearms, however the land itself was hard to conquer and even harder to hold, with the bulk of efforts laying on the shoulders of the colonists themselves, those who govern, protect and work. Consequently, the documents show an informative view of the Russian handling of colonization, the role of state and the people, and finally what was expected to be achieved.
Advertisement
Add Comment
Please, Sign In to add comment