pirate rewards

The rewards John Spearow offers are as follows:

6000 potch
A vitamin of your choice

And two of:

4000 more Potch (once per character)
Another vitamin
A pirate-themed weapon for your character (can be previewed before you confirm, but I'm not just gonna make a bunch of weapons without knowing if you want one :V)
A pirate themed TM from: (Pillage, Cannons Away, X Marks the Spot, Cursed Treasure)
An alchemy reagent (Gold Doubloon, Weapons Grade Ravarran Rum, Iridescent Chatot Feather, or Sarangan Silk. You don't know what effects these have)
A standard, buyable Held Item from the book.