Tips for myself when judging domination maps.

5 Things to Always focus on when reviewing domination maps:

1. Focus on game play, is it generic? does it work? is it cramped? is it unique?

2. Style, does the map look good? is it visually appealing?

3. Alignment, alignment is very important, always make sure maps are aligned, especially make sure they're aligned if the map is meant to be symmetrical.

4. Decorations! Does it have decorations? decorations are a big part to making a map look better.

5. If all of these things check out then test it in a live domination room, it's also important to see how it does as the real thing!


Other things:


Are the flags out of place?

Is there not enough flags / too many flags?

Is the map fair for both sides?

Is everything within the screen and not out of screen?

Is the map fun?

Are the flags separated well? so it encourages whole map gameplay?

Are the grounds too low / too high?
Remember, tell them how the map is  bad but don't forget what's good about it and how they can improve.

> [en] [Shamousey] I think there's a few more precise/picky things you could mention in reviews but they're fine honestly.
So be a little more precise in reviews (:

Also make sure that you re-read your reviews before posting